Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Michaelsanders

Edit count for Michaelsanders
User:Michaelsanders

run at Sat Dec 8 15:15:27 2007 GMT

Category:             7 Image:                120 Mainspace             10401 Portal:               2 Talk:                 1204 Template talk:        6 Template:             255 User talk:            470 User:                 45 Wikipedia talk:       86 Wikipedia:            134 avg edits per page    5.48 earliest              18:40, 24 March 2006 number of unique pages 2324 total                 12730

2006/3  37 2006/4   100 2006/5   47 2006/6   43 2006/7   100 2006/8   49 2006/9   121 2006/10  102 2006/11  749 2006/12  1318 2007/1   1608 2007/2   1623 2007/3   3106 2007/4   2163 2007/5   0 2007/6   0 2007/7   19 2007/8   0 2007/9   3 2007/10  139 2007/11  1120 2007/12  283

(green denotes edits with an edit summary (even an automatic one), red denotes edits without an edit summary)

Mainspace 185 List of Queens and Empresses of France 152 Spells in Harry Potter 143 Harry Potter (character) 116 List of Holy Roman Empresses and German queens 91 Severus Snape 89 Sirius Black 81 List of Byzantine Emperors 80 Lord Voldemort 80 List of Harry Potter characters 77 Albus Dumbledore 75 Hogwarts founders 72 Hogwarts 66 Charlemagne 65 Hermione Granger 59 Horcrux

Talk: 83 Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows 79 List of Navarrese royal consorts/sandbox 49 Horcrux 41 Weasley family 39 Severus Snape/Archive 4 33 Lord Voldemort 31 Hogwarts founders 30 Marie Antoinette 28 Catherine of Aragon 27 Black family 25 List of French monarchs 22 Carloman I, King of the Franks 21 King of the Romans 21 Louis, Dauphin of France (1729-1765) 19 Sirius Black

Category: 2 House of Bourbon

Image: 4 EleanorAquitaine.JPG 3 Louis Dauphin Brittany.jpg 3 Robert the Pious coin.jpg 2 Ardents.jpg 2 Bal des ardents.jpg 2 Margaret of Sicily.jpg 2 Coronation of King Odo.jpg 2 Constance of Arles.jpg 2 ValentinianIIIfamily.jpg 2 Alienor-d-aquitaine et jean sans terre.jpg 2 Marieluxembourgfrenchqueen.jpg

Template: 116 Farseerfamilytree 17 German monarchs 13 Direct Capetians 13 Carolingians, East Francia 11 House of Bourbon(France) 9  Monarchs of France 8  Carolingians, West Francia 6  Holy Roman Emperors 6  Carolingians 5  Capetian Cadets 4  Valois Burgundy 4  Carolingians, Aquitaine 4  Carolingians, Middle Frankish Branch 4  Kings of the Western Franks 3  HRE Arms

Template talk: 5 Carolingians, East Francia

User: 21 Michaelsanders/Dates in Harry Potter 15 Michaelsanders 3 Michaelsanders/Popes 2 Deb

User talk: 61 John Reaves 45 Michaelsanders 27 Srnec 27 Folken de Fanel 18 T-dot 16 Str1977 13 Sandpiper 13 PNW Raven 9 Deathphoenix/Archive6 9 Fbv65edel 8 PeaceNT/Archive 2 8 Causesobad 8 Duane543 6 Ipankonin 6 RosePlantagenet

Wikipedia: 28 Administrators' noticeboard/3RR 22 Articles for deletion/Dates in Harry Potter (second nomination) 15 Articles for deletion/Dates in Harry Potter 12 Deletion review/Log/2007 April 6 11 Articles for deletion/Harry Potter characters birthday list 11 Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents 8 Articles for deletion/Students in Harry Potter's Year 7 Articles for deletion/Blood purity 3 Deletion review/Log/2007 January 10 3 Templates for deletion/Log/2007 November 21 2 Articles for deletion/Harry Potter in translation series 2 Good article nominations 2 Requested moves

Wikipedia talk: 51 WikiProject Harry Potter/Archive 10 19 Naming conventions (names and titles) 8 WikiProject Harry Potter/Templates 6 Manual of Style (writing about fiction) 2 WikiProject France

If there were any problems, please email Interiot or post at User talk:Interiot . Based directly on these URLs: [1], [2], [3]


 * The edit count was retrieved from this link at 15:15, 8 December 2007 (UTC).

Reverts, moves, & edit summaries
I'll recuse myself from expressing any opinion due to past conflicts with the candidate and the suspicion that I am irredeemably prejudiced here. Instead, let's have some fascinating diffs, all of which relate to the last month.

Ramon Berenguer IV, Count of Provence passes three uneventful years until it is moved by Michael. Six minutes later Srnec moves it back. It only stays there for a minute until Michael moves it back. Four days pass and then Srnec moves the article back to the original name. Michael moves it back. At last we get some dialogue when Srnec leaves a message for Michael. However, some officious bastard moves it back to the original name, leaves a note on the talk page, and asks other editors to comment, which they did, although Michaelsanders did not.


 * Naming conventions (names and titles) says "Most general rule overall: use the most common form of the name used in English". Which was why I moved it. Castigating me for adherence to the rules seems rather strange. I then sat back, looked around, and came to the conclusion that in this particular case a laissez-faire attitude would do no harm, since the name was often used in the Catalan form. I didn't contribute further to the discussion because I'd come to that conclusion, and the discussion there was proceeding well enough without me. Michael Sanders 19:35, 8 December 2007 (UTC)

Michael often reverts with no edit summaries. The great ahnentafel kerfuffle wasn't so great. In general it looked like this: I remove ahnentafel: this information should be in the article text if it is important and nowhere if it is not important, revert by Sanders with no comment. Likewise Henry Stewart, Lord Darnley: me, Michaelsanders; Edward the Confessor: me, Michaelsanders, me fixing the inaccurate disputed table; William I of England: me, Michaelsanders; and so on. Lots of discussion at Talk:Louis V of France follows, but nothing much is contributed by Michael.


 * What I objected to was you removing them because you didn't like them. I restored them, got discussion going. Discussion was fruitful, people with more meaningful contributions got involved, so I didn't see the need to stick my oar into the discussion further. Michael Sanders 19:35, 8 December 2007 (UTC)

Or again here: Elonka does some copyediting on Louis IX of France, but Michael doesn't like it, or rather he doesn't like a small part of it, so he reverts the lot with no summary. Angus McLellan (Talk) 19:17, 8 December 2007 (UTC)


 * There is a summary. It says, "restoring images". Because I was restoring the images, that had been removed for what appeared to be an unjustified reason (which was then explained, and sorted out). Michael Sanders 19:35, 8 December 2007 (UTC)


 * My apologies. You did indeed use an edit summary, although editors can decide for themselves whether that is an accurate description. It indubitably was a revert. Angus McLellan (Talk) 19:48, 8 December 2007 (UTC)