Wikipedia:WikiProject Martial arts/Article Review

This page holds the list of articles currently been reviewed to decide if they can be improved or sent for deletion. This is to clear out the backlog of subs and separate the advertisements and non-notable ones from those that are seeds that an article can be grown from. We have a weekly list of around 20 articles generated with the CatScan tool. For each article, we aim to flag as good those stubs that can be improved, blatantly useless those that can be speedily deleted, and the less clear-cut ones can be sent to AfD for a broader community view.

Please read the articles and search for sources, then add a comment saying what you have found, including any sources (please add these to the article too!) and with a recommendation (Speedy/Improve/AfD). In the case of 'speedies' please tag the article, too. This is not a vote, so please look at ones that have not been reviewed first.

At the end of the week (Wednesday), we tie it off by tidying up the 'improves,' nominating the 'AfDs,' and checking in on the 'speedies.'

Weekly list
Generated with the CatScan tool.

Left overs
Articles that are still under debate from past weeks.


 * Ebrahim Ghaderi: Iranian taekwondo practitioners, Martial arts biography stubs; Notability
 * Weak AfD Winner of a single international medal (1986 Asian games). I don't think that's quite enough, but others have disagreed. Papaursa (talk) 23:20, 23 July 2010 (UTC)


 * Enbukan: Japanese martial arts, Koryu bujutsu; Notability


 * Ernesto Presas: Filipino eskrimadors, Martial arts biography stubs; Notability


 * Fight Zone USA: Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu; Notability

Requested Reviews
Articles someone has posted on the Project talk page etc that need some extra eyes on.

To Do

 * Scouting: Look over the shorter MA articles (CatScan) and mark candidates with 'notability' tag.
 * Send past weeks' articles (with two afd comments) to afd (use good faith judgement).
 * Tag oldest, reviewed articles with