Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2015-08-12/In the media



Paid editing in the spotlight again
The Atlantic examined "The Covert World of People Trying to Edit Wikipedia—for Pay".

The article first discusses medical editing and the experiences of Dr. James Heilman, a Canadian physician who is currently on the Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees. (Heilman discussed his opinions on paid editing in a Signpost op-ed earlier this year.) In 2013, Heilman was editing the Wikipedia article for kyphoplasty, a popular back procedure of disputed effectiveness. When Heilman reverted changes to the article that he thought were not "supported by existing research", he found himself drawn into a contentious debate with employees of Medtronic, a medical equipment company which sells a kyphoplasty kit. He was emailed by a physician who was a consultant for Medtronic and the resulting email thread was cc:ed to over 300 others, including one of Heilman's medical school professors. Heilman was intimidated by the contact. Elsewhere, he wrote "having 'representatives' from an 28 billion USD company email 300 of your colleagues to inform them how misguided you are is disconcerting."

The Atlantic puts this incident in the context of the conflicts between the motivations of company employees and volunteer editors.

The Atlantic writes that these issues are exacerbated by the shrinking ranks of active editors, the small number of administrators, and the growing number of articles. Heilman told The Atlantic that undisclosed advocacy edits "often distract the core community of editors away from more important topics." The Atlantic notes that Wikipedia's wide reach makes these issues important ones. According to Wikipedia's medical articles likely have a larger readership than WebMD and are used by 50-70 percent of doctors. Wikipedia information has even turned up in medical books themselves. As recounted by Heilman in the Signpost earlier this year, Wikipedia was plagiarized by a contributor to an Oxford University Press medical textbook. The Atlantic discusses what public relations companies are and are not doing. It mentions in passing the 2014 pledge by a number of PR firms to adhere to Wikipedia's terms of use by disclosing their conflict of interest. (William Beutler, a paid editor who spearheaded that effort and wrote an op-ed in the Signpost about paid editing last month, called that a "big missed opportunity".) Despite this, undisclosed advocacy editing persists, ranging from the high profile, such as this summer's Sunshine Sachs controversy (see previous Signpost coverage), to the low profile, like the abundant ads on Elance advertising the services of Wikipedia editors and even administrators. Patrick Taylor, one of the duo at the head of Wiki-PR, which was blocked from editing Wikipedia for operating an army of sockpuppets (see the Signpost's Wiki-PR series), told The Atlantic that "Undisclosed paid editing, especially on the part of the largest PR firms, is rampant on Wikipedia."

The Atlantic talked with two paid editors, Gregory Kohs, founder of MyWikiBiz and longtime Wikipedia critic, and Mike Wood, who runs Legalmorning. The Atlantic failed to note that both have been banned from Wikipedia for policy violations. Both refuse to disclose their advocacy editing and claimed to The Atlantic that they did so because of Jimmy Wales, an odd, self-serving justification. Wood said "As soon as Jimmy Wales adheres to Wikipedia guidelines, I will adhere to Wikipedia guidelines," though the only specific act of Wales cited by The Atlantic was Wales editing his own Wikipedia article back in 2005. (Aug. 11)

Wikipedia traffic from Google drops 250 million visits
Business Insider reports that Wikipedia traffic from the search engine Google has experienced a significant drop. It recounts analysis from a July 28 blog post by Roy Hinkins, head of search engine optimization for SimilarWeb, a web analytics company. Hinkins writes:

Business Insider speculates that the drop is due to Google's growing "preference for inserting its own content above the content of other non-Google web sites, even when those sites may be better resources than Google itself", though it notes " there is no evidence that Wikipedia's traffic loss is due to Google".

The drop in traffic was noted at the Wikimedia Foundation August Metrics & Activities meeting (see graphic at right), though the meeting did not discuss a potential cause. Elsewhere, a number of experienced editors are attributing the drop to the normal summer decrease in Wikipedia traffic. (Aug. 12)

Nicki Minaj complains about her boyfriend's Wikipedia article
Music news outlets noted that singer Nicki Minaj took to Instagram, where she has 31.2 million followers, to complain about the Wikipedia article for her boyfriend, rapper Meek Mill. Whenever she posted Mill's birth name, Rihmeek, she was inundated with complaints and mockery on social media for "misspelling" his name, because his Wikipedia article spelled it "Rahmeek". She posted a picture of herself with Mill and his family and wrote:

Neither Minaj nor the media outlets noted that the incorrect spelling in Meek's Wikipedia article was cited to a biography page on the website of his own record label, Roc Nation, where the error remains. (Aug. 8)

Editor's note: Emoticons in the above quote may not be visible on all computers. 

In brief
Do you want to contribute to "In the media" by writing a story or even just an "in brief" item? Edit next week's edition in the Newsroom or contact the editor.
 * New CEO, new edit war: The Hindu reports on the furious editing on the article for Sundar Pichai following the annoucement that he would be the next CEO of Google. While there was no dispute over his graduate education in the US, editors attempted to claim him as an undergraduate alumnus of a number of different schools in India.   The Next Web noted that over 250 edits were made during the edit war. (Aug. 12)
 * Bieber or Swift?: The New York Observer reports on the debate about which celebrities should be included in the Wikipedia article Millennials. (Aug. 11)
 * Liberland Über Alles: A lengthy profile in The New York Times Magazine of Vít Jedlička, founder of the micronation Liberland, notes that the land comprising the country was discovered by consulting the Wikipedia article Terra nullius.  (Aug. 11)
 * Another plagiarism case: Spanish language media reports that sports journalist Sara Carbonero is alleged to have plagiarized Wikipedia in an August 5 blog post for Elle about her new home Porto, Portugal. (Aug. 10)
 * Identity crisis: Actor Peter Dinklage told The Guardian that, contrary to what it said in his Wikipedia article, his daughter's name was not Zelig.  He said "But it’s hilarious that that’s a fact in Wikipedia."  When asked if he wanted a correction, he replied "I don’t care!" The name was cited to articles from Gather.com and The Daily Mail. (Aug. 9)
 * Accessing history: The Hans India reports on efforts by Telugu Wikipedians to provide access to rare Telugu language works via Wikisource. (Aug. 7)
 * Support your local fireman: Channel 4 reports on "A year in the life of Whitehall's Wikipedia warriors", examining edits from IP addresses assigned to the UK government. The most frequently edited article was that of author Simon Bucher-Jones and the edits included "a detailed 800-word analysis of the characters in the children's TV series Fireman Sam".  (Aug. 7)
 * Nature editathon: The Hindu reports on a Wikipedia editathon in Bengaluru focused on wildlife and the natural world. (Aug. 6)
 * "How can I change my Wikipedia page?": In an interview with the Naples Daily News, comedian Heather McDonald said that while the list of impressions she is known for in her Wikipedia article includes many male impressions, she only impersonates women. (Aug. 6)