Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Andrew Chan

Valid Deletion Arguments

 * WP:ONEEVENT
 * WP:PERP

Invalid Deletion Arguments

 * Not notable until recently when arrested
 * Too many duplicated contents

Valid Keep Arguments

 * Notable for something other than crime
 * Significant enough coverage, such that WP:ONEEVENT does not apply
 * Covered in multiple WP:RS

Invalid Keep Arguments

 * Would lose information if article is deleted
 * Bad for encyclopedia if deleted

Remarks
WP:ONEEVENT and WP:PERP is the only valid deletion reason here, and it may apply to some of the articles, however, that cannot be determined from this AfD alone and another AfD may be needed, preferably on a more individual basis. Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran are notable for more than just criminals and hence, WP:ONEEVENT and WP:PERP hardly applies to them, not to mention there are plenty of WP:RS on this subject, so they are kept for that reason. Other articles will be closed with no consensus, with no prejudice if they are individually nominated for deletion again. 山本一郎 (会話) 04:46, 5 December 2011 (UTC)