Wikipedia talk:Requests for arbitration/RickK vs. Guanaco/Proposed decision

Proposed finding of fact #2 was resolved by talk page discussions. I agreed not to unblock users just because they're unlikely to reuse the accounts. Arbitration is supposed to be a last resort, so why is this here? RickK may have meant the more recent unblocking/reblocking issue that failed RfC's certification requirement or other issues such as the unblocking of User:Bird because the account was not used for vandalism and because Bird is not banned. Guanaco 00:53, 6 Sep 2004 (UTC)


 * 2.5 seems much more on target. Guanaco 00:35, 8 Sep 2004 (UTC)

Article inaccuracy
The current proposed finding of fact #6 does not mention that the inaccuracy in Something Bitchin' This Way Comes was caused by the source used by both Mike Garcia and myself. It still contains that mistake, which can be seen by clicking "Next >" on the album browser. Guanaco 01:57, 12 Sep 2004 (UTC)

barnstars
"special commendation"? Have to say, I prefer barnstar. It's a weird term, perhaps, but it is what Wikipedia has been using recently. I'm not sure as arbitrators we should over-ride that based on our personal preference... Martin 15:36, 25 Sep 2004 (UTC)

Finding of fact re age
Point 1.1 asserts that Michael is 14. His user page says he is 24. I realize it once said otherwise, but is it reasonable to make this a "finding of fact" when the information is ambiguous? Very Verily 07:04, 6 Nov 2004 (UTC)