Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/Peer review/List of orders, decorations and medals of the Republic of China

List of orders, decorations and medals of the Republic of China
This is my first WP:FLC hopeful. Not sure if any of you guys are familiar with the quirks and habits of the powers that be who control FL ascension, but I'll try here anyway. (It's within our scope, right?) I'm about a half done with this article, which lists all the military and civilian awards of the ROC. I sort of followed the format of List of Canadian provincial and territorial orders (which isn't much) and did some table-pushing (not too complex) and got a fairly respectable (IMHO) semi-complete list here. I'm submitting this PR since I'll be finishing the rest of the article fairly soon and the new sections will be very similar to the current layout. Then I can submit it for FLC as soon as I finish the article and make changes (if any) based on you guys' suggestion. I'm already using the tag for notes since I had to have a way of saying long-ish sentences about certain objects, so I had to resort to using the archaic reference system. (Outline, as opposed to inline :D) -- Миборо в ский 05:59, 28 August 2006 (UTC)

Kirill Lokshin
I have no experience with FLC in particular, so I'm not sure what the quirks are there; but looking at existing FLs suggests that the general idea is correct. A few comments about the list itself: Other than that, this looks very good so far; please post an update when the other sections are filled out! Kirill Lokshin 09:14, 28 August 2006 (UTC)
 * None of the titles are linked; I would have thought that many of these orders have (or could have) their own articles. Is that not the case?
 * The "Picture" column might be renamed to something like "Badge", to make it clearer what the image is.
 * This might be resolved if a separate article is created, but it's not at all clear what the different numbers of lions refer to on the saber; a footnote might be helpful here.


 * Actually, at the moment only one of the awards have an article. :( The rest would show up as red links, and an article full of bold red links would be uglier than one full of bold black text but no red link. When done with this article, I will create stubs for all of the awards listed. (Probably)
 * Noted and changed.
 * Noted and changed.
 * -- Миборо в ский 18:30, 28 August 2006 (UTC)

Grafikm_fr
Trying to compile an FLC myself, I studied the question a bit and your list is very nice. However, people might have two potential quibbles:
 * Sources for the date of institution (you have to source it one at the table header if the source is the same).
 * The number awarded if the information is available somewhere (I have no idea whether if it's compulsory though...)

Otherwise, I'm looking for this one to hit FLC, it really interests me!!! -- Grafikm  (AutoGRAF)  12:16, 28 August 2006 (UTC)


 * As I'm using the inline footnotes system for article/list notes, I can't (or shouldn't) mix up the references and the notes. So I did the next best thing, created a note and on it telling the reader to look at the references section for the reference. :/ Not sure if that'll work though.
 * I tried to, and could only find the number for one of the awards on the list. Though I'll be looking out for these figures when finishing up this list. -- Миборо в ский 18:30, 28 August 2006 (UTC)