Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Banksia Park International High School

Response to TJ Spike
In regards to your "silly" points: Although it is not yet required that nominators look for sources before deleting an article, it is strongly encouraged. The nominators argument would be stronger if he had looked for sources, and it shows a lack of contemplation and investigation before throwing other editors hard work in the garbage. I am pointing out the clear weakness of the nomination. I actually do feel that all high school pages should be kept. There were already huge debates high schools inclusion years ago, when editors deleted hundreds of pages in bulk, those who wanted to keep high schools prevailed.

I don't see listing all highschools as a problem at all. Wikipedia is not paper, listing this articles does not degrade the quality of another more "encyclopedic" article.

Although jimbo's opinion is not binding, it can help people decide how to approach issues, and is authoritative as essays, which are quoted frequently in deletion debates.

I see you criticizing my points, but spending no time explaining, with policy and guidelines yourself, why this article should be deleted.

This article "isn't hurting anything" you "should relax and accommodate" this page. travb (talk) 02:01, 11 January 2009 (UTC)