Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/List of fictional worms (3rd nomination)

Valid Deletion Arguments

 * List is too broad
 * WP:NOTDIR
 * WP:IINFO
 * The topic itself may not be appropriate for lists.

Invalid Deletion Arguments

 * List is only published on Wikipedia
 * Entries in the list are non-notable

Valid Keep Arguments

 * The topic is not too broad for list
 * Individual entries are not non-notable
 * Article which can be improved does not require deletion

Invalid Keep Arguments

 * Other stuff exists

Conclusion
Overall, considering the strength of the arguments presented, the consensus leaning towards keep. Although there are valid arguments for deletion, many of the arguments for deletion have been considered and in the end, none of them are really applicable as I fail to see any evidence to support the claims of WP:OR, WP:NOTDIR, WP:IINFO, and etc. I am also fully aware that some items on the list may individually fail WP:OR and they may not be notable, however, that is not a grounds for deletion in this case. Therefore, the decision here is to keep. 山本一郎 (会話) 19:47, 21 June 2010 (UTC)
 * I fail to understand why there's no evidence to support "WP:IINFO". This list doesn't just cover earthworms, it covers dragons and serpents and so forth, and there's no clear indication of what sort of supernatural creature counts as a worm. Claritas § 22:32, 21 June 2010 (UTC)
 * Shouldn't that be discussed on the article talk page instead, why isn't that being discussed and edited? Deletion is no substitute for fixing an article. 山本一郎 (会話) 01:36, 22 June 2010 (UTC)
 * I'll move the article to List of fictional earthworms and remove non-earthworm related material - there seems to be little interest in editing at the moment, and separate lists for dragons and supernatural creatures are warranted . Claritas § 06:58, 22 June 2010 (UTC)
 * The article was threatened by deletion which tends to have a chilling effect. Now that the AFD is over, talk should continue at the article's talk page. Colonel Warden (talk) 08:06, 22 June 2010 (UTC)