Wikipedia talk:Mediation Cabal/Cases/2006-12-26 Decline of Buddhism in India/hist

Jan 19 to Feb 1
 06:23, February 1 Kiore (Talk contribs) m (Xuanzang's Report - Eliminate redirects: Vijaywada -&gt; Vijayawada, Chalukyas-&gt;Chalukya dynasty, Pallavas-&gt;Pallava, Vaishnavite-&gt;Vaishnavism, etc)   11:35, January 31 SebastianHelm (Talk contribs) (Undid revision 104557809 by Freedom skies (Talk); mv link to History out of #years; -- will leave msg on Fs's talk page)   11:19, January 31 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (revival and quasim, editing as per discussion)   05:49, January 31 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (rv to last Revision as of 23:05, 30 January 2007 by SebastianHelm ( Talk and discuss before making edits @ [Wikipedia:Mediation_Cabal/Cases/2006-12-26_Decline_of_Buddhism_in_India]))   05:43, January 31 Wiki Raja (Talk contribs) m (fixed spelling)   04:58, January 31 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (rv, Removal of 5 additional refes? Removal of Islam ? Edit warring really won't help Tigeroo)   23:05, January 30 SebastianHelm (Talk contribs) (replacing and with  )   21:04, January 30 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Buddhism Template added)  <li class="MsoNormal" style="color: green"> 21:01, January 30 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Exactly ... (Qasim restored to Revision as of 20:57, 21 January 2007 by Moderator SebastianHelm and all material everywhere has been NPOV Cited) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 18:14, January 30 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (edit wars harm the article, Keep personal opinions out of revival and quasim.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 11:04, January 30 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Revival - grammar edits) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 11:02, January 30 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Revival - Removed material not related to decline. Belongs in the history article.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 11:01, January 30 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Revival - Add new sources, merged old sourced material blanked, removed honorific, expanded one citation for NPOV accurate representation.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 10:29, January 30 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) m (Buddhism under various governments - fixed mistaken change from last change) </li> <li class="MsoNormal" style="color: green"> 10:27, January 30 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Restored Qasim to last version by Moderator and the word &quot;while&quot; as acceptable for WT:MEDCAS/DoBiI##3: Buddhism outside @ Sungas - Kushans(history sec)) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 07:07, January 30 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (removing two sections which I added, they've been moved to the history section. These are under which the decline did not occur + reinstating link) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 06:50, January 30 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (rv, Quasim was reverted as well and the three periods may be appropriate for the history section but removing them from here?) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 11:53, January 29 80.227.40.9 (Talk) (Ideological and financial causes - link) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 11:37, January 29 80.227.40.9 (Talk) (moved material more appropiate to history of Buddhism in India section.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 09:06, January 28 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) m (links) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 09:05, January 28 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) m (links) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 09:04, January 28 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) m (keeping the line as agreed; it's resolved. Will mention the entire bactrian and Kushan periods then. Also a mantion of the hospitable Mauryans is in order.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 08:59, January 28 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) m (removing Greco Bactrians from the Sunga section altogather) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 08:33, January 28 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (The Sungas) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 08:32, January 28 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 06:28, January 28 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (deleted the content while editing Quasim by mistake. oops!) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 13:59, January 27 Schzmo (Talk contribs) (restore unexplained deletion of much of the article) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 13:47, January 27 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (The decline under quasim was removed by Tigeroo, I'm putting it and the text he wanted to be put in back.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 13:15, January 27 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (Revival) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 13:13, January 27 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (revival, mentioning Islam and BR Ambedekar's views on it as well. Expanding Lama Gyatso) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 10:32, January 25 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Revival - wikilink) </li> <li class="MsoNormal" style="color: green"> 20:57, January 21 SebastianHelm (Talk contribs) (r unexplained edits (See also WP:MEDCAS/DoBiI##6: Decline @ Qasim)) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 05:27, January 21 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (Muhammad bin Qasim) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 05:01, January 21 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 13:21, January 19 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Revival - Sentence removed temporarily. Will reinstate later if can be sourced and contextualized.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 13:10, January 19 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Revival - refercing the societys own words to do away with the musim destruction or reclaiming them from hindus POV problem. Integrating sentence to show why Ambedkar was different.) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 12:31, January 19 Freedom skies (Talk contribs) (not quite) </li> <li class="MsoNormal"> 11:26, January 19 Tigeroo (Talk contribs) (Revival - The society focused heavily on recovering Buddhist stupas that had being taken over by Hindus. Conversion ban as relevant as jizya to Buddhism revival.) </li> </ul>

Jan 11 to Jan 21
{| class="wikitable" ! date (of last, if several)!!editor!!summary!!diff to "form covered"!!diff to previous
 * 18:31, January 11||Fs||Ti reverted it to the form not covered in the discussion; now it is||this is it||
 * 12:16, January 17||colspan=2|several edits by all three; all major changes are per mediation||||
 * 04:38, January 19||Fs||"Ti misses the line which mentions the muslims, how convienient"||||
 * 11:26, January 19||Ti||→Revival - The society focused heavily on recovering Buddhist stupas that had being taken over by Hindus. Conversion ban as relevant as jizya to Buddhism revival.||||
 * 12:31, January 19||Fs||not quite||colspan=2|(reverted to his version of 04:38)
 * 13:21, January 19||Ti||→Revival - refercing the societys own words to do away with the musim destruction or reclaiming them from hindus POV problem. Integrating sentence to show why Ambedkar was different. Sentence removed temporarily. Will reinstate later if can be sourced and contextualized.||||
 * 05:27, January 21||Fs||none||||
 * 20:57, January 21||Se||rv unexplained edits (See also WP:MEDCAS/DoBiI)||colspan=2|(reverted to Ti's version of 13:21)
 * 12:31, January 19||Fs||not quite||colspan=2|(reverted to his version of 04:38)
 * 13:21, January 19||Ti||→Revival - refercing the societys own words to do away with the musim destruction or reclaiming them from hindus POV problem. Integrating sentence to show why Ambedkar was different. Sentence removed temporarily. Will reinstate later if can be sourced and contextualized.||||
 * 05:27, January 21||Fs||none||||
 * 20:57, January 21||Se||rv unexplained edits (See also WP:MEDCAS/DoBiI)||colspan=2|(reverted to Ti's version of 13:21)
 * 05:27, January 21||Fs||none||||
 * 20:57, January 21||Se||rv unexplained edits (See also WP:MEDCAS/DoBiI)||colspan=2|(reverted to Ti's version of 13:21)
 * 20:57, January 21||Se||rv unexplained edits (See also WP:MEDCAS/DoBiI)||colspan=2|(reverted to Ti's version of 13:21)
 * 20:57, January 21||Se||rv unexplained edits (See also WP:MEDCAS/DoBiI)||colspan=2|(reverted to Ti's version of 13:21)

Explanation
As can be seen from this table, we had a bout of changes directly linked to the mediation until January 17. My impression was that they were fair since it was all per agreement. Then, on Jan 19, Freedom skies edited the article (in 3 edits) without discussion. That started an escalation from which we did not recover until Utcursch took over. &mdash; Sebastian 07:02, 21 March 2007 (UTC)