Wikipedia talk:Categories for discussion/Log/2022 March 16

Protest against evidently wrong non-admin closure decision by user Marcocapelle
The recent non-admin closure decision by user Marcocapelle in Category:Films shot in 16mm is not at all correct! The result as I read it was four oppose votes against two delete votes (only if you count the nominator in). That is really not the same as no consensus which leaves it as 'completely open' for the future and another attempt. This closure decison is evidently wrong. You could even name it abusive. Marco has obviously a personal opinion about the facts in this case that is not the same as the majority of voters -> and he has given in to the temptation to correct the result in this direction. I would like to hear his formal apology as well as his explanation why he did this? It indeed does semm that he didn't expect anyone to protest against this evident wrong decision and vote tampering. -- Sorry, Marco, I do know your longtime good work at CfD but this can't be without consequences. I insist on an authentic promise that you'll never do again any non-admin closures in cases that are controversial. And I want the mistake immediately corrected and the evident voting result carried into effect. --Just N. (talk) 12:54, 10 April 2022 (UTC)
 * It's generally pointless to spend so much energy obsessing over whether something should be closed as "no consensus" or "keep"; the result is the same. * Pppery * it has begun... 00:43, 1 May 2022 (UTC)