Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Timeline of the Phantasy Star series

Closing rationale
I anticipate that there are going to be passionate feelings about this AfD, so I'm going to post a bit more of my thinking regarding the closing decision here.

I discounted a number of arguments when judging the consensus here. Keep arguments with no rationale at all and delete arguments citing only "per above" were discounted because they added nothing to the conversation and amounted to votes. The consensus from the "keep" side of the debate seemed to be arguing that the games themselves were sufficient sources to justify the presence of the article, a line of thinking which is blatantly contradictory to WP:Attribution. On the "delete" side, there was a wide variety of cogent arguments from a much larger number of editors, which I judged as a consensus to delete.  A  Train ''talk 12:34, 13 April 2007 (UTC)
 * Which part of WP:ATT does it go against? That page is long. Voretus 15:22, 16 April 2007 (UTC)