Wikipedia talk:Files for deletion/2008 July 19

General objection

 * There's a good chance that a lot of those pictures aren't useful and so could be deleted. But let's not kid ourselves, saying "image fails NFCC #8 and is not significant to the article as a whole" is redundant and really only gives one rather vague reason to delete the image.  Why?  Because NFCC #8 is synonymous with "not significant to the article as a whole."  It's rather like pointing at a geometric shape, saying "that's not a square...it's a triangle and it has three sides," and then claiming that you've given two distinct pieces of evidence that the shape isn't a square.


 * So returning to the pictures, what makes them insignificant? Could their role be filled better with a composite picture?  Is it really easy to go onto Google images and find a picture of the characters (or could a link be added to the character list pages on Wikipedia directing you to a site that does have all the characters)? 70.179.100.216 (talk) 14:07, 19 July 2008 (UTC)