Wikipedia talk:Requests for comment/Redvers

''Moving User:Mahawiki and User:Arya_Rajya_Maharashtra's comments from the Response section on the main page to this discussion page. This RfC is not about them. The focus of this article is solely what I perceive as Admin Redvers' unnecessary use of a belligerent tone when communicating with me. Arya and Mahawiki are NOT respondents here.''

I am not so concerned even with the fairness or unfairness'' or Redvers' assessment of the situation though I hold that it was indeed unfair. My only concern here once again, is Redvers' belligerence and his 'not so veiled' threat to have me blocked permanently.''


 * Sarvagnya has accused me of incivility but he seems to forget the rude behaviour he exhibited on the same page.See this. Note that he is not agreeing even after a consensus is attained (consensus of a mob) when the same user used this policy here.So coming to the point,admin in question, did warned both of us,but IMO he was enraged upon Sarvagnya's very long complaint and my detailed answer.I think Sarvagnya should not take those words personally and stop being a perfectionist.I think the admin in question should be spared. Mahawiki 05:17, 20 October 2006 (UTC)


 * Really, Sarvagnya should know better that talk pages do come under 3RR rule. Please check the 3RR page. And regarding his thinking of my warning being frivolous, I cannot waste my time, energy and resources on where he has used popups or not. He has been using popups for a long time in edit-warring/content dispute/POV pushing etc. and this certainly is popup abuse. Check this out - Sarvagnya and his suspected socks Naveenbm and Gnanapiti(see note) use popups to push POV, this time on Saare Jahan Se Accha page, just check how many times the user uses popups here. There are many such instances and the user should know this himself. Note that almost all of these instances are not of reverting vandalism but of pushing POV and content disputes. Admins like Blnguyen and Redvers warned him for excessive bickering and popup abuse, and this user now files RfC against them. Amazing heights ! I think Redvers did nothing wrong, infact Sarvagnya deserves this kind of rapping.


 * NOTE:There is a case against Sarvagnya for using sockpuppets and it is neither filed by me nor by Mahawiki. Check it here - Requests for checkuser/Case/sarvagnya


 * -  Arya   Raj ya  महाराष्ट्र  14:56, 20 October 2006 (UTC)


 * Sarvagnya please read the default note where me and Arya had posted our comments.Please put out comments back to that page.Mahawiki 11:10, 21 October 2006 (UTC)