Wikipedia:WikiProject Cats/Peer review/Odd-eyed cat

Odd-eyed cat
I've recently written this article about odd-eyed cats and I would like to know what information needs to be added and how it can be improved. Thanks. --Candy-Panda 10:37, 6 February 2007 (UTC)


 * Please see automated peer review suggestions here. Thanks, APR t 20:36, 6 February 2007 (UTC)


 * You mention that they are popular among the Japanese, but that is the only cultural reaction you have. Is there any folklore in any countries about odd-eyed cats?  Goldfritha 02:51, 7 February 2007 (UTC)
 * Excellent idea! I've now added a "cultural reactions and folklore" section. --Candy-Panda 04:32, 7 February 2007 (UTC)


 * I would suggest perhaps adding a section towards the discovery and early mentions of odd-eyed cats and perhaps some mentions of the genes history with breeders. user:Editor125637373737353 10:28, 4 May 2020 (UTC)

A mcmurray
At a first glance:
 * Cool concept, interesting. I added your intitial fact to the Did You Know nominations for the date of creation, Feb. 3. You'll have to cite that fact quickly as the article can only be 5 days old or less to be featured on DYK.
 * Clean up the references section, check Citing sources and these templates.
 * Also may want to look at Reliable sources.

My more thorough edit, changes, adds and removals (all of which are reversible per user discrimination):
 * Add fact tag where applicable
 * Inserted hidden comment(s) looking for more detail.
 * Minor rewording of caption.
 * Minor word removal, ex:perfectly contradicted by a stat right after it.
 * Other minor copy editing details.

If interested I have an article up for peer review here. Hope that helps.A mcmurray 07:05, 7 February 2007 (UTC)

Auroranorth

 * I do not think you need so many pictures of odd-eyed cats. This clutters up the article and makes it look unprofessional, in my opinion.
 * The lead section needs improvement. I would suggest keeping the current information but then going on further 'The condition is caused by a genetic disorder. Turkey considers this type of cat to be a national treasure,' or something to that effect.
 * The external links section needs capitalisation and the wikifying has not been done correctly.
 * The kittens section could be merged with the cause section.

Thanks for your interest in developing good articles.

You may like to look at the Good Article criteria and the Featured Article criteria if you wish to go further with this article. You could also use Manx (cat) as an example. Auroranorth (sign) 13:47, 2 November 2007 (UTC)