Wikipedia:WikiProject Discographies/Noticeboard

Welcome to the Discographies WikiProject Noticeboard! Post any requests for discography articles here, and use this space for any other discussions regarding discography-related articles on Wikipedia in general. Please post under the appropriate headline, or create a new one if this is needed.

Joshua Groban discography
I noticed on Josh's discography it says 2010 album Illuminations is US Platinum - Platinum requires 1,000,000 sales but US sales are shown as 803,000. Could someone please correct the sales figure to accurate current number which apparently is over 1 million. Finding this figure is out of my area of expertise. Thanks.

Omar Rodríguez-López discography
Hey there, I noticed that Omar's discography he is listed as a producer on all the Mars Volta albums instead of it being under studio albums. Should it not be under both? As well, none of the At the Drive-In or De Facto albums are listed, is there a reason for this? Thanks --Skifreak16 (talk) 21:57, 29 March 2011 (UTC)

The Carpenters discography
Hello, would somebody mind helping me to get this discography to FL status? Thanks. – Obento Musubi (C • G • S) 19:36, 24 May 2008 (UTC)

Foo Fighters discography
I have started work on this. Once I have finished the prosy (cite rich) intro para, I'll start on the tables. Tenacious D Fan (talk) 10:16, 21 April 2008 (UTC)

Peer review request
I've requested a peer review of The Smiths discography and Morrissey discography with a view to taking them to WP:FLC. Any comments would be appreciated. Review pages are Peer review/The Smiths discography/archive1 and Peer review/Morrissey discography/archive1 respectively. Thanks --JD554 (talk) 12:51, 10 July 2008 (UTC)

Article assessment
hey guys, was just wondering if anybody could re-assess the Phil Collins discography? have been making lots of changes and improvements over the past few days and i know there is still work to be done but just wanted some opinions for improvements and if they think the article is heading in the right direction. thanks :) Mister sparky (talk) 14:50, 2 September 2009 (UTC)

Website sources
I've started a discussion over at WP:CHARTS about which charts should be used in a featured list (I wasn't too sure where to put it so i put it there). I would love if some of you guys would come over and help me out. You can find it under Wikipedia talk:Record charts. Thanks! --SteelersFanUK06  HereWeGo2010!   00:30, 23 January 2010 (UTC)

Bon Jovi Discography page
I have been doing extreme work on the Bon Jovi discography page. Before all my work, the wiki was graded a C-Class Discography. Surely it is now worth a level upgrade? Everything has been reliably sourced and set out properly. I have also included information on the page regarding music videos, promo releases and world album sales, as well as a re-write of the page intro and video release section. Savvi72 (talk) 17:41, 23 January 2010 (UTC)

Isaac Hayes Discography page
"(Theme From) Shaft" never reached #1 on Billboard's R&B chart. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%26B_number-one_hits_of_1971_(USA) and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%26B_number-one_hits_of_1972_(USA).

Buddy Holly Discography (References Needed)
I noticed that on the Buddy Holly discography features no references for anything. Because Buddy Holly is one of the most famous artist in Rock and roll the references are badly needed. Rock&#39;N&#39;More (talk) 22:56, 19 August 2010 (UTC)

Help setting up a Discography for a record label
I am working on setting a discography for a independent classical music label that specializes in recording pipe organs. Could someone give me guidance in setting up a chart? Much of what I have read pertains to major artists with their chart listing. This label has no chart listing.

The information they would like to document is:
 * 1) Numbered list item Catalog Number
 * 2) Numbered list item Year of issue
 * 3) Numbered list item Artist
 * 4) Numbered list item Title of the CD
 * 5) Numbered list item Name of Venue with the Pipe Organ
 * 6) Numbered list item The builder of the pipe organ

Is it acceptable to link to their website for each release or should there be only one listing of their website in the header of the article?

Thank you --Aristide1811 (talk) 13:42, 1 April 2012 (UTC) HELP NEEDED FOR SETTING UP DISCOGRAPHY FOR RANINA REDDY PAGE

Discography Details of Singer Ranina Reddy - Indian Play Back Singer The Discography is a Table containing all Details about the songs Sung by the Particular Singer. This is a Must Table for all Indian Playback singers and this exists for all Singers. Please allow me to add details to the Table as they all have proofs and its based on true reference... The same is getting edited and deleted daily by other editors. The Table Contains details like Year, Language, Name of the Song. Vithurgod (talk) 05:04, 14 April 2012 (UTC)


 * Pls approve adding All details for Discography for an Indian Singer... Am waiting for a Conscensus in this 122.174.105.102 (talk) 17:35, 15 April 2012 (UTC)

Christina Perri Discography
Please add Germany (GER) to the Singles table. Peak chart position of "Jar of Hearts" = 5. Reference. Thanks!

Lesley Gore Discography
Hello Wikipedias, Thank you for reading my entry and considering my request to re-enstate deleted album pages. Background: On 8/26/2018 I devoted over 8 hours of personal time to creating and curating new pages for missing Lesley Gore albums. My efforts are in support to improving Wikipedia's collection of discography, which Wikipedia defines as the study and cataloging of published sound recordings, often by specified artists or within identified musical genres. Issue: Within only a few hours I was sent the following message. "Thank you for your contributions. I have redirected several of the pages you created as they did not satisfy Wikipedia's notability criteria for albums to have a solo article. Please do not remove these redirects unless you can demonstrate that the articles pass the notability standards, which in this case would be significant coverage in secondary sources that are independent of the subject. Notability is not inherited, and there was a reason the albums did not have pages. If you have any questions, please let me know. Cheers, Etzedek24 (I'll talk at ya) (Check my track record) 01:43, 27 August 2018 (UTC)" Objection:I have read the notability stipulations for albums. I disagree with the actions taken to redirect the pages I added. These pages are intended as an aid to persons researching the recording catalogue of Lesley Gore, a notable American female musician. Ms. Gore recorded 13 studio albums. These releases are well documented by title and relate date and many are still available for purchase or download via Amazon, iTunes, or other digital streaming services. The album pages I created "Lesley Gore Sings All About Love", "Love Me By Name", "The Canvas Can Do Miracles" are all verifiable releases by Ms Gore and can be found listed in a number of websites (i.e., DISCOGS, ALLMUSIC, AMAZON, etc.) Further, the album artwork and audio track recordings can be found both Google and Youtube. Resolution: I request the pages I created to be restored and all the links repaired. Otherwise, my hours of voluntary work researching and documenting song titles, their composers, and the track running times are no more; the will remain simply deleted because they were deemed not notable enough to have a dedictaed page. Given that Wikipedia deems Discography of the Resident Evil video game series notable enough to have a dedicated page then why not all 13 studio albums by Ms. Gore? Remember the goal of adding the pages today is to improve Wikipedia's collection of discography. T.C.Parker (talk • contribs)