Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Twila Tanner

Whom to keep and whom to merge with their season?
Because Survivor is a much more noted show than the Amazing Race, it is easy to see why there are so many more pages devoted to its players. Incidentally, there has been only one season following Pearl Islands in which there were 16 contestants.

Keep:
 * Tom Buchanan and Lex van den Berghe (part of two seasons and are highly recognizable icons of Survivor lore)
 * Matthew Von Ertfelda (was a subject of mass discussion on good and bad game play well past his season)
 * Jennifer Lyon (incident of breast cancer)
 * Bobby Jon Drinkard (noteworthy roles in two seasons)

Delete (or merge with the pages linking to their respective seasons):
 * Ian Rosenberger
 * Rodger Bingham
 * Stacey Stillman (who remembers that lawsuit? My point exactly)
 * Lillian Morris
 * Kim Johnson
 * Osten Taylor (his quitting incident was already covered)
 * Heidi Strobel
 * Gregg Carey
 * Danielle DiLorenzo (breast enhancement?)
 * Clay Jordan
 * Cirie Fields
 * Cindy Hall
 * Caryn Groedel

Just because someone is notable only for the show means does not mean no significant history can be provided on them. However, the show has regressed to the point where it is little more than a jungle version of Your Big Break. Messy Thinking 22:21, 8 October 2006 (UTC)Contribs