Wikipedia talk:Editor review/Dodger67

Qualitas Career Academy
I noted that you marked this institution for speedy deletion. You cited your reasons. On receiving an objection, you commented that you'd mark it as spam. The article can certainly be improved, rather offer improvement suggestions before recommending deletion. The accreditations, date of establishment, and multi site representation suggest this is more of a notable institution than a mere training company. Note that the user also started the Damelin page, which evolved into a decent page, with multiple contributors over years.

Do you know the user/company personally that you would respond as you did?

Rather provide useful feedback than going straight for deletion/spam. Wikicheesecake (talk • contribs) 17:10, 1 September 2013 (UTC)

GTCL
I think I see your point vis a vis GTCL (Graduate of Trinity College London) not being worthy to have its own page. However, GRSM (the qualification of another college) does, so there is no consistency.

As it stands, all these qualifications are important in Britain, though they are no longer issued.

How would it be if I rewrote one article that serves them all (there are five mainline conservatories of music in Britain) and put a redirect on the GRSM? Could you support that?

Otherwise I will perhaps give up on this - there's quite some effort involved in writing a properly referenced article about a cornerstone feature of the British Arts Music scene, when (for some reason) it won't be accepted.

Thine, coranglais2001 — Preceding unsigned comment added by Coranglais2001 (talk • contribs) 15:01, 31 January 2014 (UTC)