Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Kirov (novel series)

Not clear what do you mean. The page had been created by myself and I am not the author. If you mean that you cant find other references to the reviews, then you can check Amazon respective pages - there are 77 reviews for the first book - https://www.amazon.com/Kirov-John-Schettler/dp/0984946527

Moreover, the book had been seemingly unofficially translated to Russian and heavily commented, which is even better than reviews, and obviously, it was not done by the author: http://samlib.ru/z/zarewich_a_n/dzhonshettlerkirow.shtml And there are another 45 comments there - http://samlib.ru/comment/z/zarewich_a_n/dzhonshettlerkirow?&COOK_CHECK=1

7 more books, also translated by fans, are located here - https://www.litmir.me/a/?id=283232 Also with comments - https://www.litmir.me/a/?id=283232

More references - http://flibusta.site/a/187257 http://www.rulit.me/books/kirov-lp-read-486781-5.html https://coollib.net/a/153789 https://knigochei.net/fantastika-i-fentezi/alternativnaya-istoriya/10378-kirov.html https://litvek.com/av/153789

And so on. So if you mean the article has no value, you are worng - you cant name too many 38-book long series and subject is also far from mainstream, so its obvious that interest is niche.

So I see no reason why the article needs to be deleted and its not clear why the books contents was removed. Yes, it was copied from the cited source, so what? It gave necessary information to people about the books and plot

Портовик (talk) 18:48, 9 September 2018 (UTC)