Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/FlyingToaster

FlyingToaster's edit stats using Soxred93's tool as of 07:52, 20 February 2009 (UTC):

Username: FlyingToaster User groups: rollbacker First edit: Mar 31, 2006 02:43:52 Unique articles edited: 7,319 Average edits per page: 1.91 Total edits (including deleted): 13,996 Deleted edits: 3,599 Live edits: 10,397 Namespace totals Article	4049	28.93% Talk	154	1.10% User	298	2.13% User talk	5133	36.67% Wikipedia	511	3.65% Wikipedia talk	20	0.14% File	189	1.35% File talk	1	0.01% MediaWiki talk	1	0.01% Template	21	0.15% Help	2	0.01% Category	14	0.10% Category talk	1	0.01% Portal	3	0.02% Month counts 2006/03	3	2006/04	2	2006/05	0	2006/06	3	2006/07	77	2006/08	3	2006/09	0	2006/10	13	2006/11	15	2006/12	0	2007/01	0	2007/02	1	2007/03	6	2007/04	12	2007/05	1	2007/06	0	2007/07	5	2007/08	2	2007/09	8	2007/10	1	2007/11	0	2007/12	1	2008/01	3	2008/02	1	2008/03	0	2008/04	1	2008/05	5	2008/06	53	2008/07	53	2008/08	33	2008/09	670	2008/10	2456	2008/11	2514	2008/12	1242	2009/01	1730	2009/02	1483	Logs Pages patrolled: 5695 Files uploaded: 97 Top edited articles Article

* 22 - Derren_Brown * 21 - John_Morrow_(peace_activist) * 19 - Jett_Loe * 19 - BART_Police_shooting_of_Oscar_Grant * 18 - Corrymeela_Community * 16 - Letter_To_America * 16 - Trevor_Williams_(bishop) * 14 - Just_for_Laughs_(UK_TV_series) * 12 - Keith_Law_(comedian) * 11 - Wild_Rover_Productions

Talk

* 7 - Barack_Obama * 6 - Hillary_Rodham_Clinton * 6 - BART_Police_shooting_of_Oscar_Grant * 5 - Pat_Finucane_Centre * 5 - Corrymeela_Community * 4 - Capriopholis * 4 - Fishing_with_spoons * 3 - List_of_fictional_demons * 3 - Transhumanism * 2 - Irish_School_of_Ecumenics

User

* 123 - FlyingToaster * 33 - FlyingToaster/monobook.js   * 10 - FlyingToaster/sandbox5 * 10 - GlassCobra/Editor_for_deletion * 6 - FlyingToaster/sandbox1 * 5 - FlyingToaster/sandbox3 * 5 - FlyingToaster/sandbox4 * 4 - Theripper42/WIT_Draft * 4 - Theripper42/Sandbox * 4 - Linuxguymarshall/François_Ponchaud

User talk

* 132 - FlyingToaster * 22 - MidKnightHunter * 20 - David_Ballantine * 15 - Gonzonoir * 12 - Rezanasab * 12 - QCAnalist * 11 - Team_BBN * 11 - Daniel_Bengrave * 9 - Adeeb610887890 * 9 - Tjhill

Wikipedia

* 117 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism * 76 - Usernames_for_administrator_attention * 10 - Meetup/San_Francisco_9 * 10 - Articles_for_deletion/Boxxy * 9 - WikiProject_Spoken_Wikipedia * 8 - Requested_articles/Philosophy * 7 - Administrators'_noticeboard * 7 - Most_wanted_articles * 7 - Sockpuppet_investigations/Team_BBN * 6 - Articles_for_deletion/David_Karle

Wikipedia talk

* 6 - Criteria_for_speedy_deletion * 5 - Twinkle/Bugs * 3 - Twinkle * 2 - WikiProject_Northern_Ireland * 1 - Requests_for_comment/Roux * 1 - WikiProject_Database_analysis * 1 - WikiProject_New_York_City_Public_Transportation * 1 - AutoWikiBrowser/CheckPage

File

* 4 - Tian_Tan_Buddha_stairs2.jpg * 4 - Corrymeela_logo.png * 3 - Wild_rover_logo.png * 3 - Edgar_allen_poe_recording.ogg * 3 - Yalex01.jpg * 3 - KateRusbylive.jpg * 3 - An_army_worm_on_fabric.jpg * 3 - Williams.jpg * 3 - John_Morrow.JPG * 3 - HolodomorCalgary.jpg

File talk

* 1 - Squawcreekmissouri.JPG

MediaWiki talk

* 1 - Uploadtext

Template

* 7 - X8   * 2 - X9    * 2 - X1    * 2 - Northern_Ireland_tasks * 1 - Huggle/warn-4 * 1 - Huggle/warn-3 * 1 - Huggle/warn-1 * 1 - X3   * 1 - Icon-issues * 1 - Obama_cabinet

Help

* 1 - Reverting * 1 - Archiving_a_talk_page

Category

* 6 - Mozilla_people * 5 - Mozilla_developers * 1 - Maltese_prehistory * 1 - Weapons_of_Croatia * 1 - Pokémon_characters

Category talk

* 1 - Mozilla_people

Portal

* 1 - Contents/Categorical_index/Culture_and_the_arts * 1 - Wicca/Wicca_topics * 1 - Science

SoWhy's oppose

 * 1) Oppose Good user but I would not trust her with the mop at the moment. She wants to work in speedy deletion but her tagging is less than good. Let me elaborate:
 * 2) *Mistaken A1 for an article with clear context
 * 3) *A7 on an article that makes claims of notability (owner of multiple newspapers)
 * 4) *A3 one minute after creation (another one like that, here an A7)
 * 5) *A7 on article with clear claims of notability
 * 6) *Good faith attempt at a game report but no test page
 * 7) *A7 on an article about someone who has a notable school named in his honor (that should be enough claim of notability to fail A7)
 * 8) *Incorrect G11 (how can sth be advertising if the product is not sold anymore?)
 * 9) *A1 with clear context (Another one)
 * And that is just within the last week (and I left out most of those where she realized her mistake). We have a shortage of admins at CSD, I know that, I cleared CAT:CSD the last days almost alone for several hours. But I cannot support someone to help with it if they make such basic mistakes so frequently. The candidate seems overeager to delete on sight and I fear she will continue with such mistakes when allowed to delete herself. At the moment I advise against this candidate, although it is a pity given the good contributions overall. But this is too grave to overlook. Regards  So Why  10:35, 20 February 2009 (UTC)
 * Comment - SoWhy - Thank you for your feedback. As Neurolysis mentioned, I do a ton of CSD'ing each day, and definitely I make some mistakes along the way.  Whenever this happens, I try to as fast as possible fix the mistake, apologize to all involved, and explain what happened if a user is confused.  And definitely, if a hangon tag is present, I will investigate the subject again to try and find the notability or content that the article in its first form could not convey.
 * That said, while the CSD criteria are reasonably well defined, deciding if something meets the criteria and which one can be open to interpretation. Many of the diffs you provided are edge cases which I think can simply be interpreted differently, so I'd like to address them individually:
 * Mistaken A1 for an article with clear context I do believe this could qualify in sufficient lacking in context, as the only tie that this entry provides to the world is a name with no Wikipedia article.
 * A7 on an article that makes claims of notability (owner of multiple newspapers) This one is definitely an edge-case, and certainly it could be argued that owning newspapers is an indication of why the subject is important.  For this reason, when the user made an edit to my talk page asking about the tag, I declined my own speedy and instead helped wikify and source the article.  I also want to point out that the A7 tag is not exactly a mark of the subject being notable, but rather if there is any indication of why the subject is important.  It's a slightly lower standard than notability, which is often more suited to an AfD or Prod.
 * A3 one minute after creation (another one like that, here an A7) The question here is time (this article was marked quickly) rather than the tag (the article indeed had no content). The reason I am willing to mark pages for speedy deletion very shortly after creation is because speedy is just that - a tag for deletion, not deletion itself.  It alerts the article creator that something is wrong, and gives them the chance to correct it (via the hangon tag, another edit, using the talk page, using my talk page, etc).  This is very different than deleting an article very quickly, which I feel that admins should not do (except in cases of vandalism, attack, nonsense, etc).  My personal take is that if a page qualifies for speedy, it should be marked as such without need for much delay.  Then the editor should be given time to contest it or to fix it, and if that fails then the article will be deleted.  After all, an editor is warned when creating a page that "an article without references will likely be deleted quickly."
 * A7 on article with clear claims of notability I applied the tag here because while the claim itself would indicate notability, I searched for the name of the person and could find absolutely no evidence that they exist. I can see how you could argue that since the article provides a claim to notability and the problem is that the person in question appears not to meet that claim, a PROD or AfD explaining this would have been more appropriate.
 * Good faith attempt at a game report but no test page I agree with my tagging here, but I definitely think this is an edge case that could be interpreted a few  ways.  I applied the test speedy tag because the content appeared to be some sort of copy/paste from a blog or other article without any indication the author was trying to format the page like an article.
 * A7 on an article about someone who has a notable school named in his honor (that should be enough claim of notability to fail A7) This one is truly my mistake - I did not notice that the name of on school mentioned was the same as the subject of the article.
 * Incorrect G11 (how can sth be advertising if the product is not sold anymore?) My opinion is that advertising is no more appropriate if the item in question is hard or impossible to purchase - it's more a concern of tone and style.  The test of the G1 tag is whether an article "exclusively promotes some entity and that would need to be fundamentally rewritten to become encyclopedic" - not whether an attempt is necessarily being made to sell the reader the item.  Incidentally, I personally feel that articles written as advertisements should be either deleted or the POV parts removed until they can be substantially rewritten.  That's why, after this speedy tag was declined, I came back and removed some of the advertising language and helped to wikify it.
 * A1 with clear context I think the context here is questionable - I read the link that was provided before I applied the speedy tag and could not verify the source to be notable or true in any way.  (Another one) I must admit I did not understand the context here and thought the page might be nonsense.  That's why I removed my own CSD tag when the editor provided enough information (the subject pharmacology) for me to identify it.
 * In summary, the process of patrolling new pages is unfortunately never cut/dry black/white, and the ones above I feel are for the most part edge cases which could be interpreted and marked different ways. I suppose what I'd point out two things.  First, in many of the above cases where a speedy deletion tag is declined, you'll see I go back to that article and try to wikify/tag it to meet Wikipedia standards.  My motivation is not purely deleting bad content on Wikipedia, but making sure the content here is good - so if an article about a notable subject is written as advertising, I'm happy to fix the article and have it stay rather than delete it.  Secondly, I want to point out that, as I mentioned, I feel there's an important difference between marking pages for deletion and actually deleting them.  Honestly, I think people should mark pages for deletion more liberally than they would actually delete them, and if I become an admin this will be the tack I take.  As an admin, rather than quickly deleting many pages as fast as I mark them for deletion today, I would give the editor time to fix whatever problem was called out and err on the side of improving an article to Wikipedia standards rather than deleting it.  I see marking a page for speedy as the first line of defense to flag a problem, but actually deleting a page is the final say and I think all effort must be given to take each case individually and make a decision fairly.   Flying  Toaster  11:39, 20 February 2009 (UTC)
 * I know you do, I decline a bunch of them every time I go through CAT:CSD, that's the reason for this oppose in the first place. You are a good editor but you are too trigger-happy with the delete-tags. Putting a speedy tag on an article is a very BITEy act in itself (not jsut the deletion) and you should avoid any doubtful taggings in the first place. Some creators do not check their article all the time and when they realize it was deleted, they will feel bitten (and unfortunately there are a couple of admins who are less inclined to check if the tagging was correct). If you went around deleting those articles, I fear there will be an increase of such frustration. It's not that you are not willing to fix the article, it's that you are not willing to do it BEFORE you tag it for deletion.
 * As for the diffs, let's me explain in the order:
 * "is a movie" is context enough, because it tells you what the article is about. As WP:CSD says, context != content.
 * I know what A7 is, that's the reason you made a mistake. It's about whether there might be a chance that the subject meets the inclusion guidelines and here there was. Owning 35 nation-wide newspapers is quite a claim not only of importance but also of notability.
 * See my text above. Fast-tagging without allowing the people time to write something is BITEy and smells of WP:DEMOLISH.
 * Exactly my point. An article does not have to prove notability nor do you have to do a Google Search or anything. Just a claim of notability is enough.
 * If it's copy+paste from somewhere, it's G12. But it was no way a test page.
 * Glad you realized.
 * G11 is not advertising, not POV. It is BLATANT advertising. This article just had a single word ("excellent") that was POV, the rest was clearly no advertising.
 * The link does not have to be true. The context was clear: "...is a fighting claw". As for the other one, a short wiki search for "receptor" and "albumin" makes the context crystal clear but it was clear before. A1 is not for cases in which some people might not understand what an article is about, it's for cases in which the text does not give any clue at all what it is about.
 * I don't think there was much room for interpretation in all of these cases, they were pretty simple if one does not stretch WP:CSD. As I said above, you need to try to improve first and tag later, not the other way around (that's why we have WP:BEFORE at AFD) and I disagree with a liberal approach because we unfortunately have our fair share of admins who just delete what was tagged without checking it further. Any mistagging that occurs because of this approach might be equal to a deletion if one of them happens to stumble upon the page.
 * In conclusion, I would happy support a new RFA in a few months, after you have understood why I have those concerns. You have to forgive me that I can only judge your contributions at the moment, not your assurance you will change your behavior as an admin. Because there is no indication in the contributions for that. Regards  So Why  12:09, 20 February 2009 (UTC)
 * I don't think there was much room for interpretation in all of these cases, they were pretty simple if one does not stretch WP:CSD. As I said above, you need to try to improve first and tag later, not the other way around (that's why we have WP:BEFORE at AFD) and I disagree with a liberal approach because we unfortunately have our fair share of admins who just delete what was tagged without checking it further. Any mistagging that occurs because of this approach might be equal to a deletion if one of them happens to stumble upon the page.
 * In conclusion, I would happy support a new RFA in a few months, after you have understood why I have those concerns. You have to forgive me that I can only judge your contributions at the moment, not your assurance you will change your behavior as an admin. Because there is no indication in the contributions for that. Regards  So Why  12:09, 20 February 2009 (UTC)
 * In conclusion, I would happy support a new RFA in a few months, after you have understood why I have those concerns. You have to forgive me that I can only judge your contributions at the moment, not your assurance you will change your behavior as an admin. Because there is no indication in the contributions for that. Regards  So Why  12:09, 20 February 2009 (UTC)

Flying Toaster's detailed record of successful vs. unsuccessful deletions
between 00:00, 9 February 2009 and 20:34, 24 February 2009:
 * Pages deleted:
 * 1) JayDUB. -- WP:CSD A7
 * 2) Bob Wunnicke -- WP:CSD A7
 * 3) Slicedcheese -- WP:CSD G10
 * 4) Rakesh Pashupatimath -- WP:CSD A7
 * 5) No cross -- WP:CSD A3
 * 6) Wetechnology -- WP:PROD
 * 7) Goldarama.com -- WP:CSD A7
 * 8) TheBrutalTruth -- WP:CSD A7
 * 9) Art Cogswell -- WP:CSD A7
 * 10) Tanalbit -- WP:CSD G12
 * 11) Dvd to 3gp converter free -- WP:CSD G1
 * 12) Chennai Social Service -- WP:CSD G11
 * 13) HookahDomain -- WP:PROD
 * 14) Sally Davis -- WP:CSD G10
 * 15) Michael Blake (legend) -- WP:CSD A7
 * 16) Andrew Mason Robey -- WP:CSD G10
 * 17) Twinkydude -- WP:CSD G1
 * 18) Battle (album) -- WP:CSD G1
 * 19) Gupta Clan -- WP:PROD
 * 20) Steve Terada -- WP:CSD G12
 * 21) Nicolas R. Danjon -- WP:CSD A7
 * 22) General DarthLlamas -- WP:CSD G1
 * 23) Kingdom of Kez -- WP:CSD G3
 * 24) Ina Marie Chua -- WP:CSD A7
 * 25) Viscultus -- WP:PROD
 * 26) Necromunda Bible -- WP:CSD G11
 * 27) Bryan Mahesh -- WP:CSD A7
 * 28) Amara Pagano -- WP:CSD A7
 * 29) Gerald malvin -- WP:CSD A7
 * 30) Veins in Plants -- WP:CSD A1
 * 31) Jared mendelsohn -- WP:CSD G10
 * 32) JohnDecyk -- WP:CSD G10
 * 33) Garland insurance -- WP:CSD G11
 * 34) Joseph Thomas Waterfall -- WP:CSD G10
 * 35) Lil Fred Haywood -- WP:CSD A7
 * 36) Lil Fred Haywood -- WP:CSD A7
 * 37) Tinumsinum -- WP:CSD G3
 * 38) Tinumsinum -- WP:CSD G3
 * 39) The jmwalkrs -- WP:CSD A7
 * 40) Coco Sunday -- WP:CSD A7
 * 41) Lachlan heath -- WP:CSD G1
 * 42) Yes Boss FM -- WP:PROD
 * 43) Nerius -- WP:CSD G3
 * 44) Ciara whillock -- WP:CSD A7
 * 45) Stupid spaghetti goats -- WP:CSD G1
 * 46) Simon walter -- WP:CSD G3
 * 47) Glenn Bradford -- WP:CSD G11
 * 48) List of charactures from Rock & Roll Reality -- WP:PROD
 * 49) Logan and Jacinta Felderman -- WP:CSD G10
 * 50) Michael agerone -- WP:CSD A7
 * 51) Quentin Yarolem -- WP:CSD A7
 * 52) The Fantasy Sports Channel -- WP:PROD
 * 53) Crazy wave productions -- WP:CSD A7
 * 54) Lisaghmore -- WP:CSD G10
 * 55) Ash Archer -- WP:CSD A7
 * 56) Luke bennett -- WP:CSD G1
 * 57) Jonathan Dornel -- WP:CSD A7
 * 58) Viorica Bujor -- WP:CSD A7
 * 59) Mhazizi -- WP:CSD A7
 * 60) Line 6 (band) -- WP:CSD A7
 * 61) Elite Home Tutoring -- WP:PROD
 * 62) Oguzhan Avci -- (marking db-person)
 * 63) Oguzhan Avci -- WP:CSD G7
 * 64) Sean Moyles -- WP:PROD
 * 65) Matt Keto -- WP:PROD
 * 66) John chy -- WP:CSD A7
 * 67) Vinc Carter -- WP:PROD
 * 68) The Antiks -- WP:CSD G3
 * 69) Anjula -- WP:CSD A7
 * 70) Nathan comber -- WP:CSD A7
 * 71) Shut your mane -- WP:CSD G1
 * 72) Jethro collins -- WP:CSD A7
 * 73) Brayden renner -- WP:CSD A7
 * 74) Channel 5 News Broadcast by Jmac Film Studios -- WP:CSD G1
 * 75) بنيان -- WP:CSD A3
 * 76) Future Planning -- WP:CSD A7
 * 77) Gupta Clan -- WP:CSD G1
 * 78) RifJet -- WP:CSD A7
 * 79) Adrian Volts -- FlyingToaster first tagged for speedy; editor removed tag so he tagged for PROD and the editor removed the tag. FlyingToaster took to AfD: Articles for deletion/Adrian Volts and an admin speedied it
 * 80) RifJet -- WP:CSD A7
 * 81) Chris McNally -- WP:CSD G10
 * 82) Mr nau -- WP:CSD A7
 * 83) Shy-D -- WP:CSD A7
 * 84) Bookmykhana -- WP:CSD G11
 * 85) Liam kerr -- WP:CSD G10
 * 86) Urizon -- WP:CSD A1
 * 87) EcoSystem Generation III -- WP:CSD G12
 * 88) EcoSystem Generation III -- WP:CSD G11
 * 89) Kairos society -- WP:CSD G12
 * 90) Pineta park -- WP:CSD G11
 * 91) Bookmykhana -- WP:CSD G11
 * 92) Aftek Infosys -- WP:CSD A7
 * 93) Kairos society -- WP:CSD A7
 * 94) Falkirk ghg -- WP:CSD A7
 * 95) EcoSystem Generation III -- WP:CSD G12
 * 96) Jan Majdzik -- WP:CSD A7
 * 97) Brentwood Elvers RLFC -- WP:CSD A7
 * 98) Mitchell lugg -- WP:CSD A7
 * 99) Ellis relocation -- WP:CSD A7
 * 100) GFXRealm -- WP:CSD A7
 * 101) Toyvia -- WP:CSD G1
 * 102) Apocalyptic Penguins -- WP:CSD A7
 * 103) The DVG Group -- WP:CSD G11
 * 104) Test Toontown -- WP:CSD A1
 * 105) The DVG Group -- WP:CSD G11
 * 106) Bambi VanBurch -- WP:CSD A7
 * 107) Welch nissan -- WP:CSD G10
 * 108) Adrian Volts -- WP:PROD
 * 109) Jordie leal -- WP:CSD G10
 * 110) Cup Fiesta -- WP:PROD
 * 111) Twayne -- WP:CSD A7
 * 112) Barbara Murray (disambiguation) -- WP:CSD A3
 * 113) Shoshana Wasserman -- WP:CSD A7
 * 114) Jordie leal -- WP:CSD G10
 * 115) Adrian Volts -- WP:CSD G3
 * 116) Modern Records artists -- WP:CSD A3
 * 117) Glacial respiration -- Articles for deletion/Glacial respiration
 * 118) Heather elyse turney -- WP:CSD A7
 * 119) Karan lineswala -- WP:CSD G10
 * 120) Prodego -- WP:CSD G10
 * 121) Patts College of Aeronautics -- WP:CSD G12
 * 122) Neil Guterman -- WP:CSD A7
 * 123) 7th Cadian- Imperial Guard regiment. -- WP:CSD A1
 * 124) Confederacy of Brite Meadows -- WP:CSD A7
 * 125) Volter -- WP:CSD G1
 * 126) Cesar A. Martinez -- WP:CSD A3
 * 127) The Absolute -- WP:CSD G1
 * 128) Combat heaven -- WP:CSD A7
 * 129) The Boy Done Good -- WP:CSD A7
 * 130) Great Northeast Passage -- WP:CSD G1
 * 131) Rommel ian dela cruz -- WP:CSD A7
 * 132) Christopher F. Hartwell -- WP:CSD G12
 * 133) The Streets (Concept Character) -- WP:CSD A1
 * 134) Wixpert -- WP:CSD A7
 * 135) Pablo9 -- WP:CSD R3
 * 136) Jazzy Aces -- WP:PROD
 * 137) Federal Envelope Company -- WP:CSD A7
 * 138) Fishers Island Club -- WP:CSD A7
 * 139) Chris Friel -- WP:CSD G10
 * 140) Empora Virtual Airlines -- WP:CSD A7
 * 141) JD Naayen -- WP:CSD G10
 * 142) Vermillion lies -- WP:CSD A7
 * 143) Jun Seok Oh -- WP:CSD A7
 * 144) Soulville Band -- WP:CSD A7
 * 145) Red bedroom records -- WP:CSD A7
 * 146) 30secondcarmasta -- WP:CSD A7
 * 147) Thesoulvilleband -- WP:CSD G1
 * 148) Lerpis Syndrome -- WP:CSD G10
 * 149) The Thong Lunch Table -- WP:CSD A7
 * 150) Elle + anya -- WP:CSD G1
 * 151) Jazno Francouer -- WP:CSD A7
 * 152) Ourlord -- WP:CSD A7
 * 153) Vanilla bear -- WP:CSD A7
 * 154) Lina Rozbih -- WP:CSD A7
 * 155) Salmon Unlimited of Wisconsin -- WP:CSD G11
 * 156) Kurukshetra film -- WP:CSD A1
 * 157) Bravo Location Rentals -- WP:CSD A7
 * 158) Mr Mudie -- WP:CSD G10
 * 159) Kirk Weddle -- WP:CSD A7
 * 160) Kevin Starkweather -- WP:CSD G11
 * 161) Kirepapa -- WP:CSD A1
 * 162) Kirepapa -- WP:CSD A1
 * 163) Woodlands Cheerleading -- WP:CSD A7
 * 164) Tommy firefly -- WP:CSD A7
 * 165) Table Decoration -- WP:CSD G12
 * 166) Jiglabob -- WP:CSD G10
 * 167) Salt Candles -- WP:CSD G11
 * 168) Mona elgohail -- WP:CSD G3
 * 169) Patrick C Ramsey -- WP:CSD A9
 * 170) Jungle bhoys -- WP:CSD A1
 * 171) The Shirley Clarke Team -- WP:CSD G11
 * 172) Amelialism -- WP:CSD G1
 * 173) Amelialism -- WP:CSD G1
 * 174) Jim and camz clips -- WP:CSD A7
 * 175) New orleans pressure washing -- WP:CSD G7
 * 176) New orleans pressure washing -- WP:CSD G11
 * 177) Board Game Variations -- WP:CSD A7
 * 178) Seend C Team -- WP:CSD A7
 * 179) Kamel Saada -- WP:CSD A7
 * 180) Ryan Doughton -- WP:CSD A7
 * 181) Olga Sherer -- WP:CSD A1
 * 182) Walker Laurence(OLTL) -- WP:CSD A7
 * 183) Subasri -- WP:CSD G10
 * 184) Salt Candles -- WP:CSD G11
 * 185) Jordan ovalle -- WP:CSD A7
 * 186) Zoogle -- WP:CSD G11
 * 187) Bold for Delphi -- WP:CSD G11
 * 188) PrizeTime -- WP:CSD A3
 * 189) Dreamtion -- WP:CSD G11
 * 190) Zoogle -- WP:CSD A7
 * 191) Frederick O'Neal wrestler -- WP:CSD A7
 * 192) Samsung Tocco -- WP:CSD G1
 * 193) PrizeTime -- WP:CSD G11
 * 194) Animals From The Heart -- WP:CSD G11
 * 195) Agrotated -- WP:CSD G1
 * 196) Chris Spalding -- WP:CSD G10
 * 197) PrizeTime -- WP:CSD A3
 * 198) Bear Wrestling -- WP:CSD G3
 * 199) Petland -- WP:CSD A7
 * 200) The African Post -- WP:CSD G11
 * 201) Rasheed Smith -- WP:CSD A7
 * 202) Jacob read -- WP:CSD G3
 * 203) SAS: Secure Tomorrow -- WP:CSD G11
 * 204) James Bowers -- WP:CSD G11
 * 205) [[File:City Skyline of Toronto.jpg]] -- WP:CSD G3
 * 206) Matt Stajoke -- WP:CSD G10
 * 207) Nikolai Kulejoke -- WP:CSD G10
 * 208) Pavel Kubjokea -- WP:CSD G10
 * 209) Sean Soroka -- WP:CSD A7
 * 210) Hamilton Vegetarian Society -- WP:CSD A7
 * 211) Goodman's GDB12 -- WP:CSD G2
 * 212) Sam Robson -- WP:CSD A7
 * 213) Peter Nevill -- WP:CSD A7
 * 214) Continental Airlines Flight 3407 Buffalo -- WP:CSD G3
 * 215) Alan Threlfall -- WP:CSD A7
 * 216) Jimmeh -- WP:CSD A7
 * 217) Graham Cox -- WP:CSD A7
 * 218) Sean "the Eskimo" Quinn -- WP:CSD G3
 * 219) Cherie Moss -- WP:CSD G10
 * 220) The Flok -- WP:CSD A7
 * 221) Limited ink -- WP:CSD G11
 * 222) Full House Marketing -- WP:CSD A7
 * 223) D.Style Muzik -- WP:CSD A7
 * 224) Citizens For The 2nd Amendment -- WP:CSD G11
 * 225) Utility shield -- WP:CSD G11
 * 226) Ahmad Hamadeh -- WP:CSD A7
 * 227) Nebb -- WP:CSD A7
 * 228) Matty Harrison -- WP:CSD G10
 * 229) Mr. Pazant -- WP:CSD A7
 * 230) Killa WOlfy -- WP:CSD A7
 * 231) John macdavid -- WP:CSD A7
 * 232) Usmaan Azam -- WP:CSD A7
 * 233) Fuel Characteristic Classification System -- WP:CSD G12
 * 234) Tiger person -- WP:CSD G1
 * 235) Hotel palm beach -- WP:CSD G11
 * 236) Entertainment store group -- WP:CSD G11
 * 237) R.Gopakumar -- WP:PROD
 * 238) HAProxy -- WP:CSD G11
 * 239) Apdhte -- WP:CSD A7
 * 240) Muthalik -- WP:CSD A1
 * 241) Ready Set Go! -- WP:CSD A7
 * 242) Euw -- WP:CSD G1
 * 243) Tal Roma -- WP:CSD A7
 * 244) Katie Farmer -- WP:CSD G10
 * 245) Kaylin Brodzki -- WP:CSD A7
 * 246) Inuyashasapphire -- WP:CSD A7
 * 247) Dr.Jan Kefer -- WP:CSD A7
 * 248) Fishing with spoons -- WP:CSD A7 -- subsequently recreated
 * 249) Theory of natural falsification -- WP:PROD
 * 250) Jay talaviya -- WP:CSD A7
 * 251) InuYashaSapphire -- WP:CSD A7
 * 252) Oracle history -- WP:CSD G1
 * 253) Cameron Ferguson -- WP:CSD G10
 * 254) Donald Jeffries -- WP:CSD A7
 * 255) Atozmarket -- WP:CSD G11
 * 256) Brookvale:Example -- WP:CSD G11
 * 257) Inuyashasapphire -- WP:CSD A7
 * 258) Resultrix -- WP:CSD G11
 * 259) Bluntedsultan -- WP:CSD A7
 * 260) Jamie christine call -- WP:CSD A7
 * 261) Hotelingo -- WP:CSD A7
 * 262) Dr.Ghulam Asghar Shar -- WP:CSD A7
 * 263) Broccoli King -- WP:CSD G3
 * 264) Henry lee johnson -- WP:CSD A7
 * 265) Insta-bail -- WP:CSD G1
 * 266) Nikhila sayani -- WP:CSD A7
 * 267) Feed the geese -- WP:CSD A7
 * 268) Shakti himalaya -- WP:CSD G11
 * 269) William Joseph Brunt -- WP:CSD A7
 * 270) Nicholas Brooks -- WP:CSD A7
 * 271) Alex Reid (martial arts) -- WP:CSD A7
 * 272) Arrowhead high school biology class -- WP:CSD G3
 * 273) Conan Jadotte -- WP:CSD A7
 * 274) Josephine spitale -- WP:CSD A3
 * 275) Dark Alley Media -- WP:CSD A3
 * 276) Stephen Dyson -- WP:CSD A7
 * 277) TalentTrove.com -- WP:CSD G11
 * 278) Sgwritings -- WP:CSD A7
 * 279) Michael mobilia -- WP:CSD G10
 * 280) The Galvatron -- WP:PROD
 * 281) Nemesis airsoft -- WP:CSD G11
 * 282) We Smoke Fags -- WP:CSD A7
 * 283) St. Youstus El Anthoni -- WP:CSD A7
 * 284) The Galvatron -- WP:PROD
 * 285) Four Star Records artists -- WP:CSD A3
 * 286) Jeremy Meng -- WP:CSD A7
 * 287) Andrew Kullman -- WP:CSD A7
 * 288) Avalanche Triangle -- WP:CSD A3
 * 289) Mike Fain -- WP:CSD A7
 * 290) The Tillett man -- WP:CSD A7
 * 291) Swamp Gravy -- WP:CSD A7 -- subsequently recreated
 * 292) ML Strawn -- WP:CSD A7
 * 293) Physical Grafiti (film) -- WP:CSD A1
 * 294) Talk:Albert Castillo -- WP:CSD G8
 * 295) Sconce (insult) -- WP:CSD G1
 * 296) Albert Castillo -- WP:CSD A7
 * 297) ManishJainDBA -- WP:CSD G2
 * 298) Sea snarks -- WP:CSD G1
 * 299) Nashville Film Institute -- WP:CSD A1
 * 300) Nathaniel Cariagago -- WP:CSD A7
 * 301) B.S.S.O.S. -- WP:CSD A7
 * 302) Tsui Sun Yu -- WP:CSD A1
 * 303) Eleanor robinson -- WP:CSD G10
 * 304) Rolled Throughput Yield -- WP:CSD G10
 * 305) All Fellas Band -- WP:CSD A7
 * 306) Protoalphabet -- WP:CSD G1
 * 307) Funnyegyptiangeek22 -- WP:CSD A7
 * 308) Herman Secondary School -- WP:CSD A3
 * 309) Moondust (Book) -- WP:PROD
 * 310) Avenge the tragedy -- WP:CSD A7
 * 311) Jesseacraig/the massacre -- WP:CSD A7
 * 312) Moondust (Book) -- WP:CSD A1
 * 313) Jesseacraig/the massacre -- WP:CSD A7
 * 314) R1 Camp -- WP:CSD A7
 * 315) Richandrichy -- WP:CSD A7
 * 316) Scott ewing -- WP:CSD A7
 * 317) Mobilitywheels -- WP:CSD A7
 * 318) Free Spirit 4 U -- WP:CSD G2
 * 319) Zona kayla -- WP:CSD G1
 * 320) Dev (DJ) -- WP:CSD A7
 * 321) Zona kayla -- WP:CSD A7
 * 322) Habitualcreature:Habitualcreature/Draft -- WP:CSD G7
 * 323) Tasos -- WP:CSD A7
 * 324) Ryan "Gordo" Gordon -- WP:CSD G10
 * 325) Edward michie -- WP:CSD G11
 * 326) Fa hobson landscaping -- WP:CSD A7
 * 327) Technology Strategic Plan -- WP:CSD A1


 * Deletion flatly declined:
 * 1) Varoujan Hakhbandian -- WP:CSD A7 -- SoWhy declined speedy: notability claimed
 * 2) Needham B. Broughton -- WP:CSD A7 -- tag removed by another established editor; article implied notability in my opinion
 * 3) Kongu kootam -- WP:PROD -- PROD removed by another editor who then cleaned up article
 * 4) Jeffrey R. Shapiro -- WP:CSD A7 -- Jclemens declined speedy: notability claimed
 * 5) Strikeforce: Shamrock vs. Diaz -- WP:CSD A1 -- Jclemens declined speedy: context provided
 * 6) WMRP-LP -- WP:PROD -- PROD removed by another editor who then cleaned up article
 * 7) Originating Point Code -- WP:CSD G1 -- Tikiwont declined speedy: "not nonsense or gibberish, but a redirect should be fine for the moment"
 * 8) Jimmy Two-Shoes -- WP:CSD A1 -- Jclemens declined speedy: "Has context, google shows this exists"
 * 9) James Campagnola -- WP:CSD A7 -- Protonk declined speedy: "Pretty slim pickings on sourcing (but it is out there). May not survive AfD"
 * 10) Sheila Manahan -- WP:CSD A7 -- Jclemens declined speedy: "asserts notability, feel free to Prod/AfD"
 * 11) Pensacola Chief of Police -- WP:CSD G2 -- DGG converted to PROD then C.Fred converted article to a redirect


 * Pending PRODs:
 * 1) Michael feerick -- WP:PROD
 * 2) Northern Industrial Jumbo Wagon -- WP:PROD
 * 3) Kshemkalyani -- WP:PROD
 * 4) Toledo Hispanic Pentecostal Church -- WP:PROD
 * 5) Pagoose -- WP:PROD
 * 6) Sasha Basson -- WP:PROD
 * 7) Study Island -- WP:PROD
 * 8) Torrentula -- WP:PROD


 * Other PRODs
 * 1) Qzone -- WP:PROD -- tag removed by author
 * 2) Perfect 10 v. Visa -- WP:PROD -- tag removed by author
 * 3) Alwataniah -- WP:PROD -- tag removed by author
 * 4) Pegacorn -- WP:PROD-- tag removed by author
 * 5) Ted Wang (attorney) -- WP:PROD-- tag removed by author
 * 6) Death by Wikipedia -- WP:PROD -- tag removed by author; another editor took to AfD: Articles for deletion/Death by wikipedia
 * 7) Hesketh-with-Becconsall -- WP:PROD -- another editor converted to a redirect
 * 8) Spanish Wiffleball -- WP:PROD -- IP removed tag -- I think it may have been the author acting anonymously
 * 9) GI Film Festival -- WP:PROD -- tag removed by author
 * 10) 2008 US dollar Speculative Attack -- WP:PROD -- author subsequently protested PROD on talk page so admin declined to delete
 * 11) Greenbelt Arts Center -- WP:PROD -- Flying Toaster removed his PROD and expanded article
 * 12) Nikhila -- WP:PROD -- tag removed by author
 * 13) TextAloud -- WP:PROD -- author removed tag; another editor took to AfD: Articles for deletion/TextAloud and the consensus was to redirect

-- A. B. (talk • contribs) 04:28, 25 February 2009 (UTC)
 * Other CSDs:
 * 1) Jc piedrasanta -- WP:CSD A7 -- Flying Toaster changed her CSD to a redirect
 * 2) Anal dysplasia -- WP:CSD G3 -- Flying Toaster removed her CSD and expanded article
 * 3) Template:Sandbox Prose start date and age -- WP:CSD G2 -- tag removed by author
 * 4) Talk:Top 100 Greatest Villains -- WP:CSD G8 -- tag removed by Flying Toaster per talk page
 * 5) Top 100 Greatest Villains -- WP:CSD G12-- tag removed by Flying Toaster per talk page
 * 6) Kamensk Uralsky Metallurgical Works -- WP:CSD A7 -- 1st tag removed by author
 * 7) Kamensk Uralsky Metallurgical Works -- WP:CSD A7 -- 2nd tag removed by author, who subsequently expanded article
 * 8) Indian Express Group -- WP:CSD A7 -- "declining own speedy to give time to establish notability"
 * 9) Awaken Acappella -- WP:CSD A3 -- tag removed by author; another editor re-added tag; article is now at AfD: Articles for deletion/Awaken Acappella
 * 10) User:Themaski/Wael Eldeep -- WP:CSD A7 -- FlyingToaster tagged Wael Eldeep; admin subsequently userfied
 * 11) Institut Eksekutif -- WP:CSD G11 2nd tag: FlyingToaster subsequently removed her tag and then tried to cleanup article.
 * 12) Institut Eksekutif -- WP:CSD G11-- 1st tag removed by author
 * 13) User:Skaifey14 -- WP:CSD A7 -- FlyingToaster tagged Mitchell lugg; admin subsequently userfied
 * 14) Kolej Bersatu Sarawak -- WP:CSD G11 -- author removed tag and added more content; Flying Toaster subsequently worked to cleanup article
 * 15) Liverpool FC vs AC Milan European Champions League Final 2005 -- WP:CSD G2 -- an admin converted to a redirect
 * 16) Shaun Silva -- WP:CSD A7-- tag removed by author who subsequently expanded article
 * 17) Ashley Kumar -- WP:CSD A7 -- FlyingToaster removed own tag and tagged with in-universe; another editor has taken to AfD: Articles for deletion/Ashley Kumar
 * 18) Kalcagaj -- WP:CSD A1 -- FlyingToaster removed own tag and created stub
 * 19) Nikolayevka (Kazakhstan) -- WP:CSD A1 -- author provided reference; Flying Toaster removed CSD tag
 * 20) Nekode -- WP:CSD A1 -- author subsequently converted article to a redirect
 * 21) Albondin -- WP:CSD A1 -- author subsequently improved article; Flying Toaster removed CSD tag
 * 22) Red Skorba phase -- WP:CSD G3 -- FlyingToaster removed own tag
 * 23) Fishing with spoons -- WP:CSD A7 -- 2nd tag removed by author who subsequently improved article; admin declined speedy at this point
 * 24) Fishing with spoons -- WP:CSD A7 -- 1st tag removed by author
 * 25) Avalanche rescue -- WP:CSD A3 -- tag removed by author who subsequently improved article; admin declined speedy at this point
 * 26) Mouthfeel (wine) -- WP:CSD R3 -- FlyingToaster subsequently removed her tag and converted article to a redirect
 * 27) BlackAgumon -- WP:CSD A1 -- another editor removed tag but then a very experienced editor noted "lacks reliable sources and provides insufficient information for separate article once original research has been removed" and converted to a redirect
 * 28) Hurricane Season 2008 -- WP:CSD G2 -- admin converted to a redirect
 * Updated -- A. B. (talk • contribs) 05:46, 25 February 2009 (UTC)