Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/European Union Olympic medals count for 2004

Technical question to the experts: please, what are the objective rules and criteria to declare a wikipedian vote as invalid? What would become the validity of the general vote in the - of course purely theoretical - case that those criteria wouldn't not be respected? --Pgreenfinch 11:52, 23 Aug 2004 (UTC)


 * See Sock puppet Mintguy (T)

What if there is a "stockpuppetship suspicion" error? For example, when the decision to attribute it to some votes comes in a rush, without looking further, when the vote is going to its end, and that it changes the direction of the vote? Theorical question of course ;-)) --Pgreenfinch 12:33, 23 Aug 2004 (UTC)

I am not a Sockpuppet, I just worked here in some articles before I registered this nickname. I am a real person. This situation is totally unfair and outrageous! I am considering resignation of my collaboration with English Wikipedia because, it seems to me, that some people here are very puerile and arrogant. Eurolusitanian 14:18, 23 Aug 2004 (UTC)

Please move this discussion off this page and over to Wikipedia talk:Votes for deletion. The questions you raise have relevance for more than just this one discussion thread. (By the way, they've also been raised and answered before. It's a difficult question.)  Rossami 14:27, 23 Aug 2004 (UTC)

Just seemed to correspond to some actuality here, but thanks for your advice, and of course you were right to move it to a more general talk page, I put it on my watchlist --Pgreenfinch 14:48, 23 Aug 2004 (UTC)