Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/List of Comedy Bang! Bang! episodes


 * Keep While I do acknowledge that the article does not conform to what is considered the standard rule set, I want to comment on the content of the article itself, as I feel it merits consideration as an exception. Said content is accurate and incomparably comprehensive, verified by simply cross-referencing episode number, title, and associated guest/character appearances on any podcast application, as well as the paid service offered by the podcast host which provides access to the entire catalogue of episodes. I do not believe one should have to pay a subscription fee in order to find information on archived episodes, information that at this point (as far as my efforts thus far have confirmed) can only be found in this article or an otherwise painstaking process of looking through each free episode available on various podcast applications. Other sites, including the Fandom page for the podcast that attempts to list episode numbers/names/guests/characters, has in my experience (as recently as yesterday 2/22/2023) been impartial or inaccurate. Beyond the Fandom page, there is nothing the result has been my return to this Wikipedia article that has allowed me to identify quickly and accurately with simple keyword searches the episode I am looking for. I strongly believe that anyone else who like me has a vested interest in the podcast and this article/list can confirm this. I also believe it would be a safe assumption to say that there are many other avid listeners of this podcast who rely on this page for the content it provides that cannot be found anywhere else. While the list does not pass WP:NLIST because the episodes are not "discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources", it should be stressed that the podcast episode archive itself, the only primary source that can technically exist, attests to the reliability of this article. Deleting it would be to the detriment of many, including myself, who reference it on a regular basis without issue. Yodas4sale (talk) 17:10, 23 February 2023 (UTC)

Keep: I would agree with the above. The content here is an invaluable resource for listeners to this podcast, is accurate to the show's database and comprehensible for those looking to browse through the podcast's history. This is one of the best resources available for looking through Comedy Bang! Bang!'s backlog. 2601:19C:4000:FBB0:FCB8:700D:55BF:4E36 (talk) 18:09, 23 February 2023 (UTC)
 * Comment. This is the wrong place to make the keep arguments. Please post them at Articles for deletion/List of Comedy Bang! Bang! episodes instead. CT55555  (talk) 18:41, 23 February 2023 (UTC)