Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Michael Johns (singer)

=Closing admin's determination of rough concensus=

Delete

 * 1) 72.75.72.63 delete both citing WP:MUSIC
 * 2) Torc2 delete, provided detailed analysis of sources
 * 3) PAWiki calls for delete per nom and states not notable per musician standards
 * 4) PKT says delete and not sufficiently notable.
 * 5) Thedjatclubrock says delete per nom and after on idol can recreate
 * 6) Corvus cornix states future notanility on Ai7 is doubtable
 * 7) Brianyoumans nom, says non-notable, and cites WP:CRYSTAL

Keep and or Merge and therefore delete

 * 1) Samj suggests merge and delete and states that being in the promos is notability

Keep
88.173.106.101 said keep, but is actually also mjf08
 * 1) Mjf08 says keep and that he will be on Ai7, also states wrote lyrics for notable band/song and links to Bruce Springstien note:

Ignored

 * 1) Kmkroeger is a confirmed sockpuppet and has no voice here

MJF08 !voted several times. He gets only one !vote. As an apparent SPA account to promote the subject of the article in question, his comments have less weight. JERRY talk contribs 00:30, 18 January 2008 (UTC)