Wikipedia talk:Featured article candidates/History of Cape Colony from 1870 to 1899/archive1

Copied from Featured article candidates/History of Cape Colony from 1870 to 1899/History comments

Comment - Would be real nice to have a short summary of the entire history under a ==History== section at Cape Colony and have a full separate article at History of Cape Colony (about the size of this FAC) with sections that correspond to the separate articles in the series. The content now at History of Cape Colony would be great to have as the ==History== section at Cape Colony. As of right now, there is a short summary and detailed summary pages, but no intermediate treatment. See Summary style. --mav 17:30, 17 Mar 2005 (UTC)


 * Yes, I agree with that, but this is about the nomination of History of Cape Colony from 1870 to 1899, not the Cape Colony article. Your comments are germaine for a Cape Colony FAC, but not to this article. Páll 17:35, 17 Mar 2005 (UTC)


 * I know - that is why my comment was labled as such and not as an object. :) --mav


 * Er - one thing I just noticed. History of Cape Colony looks like it only covers the Pre-1806 history. That is not good since the article title indicates that it covers the whole history. Just more general feedback on the whole series. :) -- mav 17:41, 17 Mar 2005 (UTC)


 * Mav, I believe my talk page would be the appropriate forum for such discussions, not here. May I ask your opinion of the article under discussion here? Páll 17:42, 17 Mar 2005 (UTC)