Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Velvet Cacoon

Why was the result of this debate "Keep"? No consensus maybe; definitely don't see a Keep here. To enumerate:
 * 4 delete votes (including nomination)
 * 1 keep vote from an AIW member
 * 1 keep from article author, who has not done anything to show notability or verifiability
 * 2 keep votes from new users who joined after AFD began ( had 1 article space edit; had edited about 12 articles)

At least mark it as "no consensus" to make me feel better. :)  &mdash;Quarl (talk) 2006-01-13 01:42Z 
 * I would have to agree that this debate has no consensus, I guess I wasn't reading carefully enough the first time I closed it. Sorry for that. --Ichiro 05:24, 13 January 2006 (UTC)