Wikipedia talk:Deleted fair use image replacement

The purpose of this list
I don't understand the purpose of this list. What use is listing the Acura MDX, of which we have deleted an unfree image, and omitting a different model of which we have never had a free or unfree image? We need a free image for each and have Requested pictures for prioritization. It also seems to me that if everyone maintains this list perfectly, it will quickly become too large to be useful. ×Meegs 14:36, 9 September 2006 (UTC)
 * Although I didn't initiate it, I believe the intention is that where an image has been deleted on the grounds that it is repeatable (and thus not meeting our 'fair use' standard) that there is a record of it being removed on those grounds and needing replacement. Wikipedia:Requested pictures is, generally, used for totally new pictures being required for articles, rather than a record of ones removed. --AlisonW 15:11, 9 September 2006 (UTC)
 * Nothing wrong with requesting replacements for removed pictures at Requested pictures, and I don't see the point in keeping a record of removed images just for the sake of it (and this list will never contain more than a tiny fraction of such images anyway). You would be much better off just slapping reqphoto (or one of the more spesific image request templates listed there) on the various article talk pages. --Sherool (talk) 09:41, 5 November 2006 (UTC)