Wikipedia:WikiProject Clans of Scotland/Cleanup listing

About this listing
The listing is based on a database snapshot of 2010-03-12. It contains all articles flagged for cleanup which are tagged with WikiProject Clans of Scotland on their talk page.

Based on that data, 478 articles are assigned to this project, of which 173, or 36.2%, are flagged for cleanup.

The following quality assessment classes were evaluated for this report:

The following importance assessment classes were evaluated for this report:

A-Class articles
The project has 1 A-Class articles. None of them is flagged for cleanup.

Good articles
The project has 5 good articles. None of them is flagged for cleanup.

Top-importance articles
The project has 13 top-importance articles. 9 of them, or 69.2%, are flagged for cleanup.

High-importance articles
The project has 21 high-importance articles. 11 of them, or 52.4%, are flagged for cleanup.

Further entries (summary)
Detail listing is suppressed due to size restrictions.

Accuracy disputes

 * Clan Cumming (Dec 2008)

Articles lacking in-text citations

 * Battle of Glentaisie (Apr 2009)
 * Battle of the Pass of Brander (Apr 2009)
 * Battle of the Shirts (Apr 2009)
 * Clan Keith (Apr 2009)
 * Clan Leslie (May 2009)
 * Scottish clan (May 2009) «Top»
 * Laird (Jun 2009) «High»

Articles lacking reliable references

 * Clan Cumming (Dec 2008)

Articles lacking sources

 * Lorne Maclaine (Jan 2007)
 * Clan Bannerman (Apr 2007)
 * Clan Maclaine of Lochbuie (Apr 2007)
 * Collectanea de Rebus Albanicis (Apr 2007)
 * Clan Irvine (Jul 2007)
 * George Campbell, 6th Duke of Argyll (Jul 2007)
 * Clan Rose (Dec 2007)
 * Chiefs of McGhie (Feb 2008)
 * Clan Hall (Apr 2008)
 * Clan Stewart of Appin (Apr 2008)
 * Clan Udny (Apr 2008)
 * Campbell of Craignish (May 2008)
 * Colin Campbell, 1st Earl of Argyll (May 2008)
 * Archibald Napier, 1st Lord Napier (Jun 2008)
 * Clan Durie (Jun 2008)
 * Clan Macnab (Jul 2008)
 * Clan Malcolm (Jul 2008)
 * Clan Boyle (Aug 2008)
 * Clan Hannay (Aug 2008)
 * Clan Makgill (Aug 2008)
 * Clan Matheson (Aug 2008)
 * Colin Campbell, 3rd Earl of Argyll (Aug 2008)
 * Clan Ramsay (Sep 2008)
 * John Campbell, 4th Duke of Argyll (Sep 2008)
 * Archibald Campbell, 3rd Duke of Argyll (Oct 2008)
 * Alexander Fraser, 19th Lord Saltoun (Apr 2009)
 * Alexander Fraser, 20th Lord Saltoun (Apr 2009)
 * Archibald Campbell, 2nd Earl of Argyll (Apr 2009)
 * Clan Maitland (Apr 2009)
 * Colin Campbell, 6th Earl of Argyll (Apr 2009)
 * Francis Napier, 10th Lord Napier (Apr 2009)
 * Lord Fraser (Apr 2009)
 * Simon Fraser, Master of Lovat (Apr 2009)
 * Thomas Fraser, 10th Lord Lovat (Apr 2009)
 * MacDonald of Glencoe (Jun 2009)
 * William de Graham (Aug 2009)
 * Archibald Campbell Fraser of Lovat (Dec 2009)
 * Ian Campbell, 12th Duke of Argyll (Dec 2009)
 * John Campbell, 5th Duke of Argyll (Dec 2009)
 * Maclean of Duart (Dec 2009)
 * Simon Fraser of Lovat (Dec 2009)

Articles needing additional references

 * Clan Borthwick (Aug 2007)
 * Clan Fergusson (Sep 2007)
 * Clan Cumming (Oct 2007)
 * Clan Guthrie (Oct 2007)
 * Clan Kerr (Nov 2007)
 * Clan Turnbull (Nov 2007)
 * Clan Davidson (Dec 2007)
 * Clan Macnaghten (Dec 2007)
 * Clan Shaw of Tordarroch (Dec 2007)
 * Clan Stewart (Dec 2007) «High»
 * Battle of Glenlivet (Jan 2008)
 * Clan MacBain (Feb 2008)
 * Duncan Campbell, 1st Lord Campbell (Feb 2008)
 * Clan Boyd (Jul 2008)
 * Clan Dundas (Jul 2008)
 * Clan Agnew (Aug 2008)
 * Clan Leask (Aug 2008)
 * Clan Macrae (Aug 2008)
 * Clan Elphinstone (Sep 2008)
 * Clan Fergusson (Oct 2008)
 * Clan Hay (Oct 2008)
 * Highland Clearances (Oct 2008) «High»
 * Court of the Lord Lyon (Nov 2008) «High»
 * Battle of Glen Fruin (Dec 2008)
 * Clan Wallace (Jan 2009) «High»
 * Clan Anstruther (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Arbuthnott (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Bannerman (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Barclay (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Boswell (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Broun (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Colquhoun (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Darroch (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Dewar (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Dunbar (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Gordon (Mar 2009) «High»
 * Clan Graham (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Haldane (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Hamilton (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Hope (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Hunter (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Kennedy (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Lennox (Mar 2009)
 * Clan MacCallum (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Macgillivray (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Macpherson (Mar 2009)
 * Clan MacThomas (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Mar (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Menzies (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Moffat (Mar 2009)
 * Kilt (Mar 2009) «Top»
 * Massacre of Glencoe (Mar 2009) «High»
 * Scottish Highlands (Mar 2009) «Top»
 * Clan Davidson (Apr 2009)
 * Clan Jardine (Apr 2009)
 * Clan Maitland (Apr 2009)
 * Archibald Campbell, 1st Marquess of Argyll (May 2009)
 * Clan Morrison (Aug 2009)
 * Clan MacBain (Feb 2010)

Articles needing cleanup

 * Clan Boyd (Jul 2008)
 * Ian Roderick Macneil (Jan 2009)

Articles to be expanded

 * Clan Anstruther (Apr 2007)
 * Fosterage (Oct 2007)
 * Clan Anderson (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Armstrong (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Barclay (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Boswell (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Forbes (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Innes (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Marjoribanks (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Macdonald of Sleat (Jun 2009)
 * Lovat Scouts (Dec 2009)

Articles to be merged

 * Battle of Dingwall (Apr 2009)
 * Battle of Harlaw (Apr 2009)
 * Jewish tartan (May 2009)
 * Scoto-Norman clans (May 2009)
 * Heritable Jurisdictions Act (Jan 2010)

Articles with disputed statements

 * John III Comyn, Lord of Badenoch (Aug 2009)

Articles with obsolete information

 * Battle of Dail-Riabhach

Articles with specifically-marked weasel-worded phrases

 * Battle of Culloden (May 2009) «High»
 * Chief of the Name (May 2009)
 * Clan Campbell (May 2009) «Top»
 * Clan Kennedy (May 2009)
 * Clan Kerr (May 2009)
 * Clan MacTavish (May 2009)
 * Clan Stewart (May 2009) «High»
 * Sept (May 2009) «Top»
 * Slogan (heraldry) (May 2009)
 * Clan Lamont (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Hay (Dec 2009)
 * Clan Strachan (Dec 2009)

Articles with topics of unclear notability

 * Chiefs of McGhie (Dec 2008)
 * Lorne Maclaine (Dec 2008)
 * Clan Udny (Apr 2009)
 * Charles Godfrey McAlester (Sep 2009)
 * Charles Somerville MacAlester (Sep 2009)

Articles with unsourced statements

 * Border Reivers (Feb 2007) «High»
 * Campbell of Strachur (Feb 2007)
 * Chief of the Name (Feb 2007)
 * Clan Kerr (Feb 2007)
 * Simon Fraser, Master of Lovat (Feb 2007)
 * Clan Macnaghten (May 2007)
 * Clan Barclay (Jul 2007)
 * Clan Gordon (Jul 2007) «High»
 * Clan Rose (Jul 2007)
 * Clan MacDuff (Aug 2007)
 * Clan Logan (Sep 2007)
 * Clan Moffat (Nov 2007)
 * Clan Davidson (Dec 2007)
 * Clan Fraser of Lovat (Jan 2008)
 * Clan Kerr (Mar 2008)
 * Clan Mackinnon (Mar 2008)
 * John Campbell, 9th Duke of Argyll (Mar 2008)
 * Clan Cumming (Apr 2008)
 * Battle of Culloden (May 2008) «High»
 * Campbell of Craignish (May 2008)
 * Border Reivers (Jul 2008) «High»
 * Clan Dundas (Jul 2008)
 * Clan Guthrie (Jul 2008)
 * Clan Skene (Jul 2008)
 * Scottish clan (Jul 2008) «Top»
 * Clan Hannay (Aug 2008)
 * Kilt (Aug 2008) «Top»
 * Clan Crawford (Sep 2008)
 * Clan Primrose (Sep 2008)
 * Kilt (Sep 2008) «Top»
 * Border Reivers (Oct 2008) «High»
 * Clan Munro (Oct 2008)
 * Clan Anderson (Nov 2008)
 * List of crest badges used by Scottish clan members (Nov 2008) «Top»
 * List of Scottish clans (Nov 2008) «Top»
 * Battle of Culloden (Dec 2008) «High»
 * Clan Stewart of Appin (Dec 2008)
 * Clan Borthwick (Jan 2009)
 * Clan Durie (Jan 2009)
 * Clan Wallace (Jan 2009) «High»
 * John of Islay, Earl of Ross (Jan 2009)
 * Clan Cochrane (Feb 2009)
 * Clan Hamilton (Feb 2009)
 * Clan Hay (Feb 2009)
 * Colin Campbell, 3rd Earl of Argyll (Feb 2009)
 * Highland Clearances (Feb 2009) «High»
 * Battle of Culloden (Mar 2009) «High»
 * Clan Irvine (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Lyon (Mar 2009)
 * Clan MacNeil (Mar 2009)
 * Clan Macqueen (Mar 2009)
 * Kilt (Mar 2009) «Top»
 * Scoto-Norman clans (Mar 2009)
 * Battle of Littleferry (Apr 2009)
 * Clan Jardine (Apr 2009)
 * Clan MacTavish (Apr 2009)
 * List of Scottish clans (Apr 2009) «Top»
 * Clan Borthwick (May 2009)
 * Clan Donnachaidh (May 2009)
 * Clan Grant (May 2009)
 * Clan Hay (May 2009)
 * Clan Macdonald of Clanranald (May 2009)
 * Clan MacTavish (May 2009)
 * Tartan (May 2009) «Top»
 * Clan Macaulay of Lewis (Jun 2009)
 * Clan Ross (Jun 2009)
 * Clan Stewart (Jun 2009) «High»
 * Clan Wallace (Jun 2009) «High»
 * Alasdair Mòr (Jul 2009)
 * Carter-Campbell of Possil (Jul 2009)
 * Clan Armstrong (Jul 2009)
 * Clan Burnett (Jul 2009)
 * Clan Donald (Jul 2009) «Top»
 * Clan MacAlister (Jul 2009)
 * Clan Macdowall (Jul 2009)
 * Clan Maclean (Jul 2009) «High»
 * Carter-Campbell of Possil (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Borthwick (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Gunn (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Lamont (Aug 2009)
 * Clan MacBain (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Mackay (Aug 2009) «High»
 * Clan Maitland (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Swinton (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Urquhart (Aug 2009)
 * William de Graham (Aug 2009)
 * Clan Elphinstone (Sep 2009)
 * Clan Keith (Sep 2009)
 * Clan Donnachaidh (Oct 2009)
 * Simon Fraser, 16th Lord Lovat (Oct 2009)
 * Clan Morrison (Nov 2009)
 * Clan Campbell (Dec 2009) «Top»
 * Campbell of Craignish (Jan 2010)
 * Clan Graham (Jan 2010)
 * Clan MacNeil (Jan 2010)
 * Kilt (Jan 2010) «Top»
 * Simon Fraser, 15th Lord Lovat (Jan 2010)

Articles with weasel words

 * Clan Lyon (Mar 2009)
 * Highland Clearances (May 2009) «High»

NPOV disputes

 * John III Comyn, Lord of Badenoch (Aug 2009)

Orphaned articles

 * Scoto-Norman clans (Feb 2009)

Unreferenced BLPs

 * Katharine Fraser, Mistress of Saltoun (Aug 2009)

Wikipedia articles needing clarification

 * Kilt (Sep 2008) «Top»
 * Clan Calder (Feb 2009)
 * Scottish clan (Feb 2009) «Top»
 * Massacre of Glencoe (May 2009) «High»
 * Clan Mackay (Aug 2009) «High»
 * Massacre of Glencoe (Aug 2009) «High»
 * Battle of Drumchatt (Nov 2009)
 * Kilt (Jan 2010) «Top»

Wikipedia articles needing copy edit

 * Battle of Drumnacoub (Apr 2009)