Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Bjweeks

Edit count for Bjweeks
User:Bjweeks

run at Tue Jun 17 01:50:50 2008 GMT

Category:             11 Help:                 1 Image talk:           1 Image:                180 Mainspace             5053 Portal:               5 Talk:                 368 Template talk:        8 Template:             342 User talk:            2585 User:                 429 Wikipedia talk:       85 Wikipedia:            728 avg edits per page    1.60 earliest              04:39, 11 November 2005 number of unique pages 6120 total                 9796

2005/11 3  2005/12 1   2006/1  3   2006/2  0   2006/3  0   2006/4  0   2006/5  0   2006/6  0   2006/7  0   2006/8  0   2006/9  54   2006/10 358   2006/11 324   2006/12 431   2007/1  1005   2007/2  1781   2007/3  145   2007/4  12   2007/5  3   2007/6  4   2007/7  6   2007/8  2   2007/9  1   2007/10 1   2007/11 10   2007/12 220   2008/1  2809   2008/2  357   2008/3  947   2008/4  182   2008/5  334   2008/6  803

(green denotes edits with an edit summary (even an automatic one), red  denotes edits without an edit summary)

Mainspace 67 [2]List of commercial voice over IP network providers 56 [3]Counter-Strike 53 [4]Counter-Strike: Source 53 [5]Asterisk (PBX) 50 [6]Desert Ridge High School 33 [7]Battlefield 2 29 [8]Voice over Internet Protocol 29 [9]Steam (content delivery) 27 [10]TeamSpeak 23 [11]Anonymous (group) 22 [12]Desert Ridge Junior High School 21 [13]Barry Goldwater High School 20 [14]Sveasoft 19 [15]Highland High School (Gilbert, Arizona) 18 [16]Woodinville High School

Talk: 59 [17]Project Chanology 12 [18]ZDaemon 11 [19]Steam (content delivery) 11 [20]Burma 11 [21]Mac OS X v10.6 10 [22]Desert Ridge High School 9 [23]Linksys WRT54G series 8 [24]Mac OS X   7  [25]Sveasoft 6 [26]IPhone 6 [27]Epinephrine 5 [28]Mayo Clinic 5 [29]Aliz�e 5 [30]Asterisk (PBX) 5 [31]Barry Goldwater High School

Category: 2 [32]WikiProject Video games members

Image: 4 [33]Safari (web browser).png 3 [34]Fifi La Fume.png 3 [35]Atlantic Records.png 2 [36]Iron Butterfly In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida Riff.PNG 2 [37]Alf t.jpg 2 [38]Ten t.jpg 2 [39]TenGen t.jpg 2 [40]Honda-logo.svg 2 [41]General t.jpg 2 [42]DCFC0014.JPG 2 [43]The Woodsman movie poster.jpg 2 [44]TheScreamersScream.ogg 2 [45]Major t.jpg 2 [46]TCor t.jpg 2 [47]GEC-Marconi.JPG

Portal: 2 [48]Schools/Things you can do

Template: 5 [49]Maharashtra 5 [50]District 2AAAA 5 [51]Apple software 3 [52]Abercrombiefitch 3 [53]PRODNote 3 [54]Infobox Law enforcement agency/doc 3 [55]Hellenic Navy 3 [56]User RSAF 3 [57]PakistanCities 3 [58]Ranks and Insignia of NATO Navies/OF/United Kingdom 3 [59]ECMAScript 3 [60]Mac OS History 3 [61]Modern Honda vehicles 2 [62]Ranks and Insignia of NATO Air Forces/OF/Portugal 2 [63]Irish Free State

Template talk: 2 [64]WW2InfoBox

User: 108 [65]Bjweeks/monobook.js  77  [66]Bjweeks 76 [67]Bjweeks/Sandbox 32 [68]BJBot 17 [69]Bjweeks/monobook.css 6  [70]BJBot/BotStatus 5  [71]BJBot/Optout 5  [72]Gowrathxd 4  [73]NotifyBot 4  [74]Bjweeks/Navbar 3  [75]Java7837/userboxing/atheist2 3  [76]Java7837/userboxing/atheist 3  [77]Nomorespin2005 3  [78]Dell970 3  [79]BJBot/Status

User talk: 137 [80]Bjweeks 96 [81]BJBot 16 [82]PANONIAN 9  [83]Bjweeks/Archive 1 7  [84]Sidonuke 7  [85]Misplaced canadian 7  [86]Tcdoom 6  [87]Lufthmark 6  [88]Deryck Chan/Archive 9 6  [89]68.2.162.200   6   [90]Betacommand 5  [91]Calltech 5  [92]85.148.176.54   5   [93]Tokachu 4  [94]122.164.197.255

Wikipedia: 87 [95]Administrator intervention against vandalism 34 [96]Bots/Requests for approval 28 [97]Bot owners' noticeboard 19 [98]Bot requests 15 [99]Bots/Requests for approval/BJBot 4 14 [100]Huggle/Whitelist 13 [101]Bots/Requests for approval/BJBot 12 [102]Editor review/Bjweeks 12 [103]Bots/Requests for approval/BJBot 3 12 [104]Possibly unfree images 8 [105]Articles for deletion/Anonymous (group) 8 [106]Bots/Requests for approval/BJBot 5 8 [107]Articles for deletion/Desert Combat Extended (2nd nomination) 8 [108]Requests for page protection 8 [109]Articles for deletion/Project Chanology

Wikipedia talk: 14 [110]Bot policy 13 [111]Bot Approvals Group 9 [112]Requests for adminship 7 [113]Bots/Requests for approval 6 [114]WikiProject Arizona 5 [115]Articles for deletion/22nd century warfare 5 [116]WikiProject Amateur radio 4 [117]WikiProject Automobiles/Archive 11 4 [118]Images and media for deletion 3 [119]AutoWikiBrowser 2 [120]Requests for rollback 2 [121]Possibly unfree images 2 [122]WikiProject Schools 2 [123]Criteria for speedy deletion

If there were any problems, please [124]email Interiot or post at  [125]User talk:Interiot.


 * The edit count was retrieved from this link at 01:50, 17 June 2008 (UTC).

How successful is successful?
The final tally was: 83%: 94 supports 17%: 19 Opposes 00%: 5 Neutrals

83% support doesn't seem like enough to successfully appoint an admin, considering the relative strength of the support & oppose !votes. Looked at another way, 20% of those expressing an opinion on this RfA

Removing !votes without stated reasons yields: 79%: 67 supports (Subtracted 29%, !votes 2,3,4,5,15,27,30,31,32,33,48,50,55,60,63,65,67,71,73,74,78,81,82,89,90,91,93) 21%: 18 Opposes (Subtracted 5%, !vote 15) 00%: 5 Neutrals

Without discounting me too & per xxx !votes or discounting !votes that don't explicitly state a reason, 30% of the candidate's support is discountable as being without a stated rationale. Only 5% of the oppose !votes could be similarly discounted. This is a very weak consensus, and I worry that a newfound ability to delete outright (rather than propose deletion), coupled with a history of communication difficulties, particularly regarding content removal, is not int he best interest of the project.

Bj has a demonstrable knowledge of image policy; I question why that is used overwhelmingly to delete content rather than improve it and make it keepable. I hope we've made a good decision in adding this admin, but I suspect we haven't honored community sentiment, particularly the consensus-defeating 20% minority who don't find Bj to be a good candidate for adminship at this time. --SSBohio 15:29, 27 June 2008 (UTC)