Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/List of Latino ice hockey players

=Closing administrator's rationale= '''Do not inturrupt these comments. If you want to post a reply please do so below or in the section at the bottom entitled "Other comments".

Keep

 * 1) Zagalejo	(13 edits)	
 * 2) Mandsford	(6 edits)
 * 3) Djsasso	(6 edits)
 * 4) Gang14	(2 edits)
 * 5) Alansohn

Delete

 * 1) Tavix	(4 edits)
 * 2) QuidProQuo23
 * 3) Mr Senseless
 * 4) TenPoundHammer
 * 5) Ravenswing	(6 edits)
 * 6) Kaiser matias
 * 7) Brilliantine
 * 8) Suntag	(7 edits)
 * 9) Corvus cornix

Non-participatory

 * Cliff smith	(2 edits)
 * Resolute	

Keep

 * aren't that many black or Latino ice hockey players
 * issue of racial diversity in the NHL is a common topic of discussion
 * 7 sources provided
 * improve don't delete
 * not racist
 * if we delete this, then we have to delete all...
 * meaningful intersections that have been frequent subjects of media coverage establishing notability

Delete

 * Indiscriminate list
 * racist!
 * other stuff doesn't exist
 * fails WP:SALAT; too specific
 * If we allow x then we'll have to allow y and z
 * we deleted a bunch of similar articles already
 * non-notable intersection
 * article is appropriate. A list is not
 * should be a standalone article or section in Ice hockey
 * names are added without any attempt at a definition
 * poorly sourced, and possibly NPOV
 * topics unsuitable for category are unsuitable for list
 * Listcruft

Summary
I find that the arguments on both sides are by in large flawed, or subjective. Counterarguments present for most from other side. Niether side was convincing. That spells No consensus, which is a special form of keep.  Jerry  delusional ¤ kangaroo 00:59, 14 September 2008 (UTC)

=Other comments=