Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Carmen L. Robinson

Should this be reviewed or should author request userfication
Should anyone ask that this be userfied, it's pretty obvious the consensus was to userfy, with only the original AFD submitter not on board with userficiation.

Grsz, AFD submitter: seems to favor outright deletion Grundle2600, original author: attempted to re-userfy article herself at one point. Davidwr: recommended userfication 22:16, 10 March 2009 S Marshall: ok with non-admin userfication 08:39, 11 March 2009, providing author is as well. JohnCD: ok with userfication 22:25, 10 March 2009

There is a strong consensus not to allow this back in article space without a review for notability. davidwr/ (talk)/(contribs)/(e-mail)  16:36, 16 March 2009 (UTC)

"Result" re-creation criteria does not reflect consensus
The closing admin said
 * The result was delete. Delete, but permit recreation AFTER the primary in May

This is not consensus. The consensus is "remove from mainspace/userfy, permit re-creation after DRV for notability."

True, if she wins the primary, she will almost certainly be notable but she will probably achieve notability before election day unless the election is expected to be close.

If she loses the primary, the article should not be allowed to be re-created just because the primary is over. If she gained notability during the primary and lost, she may be wiki-notable, or she may not be. That's what DRV is for. davidwr/ (talk)/(contribs)/(e-mail)  16:40, 16 March 2009 (UTC)
 * the meaning is that if she wins the primary. I do not think the consensus was that she would be notable otherwise. I also did not rule out creation in user space and DRV. DGG (talk) 16:49, 16 March 2009 (UTC) I added some comments in italics. Anyone unhappy, try DRV. DGG (talk) 17:29, 16 March 2009 (UTC)
 * Thanks, your clarifications are good. It's always possible she'll become notable for something else, such as a future election.  I'm not optimistic though.  davidwr/  (talk)/(contribs)/(e-mail)  20:11, 16 March 2009 (UTC)