Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Vladimír Hirsch

Concerns Regarding the Deletion Nomination for Vladimír Hirsch
Hi everyone,

I am writing to express my concerns regarding the nomination for deletion of the Vladimír Hirsch article. I believe it is important to address several key points and provide a broader perspective on the notability and significance of this composer.

Bias and Notability
It appears that there may be a bias against Vladimír Hirsch due to a misunderstanding of his contributions and impact in his field. His extensive discography and numerous collaborations over several decades demonstrate his influence and relevance. Dismissing his work based on selective criteria does not provide a fair assessment of his notability.

Sources and Research
While there have been criticisms of the sources used in the article, it is important to recognize that not all sources were given due consideration and all are freely accessible. Although some state that "list cites" are not relevant, these lists show, in a comprehensive way, the ongoing and active engagement and dedication to his professional work.

Professionalism and Objectivity
We must maintain professionalism and objectivity in our evaluations. It is inadmissible to split "notable people" into those who actively engage in interviews and those who are dedicated to their field through other means. Both forms of contribution to society and their respective fields are valid and valuable. Conflating personal biases with objective assessment can lead to an unjust outcome.

Improving the Article
Instead of deleting the article, I propose that we work together to improve it.

Thank you for considering my points. Marespw (talk) 12:49, 13 July 2024 (UTC)