Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/The Utahraptor 2

Edit stats from X!'s counter.

Username:	The Utahraptor User groups:	reviewer, rollbacker First edit:	Nov 08, 2009 15:47:28 Unique pages edited:	5,858 Average edits per page:	1.88 Live edits:	10,841 Deleted edits:	201 Total edits (including deleted):	11,042

Namespace Totals

Article	4504	41.55% Talk	1099	10.14% User	815	7.52% User talk	3517	32.44% Wikipedia	571	5.27% Wikipedia talk	193	1.78% File	97	0.89% Template	10	0.09% Template talk	9	0.08% Category	23	0.21% Category talk	3	0.03%

Month counts

2009/11	161	2009/12	92	2010/01	35	2010/02	26	2010/03	106	2010/04	158	2010/05	277	2010/06	2583	2010/07	3122	2010/08	967	2010/09	1001	2010/10	2313

Top edited pages

(hide)Article 215 - Silver_Reef,_Utah 168 - Ulysses_S._Grant 120 - Abraham_Lincoln 75 - List_of_characters_in_the_Blue_Dragon_series 70 - List_of_Alex_Rider_characters 66 - List_of_GetBackers_characters 65 - Heroic_Age_(anime) 54 - Duke_of_Bivona 46 - Hellenic_Railways_Organisation 44 - Karkala

(hide)Talk 29 - Silver_Reef,_Utah 13 - Tom_Horn 13 - Ulysses_S._Grant 7 - Attention_deficit_hyperactivity_disorder 7 - National_Waterway_4_(India) 6 - Standardville,_Utah 6 - Central_Electricity_Regulatory_Commission 5 - Wesley_So 5 - Bonanza 5 - Arches_National_Park

(hide)User 232 - The_Utahraptor 164 - The_Utahraptor/Status 53 - The_Utahraptor/Sandbox_2 40 - The_Utahraptor/Biography 36 - The_Utahraptor/To_do 30 - The_Utahraptor/Awards_and_recognitions 24 - The_Utahraptor/Goce_newsletters 23 - The_Utahraptor/July_Drive 18 - The_Utahraptor/Photos_I_have_taken 16 - The_Utahraptor/Museum

(hide)User talk 269 - The_Utahraptor 40 - Dffgd 33 - HJ_Mitchell 33 - Diannaa 32 - Tommy2010 31 - The_Utahraptor/Archive_4 28 - Access_Denied 28 - SMasters 26 - EdoDodo 23 - The_Utahraptor/Archive_3

(hide)Wikipedia 81 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors/Backlog_eliminat... 48 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism 37 - WikiProject_American_Old_West 30 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors/Backlog_eliminat... 27 - Huggle/Whitelist 19 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors/Backlog_eliminat... 19 - Sandbox 18 - Reference_desk/Science 17 - Requests_for_page_protection 17 - Requests_for_permissions/Rollback

(hide)Wikipedia talk 80 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors/Backlog_eliminat... 29 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors/Backlog_eliminat... 24 - Requests_for_adminship 23 - WikiProject_American_Old_West 13 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors/Backlog_eliminat... 6 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors/Backlog_eliminat... 6 - WikiProject_Guild_of_Copy_Editors 3 - Sandbox 2 - WikiProject_Utah 2 - WikiProject_Ghost_towns

(hide)File 3 - JonMontanaTrip09_221.jpg 2 - View_of_Silver_Reef.jpg 2 - Mysterious_Shadow.jpg 2 - JonMontanaTrip09_039.jpg 2 - Housefly_on_a_leaf_crop.jpg 2 - Elberta_sinclair.jpg 2 - AntelopeIslandEchoGhosttowns_178.jpg 2 - AntelopeIslandEchoGhosttowns_186.jpg 1 - AntelopeIslandEchoGhosttowns_169.jpg 1 - AntelopeIslandEchoGhosttowns_198.jpg

(hide)Template 3 - Vandalism_information 2 - Washington_County,_Utah 1 - WikiProject_American_Old_West 1 - American_Old_West_WP_invite 1 - 2010_FIFA_World_Cup_Group_H 1 - Carbon_County,_Utah 1 - Racism_topics

(hide)Template talk 9 - Did_you_know

(hide)Category 3 - Unassessed_American_Old_West_articles 3 - American_Old_West_articles_by_quality 1 - Stub-Class_American_Old_West_articles 1 - NA-Class_American_Old_West_articles 1 - WikiProject_American_Old_West_articles 1 - Start-Class_American_Old_West_articles 1 - C-Class_American_Old_West_articles 1 - GA-Class_American_Old_West_articles 1 - B-Class_American_Old_West_articles 1 - WikiProject_American_Old_West

(hide)Category talk 3 - Mexican_dancers

Q4
Mkativerata, why do you think the offline source was insufficient? We don't require easy accessibility of sources. "The principle of verifiability implies nothing about ease of access to sources". It wouldn't be unusual for a 1989 source to not be online. Gigs (talk) 03:17, 28 October 2010 (UTC)
 * I think it was insufficient in the context. Being offline and being in a sports magazine doesn't cut it for a highly prejudicial claim about a (presumably) living person, especially when a corroborating source couldn't be found online. Although that doesn't excuse the way Mkativerata acted on the article. His perfunctory dismissal of the source merely because it was offline was not appropriate. --Mkativerata (talk) 03:19, 28 October 2010 (UTC)
 * Yes, but Utahraptor 2 still got it wrong :) I'm enjoying your questions, as they show how little many participants in RFA really know about policies and guidelines here.  Sandy Georgia  (Talk) 03:25, 28 October 2010 (UTC)
 * I agree that "magazines are unreliable", as a blanket statement, is wrong - which seems to be the point you're making in your oppose. Although reading it again, he has said "not normally", but even then that's putting it too high. --Mkativerata (talk) 03:34, 28 October 2010 (UTC)
 * Also, I would think that something like this would be in more then one source like one of the Brisbane local papers. We also don't know what kind of magazine "Rugby League Week" is or what kind of editorial oversight they have. --Ron Ritzman (talk) 03:55, 28 October 2010 (UTC)