Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Disclose.tv

Request for Deletion of Disclose.tv Article Due to Policy Violations
I am writing to express my concerns about the Wikipedia article on Disclose.tv. After a thorough examination, I have found multiple instances of policy violations, which I believe warrant the deletion of this page. I kindly request that the community reviews these violations and considers taking appropriate action.


 * 1) Reliability of sources: The current article relies heavily on Logically, an organization that has not been consistently recognized as a reliable source by the Wikipedia community. Although they may be "certified" by a reputable Wikipedia source, only content that that reputable organization produces is reputable. That does not extend to those that they "certify." There are alternative sources that could provide a more balanced and accurate representation of Disclose.tv. For instance, mainstream media outlets or academic research on conspiracy theories and disinformation.
 * 2) Neutrality: The article appears heavily biased against Disclose.tv, with an excessive focus on negative aspects and controversies. A neutral point of view, as required by Wikipedia policy, should present both positive and negative aspects of the subject in a balanced manner.
 * 3) Undue weight: The article gives undue weight to certain aspects of Disclose.tv, such as conspiracy theories and disinformation, which may not be representative of the entire scope of the website. By doing so, the article fails to adhere to Wikipedia's policy on giving appropriate weight to different aspects of a subject.
 * 4) Single hostile editor dominance: The editing history of the Disclose.tv article reveals that one editor has been dominating the contributions, limiting the opportunity for other editors to participate and create a more balanced article. This gatekeeping behavior goes against the collaborative nature of Wikipedia and raises concerns about the neutrality and accuracy of the content.
 * 5) Blocking Policy: The editor has been actively blocking other editors from contributing to the page and rejecting all attempts at collaboration. This violates the blocking policy, which states that blocks should only be used as a last resort and should not be used as a means of censorship or punishment.

Given these policy violations, I believe that the Disclose.tv article should be deleted as it cannot be reasonably modified with what currently exists. I kindly request that experienced and neutral editors review the article and its editing history to verify these concerns. Furthermore, I urge the involved editor to disclose any potential conflicts of interest that might be influencing their actions related to the Disclose.tv article.

If necessary, I am willing to raise these concerns in a broader forum, such as the Village Pump, to ensure that the issue is adequately addressed by the Wikipedia community.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Sincerely,

DiamondPuma DiamondPuma (talk) 02:07, 21 March 2023 (UTC)