Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Silver seren

Username:	Silver seren User groups:	reviewer, rollbacker First edit:	Jun 23, 2006 14:19:28 Unique pages edited:	1,665 Average edits per page:	4.06 Live edits:	6,374 Deleted edits:	385 Total edits (including deleted):	6,759

Namespace Totals

Article	2576	40.41% Talk	555	8.71% User	523	8.21% User talk	1210	18.98% Wikipedia	1238	19.42% Wikipedia talk	193	3.03% File	3	0.05% Template talk	61	0.96% Category	1	0.02% Category talk	14	0.22% Namespace Totals Pie Chart Month counts 2006/06	8 	2006/07	0 	2006/08	0 	2006/09	0 	2006/10	0 	2006/11	0 	2006/12	11 	2007/01	12 	2007/02	19 	2007/03	17 	2007/04	73 	2007/05	15 	2007/06	15 	2007/07	381 	2007/08	656 	2007/09	12 	2007/10	0 	2007/11	7 	2007/12	0 	2008/01	5 	2008/02	1 	2008/03	0 	2008/04	0 	2008/05	0 	2008/06	0 	2008/07	0 	2008/08	0 	2008/09	0 	2008/10	0 	2008/11	0 	2008/12	156 	2009/01	0 	2009/02	7 	2009/03	13 	2009/04	46 	2009/05	14 	2009/06	45 	2009/07	0 	2009/08	0 	2009/09	89 	2009/10	1 	2009/11	0 	2009/12	0 	2010/01	0 	2010/02	0 	2010/03	753 	2010/04	918 	2010/05	1053 	2010/06	6 	2010/07	32 	2010/08	1006 	2010/09	1003

Top edited pages (hide)Article

* 68 - Northern_Rocky_Mountains_Wolf * 41 - Mayoori_(actress) * 39 - Warrior_(wrestler) * 36 - Alexander_Archipelago_Wolf * 34 - Saffron_terror * 33 - Kaavalan * 33 - Jackie_Evancho * 31 - Life_at_the_Bottom:_The_Worldview_That_Makes_the_U... * 28 - Yukon_Wolf * 28 - Andy_Bachetti

(hide)Talk

* 93 - Criticism_of_Judaism * 42 - Gaia_Online * 34 - Reincarnation_research * 23 - Northern_Rocky_Mountains_Wolf * 17 - Kharsag * 14 - Saffron_terror * 10 - Chiropractic * 10 - Nair * 9 - Jackie_Evancho * 8 - Vampire:_The_Masquerade_–_Bloodlines

(hide)User

* 276 - Silver_seren/Userpage * 95 - Silver_seren * 55 - Silver_seren/Sandbox * 12 - Silver_seren/easy_to_view_userboxes * 11 - Silver_seren/Joke * 8 - Silver_seren/List_of_Wikipedians_We_Have_Lost * 8 - Sidatio/Conversations/On_list_guidelines * 6 - Silver_seren/icons * 4 - Silver_seren/Useful_Links_and_Information * 4 - Silver_seren/How_I_Feel_About_The_Project

(hide)User talk

* 83 - Silver_seren * 80 - Kkrouni * 51 - Moonriddengirl * 46 - Jimbo_Wales * 45 - Thefunk42 * 33 - Chrishy_man * 30 - Sidatio * 17 - Ashura96 * 16 - Cirt * 14 - Spriteless

(hide)Wikipedia

* 179 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents * 94 - Article_Rescue_Squadron/Hall_of_Fame * 53 - Village_pump_(policy) * 33 - Reliable_sources/Noticeboard * 21 - Articles_for_deletion/Saffron_Terror * 16 - Articles_for_deletion/Criticism_of_Judaism_(2nd_no...   * 15 - Articles_for_deletion/Machine_to_Machine    * 15 - Articles_for_deletion/Kharsag    * 14 - Village_pump_(proposals)    * 14 - Articles_for_deletion/Cairo_International_Model_Un...

(hide)Wikipedia talk

* 66 - Child_protection * 34 - Article_Rescue_Squadron * 16 - Article_titles * 9 - Notability_(sports) * 9 - Neutral_point_of_view * 8 - Did_you_know * 6 - Pending_changes/Straw_poll_on_interim_usage * 5 - Notability * 5 - Counter-Vandalism_Unit * 5 - Subtle_Vandalism_Taskforce

(hide)File

* 2 - Life_at_the_Bottom_Cover.jpg * 1 - Northern_Rocky_Mountains_wolf.jpg

(hide)Template talk

* 61 - Did_you_know

(hide)Category

* 1 - Hindu_terrorism

(hide)Category talk

* 12 - Hindu_terrorism * 2 - Sociology

Retrieved from X!'s counter at 06:00, 29 September 2010 (UTC)

Closing rationale
Although the consensus was that Silver seren is a civil and constructive editor, the opposition focused mainly on an ideological point of view with regards to the editor's inclusionism. I saw in a few !votes a logical link to previous trends of admin behavior from the extremes of the inclusionism/deletionism debate, but the evidence for these trends is rather tenuous. It's better explained by the fact that there tends to be a visceral reaction towards people who hold strong, different opinions. Thankfully, there were many opposes that looked past this and managed to properly provide areas of concern and improvement for the nominee. There was one !vote that came in after the time expiry, an oppose, but either way the consensus had been formed before its inclusion. Because of that, I have not removed it.  bibliomaniac 1  5  05:42, 6 October 2010 (UTC)