Wikipedia talk:Requests for arbitration/Derek Smart/Proposed decision

Arbitrators

 * Arbitrators active on this case
 * Fred Bauder
 * Jdforrester
 * Morven
 * Charles Matthews
 * Dmcdevit (active as of the time the case went into voting)
 * Raul654
 * SimonP
 * UninvitedCompany
 * FloNight
 * Blnguyen

The newly appointed arbitrators as of the beginning of 2007 are assumed by default to be recused from cases already open at the time they took office. If an arbitrator becomes active on this case (by declaration or activity), his/her name will be moved to the active list and the majority adjusted accordingly.
 * New arbitrators inactive on this case
 * Flcelloguy
 * Kirill Lokshin
 * Paul August
 * Jpgordon (now active as to the motion to close only)

The same is true with respect to the arbitrators newly appointed in February:
 * Essjay (now active as to the motion to close only)
 * Mackensen