Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/'Tis the Season (Vince Gill and Olivia Newton-John album) (2nd nomination)

Keep: A unique album by Hallmark and represents their reputation of high quality productions. It unashamedly appeals to those who cherish the Christmas season at a time when some look for reasons to squelch it.

Keep:
Insert non-formatted text here even if edited to limit to the bare facts of publisher, date, artists, and title list. These are matters of fact and verifiable and worthy of inclusion in an encyclopedia. A statement that the album's "importance" has been disputed could be included, but said "importance" should not rule out inclusion of any artistic production. (Let's not get into debate over definitions of "artistic" here.) I'm making general comments here. They could apply to any recording. Value judgments should not preclude the public's ability to locate the basic facts about an item that had a very real existence. As to the comment about editorial difficulty in placing a joint album under a page devoted to a single artist, I find that to be an unconvincing stance. If an album is recorded by artist A and artist B, list it on both artists' pages as "recorded jointly with." Simple.RIRN (talk) 23:05, 23 December 2016 (UTC)RIR