Wikipedia:WikiProject United States Public Policy/Assessment/Article Feedback Tool Assessment

This group of assessments is comparing your detailed article quality assessment to the results of the new Article Feedback Tool. These assessments will also be used to measure overall improvement in article quality over the course of the project.


 * Again, please use the quantitative metric described on the Assessment page.
 * Again, if you feel good about your assessment, go ahead and update the rating on the article's talk page, if another reviewer hasn't already done so.
 * Ideally, there will be 3-5 assessments for each article on this list, which means that each team member will assess approximately 10 articles.
 * If possible, please assess the requested articles within 2 weeks.
 * For this assessment, please assess as many and whichever articles you choose from the list below. (Again each articles needs at 3-5 assessments and each reviewer will assess approximately 10 articles, but you all know Amy is a data nerd and would love more data if you are motivated.)
 * The articles links below all link to the version on 1 November 2010.
 * If all of the assessments have been completed, please choose a different article to assess.
 * Please add "(done)" in the header of a review once it's been done so other reviewers can easily see what still needs to be worked on from the TOC.

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:04, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 3/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:19, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 0/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 3/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 16:36, Thursday November 4, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 0/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 3/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:28, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 0/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 3/26

Reviewer 5 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 17:03, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 2/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 0/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 5/26

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:16, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 8/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 18/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 22:18, Thursday November 4, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 7/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 18/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:19, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 8/10

Sourcing: 3.5/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 18.5/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:22, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 3/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 11/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 22:31, Thursday November 4, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 0/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 3/26

Reviewer 3 (Done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 18:07, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 2/6

Sourcing 3/6

Neutrality 3/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 3/3

Illustrations 0/2

Total 13/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:26, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 2.5/6

Neutrality: 2.5/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 13/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date: (UTC)09:14, 23 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 10/26

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:19, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 7/10

Sourcing 3/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 14/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 22:41, Thursday November 4, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 3 (Done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 18:14, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 7/10

Sourcing 4/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 15/26

Reviewer 4 (Done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 04:15, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 10/26

Reviewer 5 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:38, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 7/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1.5/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 14.5/26

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:23, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 3/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 0/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:38, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 7/26

Reviewer 3 (Done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 18:20, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 10/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 04:18, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 7/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:44, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 04:20, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 13/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:47, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5.5/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 14.5/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 08:41, 23 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 14/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:46, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 04:32, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 10/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 16:34, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 3/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 13/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 10:22, 5 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:50, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 04:34, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 6/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 14/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 15:34, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 6

Sourcing 5

Neutrality 2

Readability 2

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0

Total 16

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:52, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 00:25, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 3/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 1/6

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 7/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 15:27, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 2

Sourcing 3

Neutrality 1

Readability 2

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0

Total 9

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 17:11, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 3/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:56, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 7/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 08:36, 6 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 2/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 7/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 16:35, November 9 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 2/10

Sourcing 3/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 9/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (Done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 18:36, Friday November 5, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 9/10

Sourcing 5/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 3/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 21/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 08:26, Thursday November 11, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 7/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 19/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:21, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 8/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 1.5/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 20/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer: Nifboy (talk)

Assessment date: 10:13, 6 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 5/10

Sourcing 4/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 13/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 16:29, 9 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 5/10

Sourcing 4/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 14/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:54, Thursday November 18, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 6/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 14/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:10, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1/10

Sourcing 5/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 11/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 10:04, 6 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:56, Thursday November 18, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 2/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 5/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 00:29, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1/10

Sourcing 0/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 6/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 10:53, 6 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 2/10

Sourcing: 0/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 5/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:58, Thursday November 18, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 2/10

Sourcing: 0/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 4/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

==March on Washington for Lesbian, Gay and Bi Equal Rights and Liberation==

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 04:38, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 20:05, Thursday November 18, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 7/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 15:20, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 3

Sourcing 4

Neutrality 1

Readability 2

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0

Total 11

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 00:38, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 10/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 20:07, Thursday November 18, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 0/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 15:15, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 6

Sourcing 1

Neutrality 2

Readability 2

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0

Total 12

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 12:54, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 14:46, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 5

Sourcing 3

Neutrality 1

Readability 2

Formatting 1

Illustrations 1

Total 13

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 16:02, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 13/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:03, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 9/10

Sourcing 6/6

Neutrality 3/3

Readability 3/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 2/2

Total 25/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 11:00, 11 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 6/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 17/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:00, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 8/10

Sourcing: 5/6

Neutrality: 3/3

Readability: 3/3

Formatting: 2/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 22/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 16:22, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 9/10

Sourcing 6/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 2/2

Total 22/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:07, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 6/10

Sourcing 4/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 15/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:47, 8 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 13/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:03, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 11/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 10:35, 9 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 10/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:05, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 15:10, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 2

Sourcing 1

Neutrality 1

Readability 1

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0

Total 6

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:07, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 2/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 7/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 14:13, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1

Sourcing 6

Neutrality 1

Readability 1

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0

Total 10

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 16:43, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 6/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:09, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 6/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 16/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 14:37, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 9

Sourcing 2

Neutrality 2

Readability 2

Formatting 2

Illustrations 1

Total 18

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 16:59, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 7/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 15/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 04:40, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 3/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 10:11, 12 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 10/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:10, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 9/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 16:40, 9 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:30, 16 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 3/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 7/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:40, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 1.5/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 8.5/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:11, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 0/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 9/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:43, 8 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 2/2

Total: 13/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:36, 16 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 3/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 10/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 18:57, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:50, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 10/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:39, 16 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 5/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 12/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:13, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 13/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:15, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 5/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 12/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 17:38, 10 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 7/10

Sourcing 3/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 14/16

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:44, 16 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 7/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 14/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:25, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1/10

Sourcing 0/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 4/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 16:50, 9 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1/10

Sourcing 0/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0/2

Total 4/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: Cordless Larry (talk) 19:49, 16 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1/10

Sourcing 0/6

Neutrality 0/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 3/26

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 19:00, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 0/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 0/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 3/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:06, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 8/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:16, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 1/10

Sourcing: 0/6

Neutrality: 0/3

Readability: 0/3

Formatting: 0/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 1/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 14:57, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 1

Sourcing 1

Neutrality 1

Readability 1

Formatting 1

Illustrations 0

Total 5

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:15, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 7/10

Sourcing 4/6

Neutrality 3/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 17/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 07:46, 9 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 6/10

Sourcing: 4/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 14/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:19, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 19:30, 16 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 7/10

Sourcing 4/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 18/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:21, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 6/10

Sourcing: 3/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 15/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 15:05, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 8

Sourcing 4

Neutrality 2

Readability 2

Formatting 2

Illustrations 1

Total 19

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:33, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 3/10

Sourcing 2/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 17:42, 10 November (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 3/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 1/2

Total 13/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:22, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 5/10

Sourcing: 2/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 12/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:24, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 6/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 12/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 18:04, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 6/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 3/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 14/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:30, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 6/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 12/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 18:22, 7 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 4/10

Sourcing 1/6

Neutrality 1/3

Readability 2/3

Formatting 2/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 10/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:23, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 4/10

Sourcing: 0/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 1/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 8/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer: RexxS (talk)

Assessment date: 14:53, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 5

Sourcing 1

Neutrality 1

Readability 3

Formatting 2

Illustrations 0

Total 12

Reviewer 4 (done)
Reviewer: Mabeenot (talk)

Assessment date: 19:07, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 6/10

Sourcing: 1/6

Neutrality: 1/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 0/2

Total: 11/26

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 1 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 02:09, 4 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 10/10

Sourcing 6/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 20/26

Reviewer 2 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 01:35, 19 November 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness 10/10

Sourcing 6/6

Neutrality 2/3

Readability 1/3

Formatting 1/2

Illustrations 0/2

Total 20.5/26

Reviewer 3 (done)
Reviewer:

Assessment date: 13:26, Friday November 19, 2010 (UTC)

Scores

Comprehensiveness: 7/10

Sourcing: 5/6

Neutrality: 2/3

Readability: 2/3

Formatting: 1/2

Illustrations: 1/2

Total: 18/26

Reviewer 4
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total

Reviewer 5
Reviewer:

Assessment date:

Scores

Comprehensiveness

Sourcing

Neutrality

Readability

Formatting

Illustrations

Total
 * 1) Numbered list item