Wikipedia talk:Sockpuppet investigations/Leanne

List of AfDs that need revisiting due to sock puppetry

 * 1) Articles_for_deletion/"The_Above_Ground_Sound"_of_Jake_Holmes - edited by 7 of 9 users - already DRVd – its 2nd AfD resulted in "keep"
 * 2) Articles_for_deletion/Tuff_Monks - edited by 6 of 9 users - closed no consensus anyway
 * 3) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_R&B_musicians - edited by 5 of 9 users - Restored and relisted at AfD – its 2nd AfD resulted in "keep"
 * 4) Articles_for_deletion/It's_Nobody's_Fault_But_Mine - edited by 5 of 9 users - redirect undone - someone else may wish to re-AfD – It was relisted, and the new result was "keep"
 * 5) Articles_for_deletion/Lucifer_Rising_(album) - edited by 4 of 9 users - has since been recreated
 * 6) Articles_for_deletion/Zeyd_Naito - edited by 3 of 9 users Unsourced BLP about a member of a borderline notable band - not worth worrying about
 * 7) Articles_for_deletion/You_Owe_Me_One - edited by 3 of 9 users a b-side to a single, redirect to the single at the most
 * 8) Articles_for_deletion/We're_Going_Wrong - edited by 3 of 9 users Was redirected, which the non-socks suggested as well
 * 9) Articles_for_deletion/Two_for_the_Price_of_One - edited by 3 of 9 users album track only, should be a redirect at the most as also suggested by non-socks
 * 10) Articles_for_deletion/This_Girl_(Kylie_Minogue_song) - edited by 3 of 9 users Demo, was redirected as per WP:MUSIC suggests
 * 11) Articles_for_deletion/The_Lazys - edited by 3 of 9 users - restored and relisted at AfD – its 2nd AfD also resulted in "delete"
 * 12) Articles_for_deletion/The_Game_Tour - edited by 3 of 9 users - restored and relisted at AfD – After relisting and further discussion, the result was "keep"
 * 13) Articles_for_deletion/The_Collegiates - edited by 3 of 9 users AfD ongoing, sock votes removed – closed as no consensus
 * 14) Articles_for_deletion/Queen_bootlegs - edited by 3 of 9 users Merged, which would probably have been final outcome anyway
 * 15) Articles_for_deletion/Queen_Will_Be_Crowned - edited by 3 of 9 users Closed no consensus anyway
 * 16) Articles_for_deletion/Presence_(amplification) - edited by 3 of 9 users closed no consensus anyway
 * 17) Articles_for_deletion/Pink_Floyd_French_Summer_Tour_1974 - edited by 3 of 9 users closed Keep anyway
 * 18) Articles_for_deletion/Permanent_Vacation_(song) - edited by 3 of 9 users Result probably unchanged (and per WP:MUSIC)
 * 19) Articles_for_deletion/Our_Last_Summer_(2nd_nomination) - edited by 3 of 9 users closed no consensus anyway
 * 20) 2 Articles_for_deletion/One_Shot_(song) - edited by 3 of 9 users redirected as per non-socks
 * 21) Articles_for_deletion/Mine_Again - edited by 3 of 9 users redirected per WP:NSONGS and non-socks
 * 22) Articles_for_deletion/Making_Time - edited by 3 of 9 users This one's unusual in that it was actually nominated by a sock - restored without relisting – Noted on its talk page
 * 23) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_music_videos_made_in_the_1960s - edited by 3 of 9 users only one keep vote, result probably unchanged
 * 24) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_gamelan_ensembles_in_the_United_States - edited by 3 of 9 users - restored and relisted at AfD – its 2nd AfD resulted in "no consensus"
 * 25) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_Australian_TV_Newsreaders - edited by 3 of 9 users Closed as Keep
 * 26) Articles_for_deletion/Killing_Yourself_to_Live - edited by 3 of 9 users Probably no change, and has since been merged through a Requested Merge discussion
 * 27) Articles_for_deletion/ITunes_Originals - edited by 3 of 9 users - my (Black Kite's) own close, someone else should look at this &mdash; taken to Deletion Review by its creator, User:TheHYPO – its 2nd AfD resulted in "no consensus"
 * 28) Articles_for_deletion/Fever_(Kylie_Minogue_song) - edited by 3 of 9 users redirected as per non-socks
 * 29) Articles_for_deletion/Dream_World_(ABBA_song) - edited by 3 of 9 users merged per NSONGS, no difference
 * 30) Articles_for_deletion/Cassandra_(song) - edited by 3 of 9 users b-side to a single, recreated as a redirect
 * 31) Articles_for_deletion/British_Winter_Tour_'74 - edited by 3 of 9 users Were non-sock delete votes, but was merged per a good rationale
 * 32) Articles_for_deletion/An_Original_Man_(A_Song_for_Keith) - edited by 3 of 9 users deleted per non-socks
 * 33) Articles_for_deletion/Alex_Kweskin - edited by 3 of 9 users Discussion, with sockpuppet contributions struck out, resulted in a redirect
 * 34) Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/77:_The_Year_of_Punk_and_New_Wave - edited by 3 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppet contributions (ironically accusing other editors of being "simply here to disrupt AfD") didn't sway the outcome in favour of deletion, which only one other person supported.
 * 35) Articles_for_deletion/X-Offender - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Article was Capitalistroadsterized, and kept.
 * 36) Articles_for_deletion/Wired_Desire - edited by 2 of 9 users - restored and relisted at AfD – its 2nd AfD resulted in "no consensus"
 * 37) Articles_for_deletion/Who_Dunnit?_(song) - edited by 2 of 9 users redirected per non-socks
 * 38) Articles_for_deletion/Whenever_You_Call - edited by 2 of 9 users no change
 * 39) Articles_for_deletion/When_I_Kissed_the_Teacher - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets may have influenced the decision to merge, but no actual deletion occurred, despite the sockpuppeteer's efforts.
 * 40) Articles_for_deletion/Underneath_the_Stars - edited by 2 of 9 users redirected per NSONGS, probably not worth relisting
 * 41) Articles_for_deletion/True_(Brandy_song) - edited by 2 of 9 users Discussion, with sockpuppet contributions struck out, resulted in "merge"
 * 42) Articles_for_deletion/Too_Far - edited by 2 of 9 users No change
 * 43) Articles_for_deletion/Tomorrow_is_Today_(song) - edited by 2 of 9 users - restored and relisted – its 2nd AfD resulted in "keep"
 * 44) Articles_for_deletion/Till_the_End_of_Time_(Mariah_Carey_song) - edited by 2 of 9 users redirected - no change
 * 45) Articles_for_deletion/The_Works_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users closed as no consensus anyway
 * 46) Articles_for_deletion/The_Way_Old_Friends_Do - edited by 2 of 9 users deleted, but since recreated as a redirect, which probably should've been the initial result
 * 47) Articles_for_deletion/The_Summer_EP - edited by 2 of 9 users - restored and relisted — its 2nd AfD resulted in "delete", but later recreated with reliable sources
 * 48) Articles_for_deletion/The_Rain_Tapes - edited by 2 of 9 users - restored and relisted – its 2nd AfD resulted in "delete"
 * 49) Articles_for_deletion/The_Quietus - edited by 2 of 9 users no change
 * 50) Articles_for_deletion/The_One_(Mariah_Carey_song) - edited by 2 of 9 users no change
 * 51) Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/The_Mummy:_Rise_of_the_Aztecs - edited by 2 of 9 users redirected per non-socks
 * 52) Articles_for_deletion/The_Metallica_Collection - edited by 2 of 9 users result not affected by sock votes
 * 53) Articles_for_deletion/The_Complete_Depeche_Mode - edited by 2 of 9 users Result not affected by sock votes
 * 54) Articles_for_deletion/Tea_for_julie - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Discussion still active, with sockpuppet contributions struck out.
 * 55) Articles_for_deletion/Taylor_EP - edited by 2 of 9 users result not affected by socks
 * 56) Articles_for_deletion/Taxi_(EP) - edited by 2 of 9 users result not affected by socks
 * 57) Articles_for_deletion/TGT_(group) - edited by 2 of 9 users closed as no consensus anyway
 * 58) Articles_for_deletion/Sunbul_Effendi - edited by 2 of 9 users VfD from 2005(!), closed as keep anyway
 * 59) Articles_for_deletion/Spider_Rockets - edited by 2 of 9 users - already relisted and restored by User:Stifle – its 2nd AfD resulted in "keep"
 * 60) Articles_for_deletion/Solomon_Grundy_(song) - edited by 2 of 9 users – restored and relisted with sock puppet contributions noted – after relist and further discussion, closed as "no consensus"
 * 61) Articles_for_deletion/Sierra_Fin - edited by 2 of 9 users – was nominated by a sock, but consensus to delete was unanimous, with adequate participation
 * 62) Articles_for_deletion/Sheer_Heart_Attack_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users closed as no consensus anyway
 * 63) Articles_for_deletion/Sepulveda_Dam_bicycle_path - edited by 2 of 9 users – sock puppets didn't sway the outcome, which was to unbundle and relist
 * 64) Articles_for_deletion/Secret_(Take_You_Home) - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of the non-sockpuppet accounts was the actual outcome.  Later editorial actions have undone the outcome, moreover.
 * 65) Articles_for_deletion/Saint_John_and_the_Revelations - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Discussion still active, with sockpuppet contributions struck out.
 * 66) Articles_for_deletion/Room_Service_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users – restored; closing admin changed result from "delete" to "no consensus"
 * 67) Articles_for_deletion/Rock_the_Cosmos_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users closed as no consensus anyway
 * 68) Articles_for_deletion/Robert_Muchamore* - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the article exists today at Robert Muchamore.
 * 69) Articles_for_deletion/Rama_Claproth - edited by 2 of 9 users All non-sock votes were to delete, fairly obviously non-notable
 * 70) Articles_for_deletion/Queen_Hyde_Park_1976 - edited by 2 of 9 users  &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and failed to rebut arguments that plenty of sources exist.
 * 71) Articles_for_deletion/Punkradiocast.com - edited by 2 of 9 users – restored and relisted, with sock puppet contributions noted – after relist and further discussion, closed as "keep"
 * 72) Articles_for_deletion/Pulse_Nation - edited by 2 of 9 users – restored and relisted, with sock puppet contributions noted – after relist and further discussion, closed as "delete"
 * 73) Articles_for_deletion/Promentalshitbackwashpsychosis_Enema_Squad_(The_Doo-Doo_Chasers) - edited by 2 of 9 users – VfD from 2005; article's content for the most part exists today at One Nation Under a Groove anyway
 * 74) Articles_for_deletion/Poochandi - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Several other editors made arguments for deletion, albeit that the sockpuppets may have tipped the balance.  From inspection of the deleted revisions a Deletion Review would a waste of time better spent writing a real article, if there is one to be had.
 * 75) Articles_for_deletion/Pink_Floyd_Wish_You_Were_Here_Tour_1975 - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppet contributions didn't sway the outcome in favour of deletion.
 * 76) Articles_for_deletion/Papa_vs_Pretty - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; This was nominator+article creator+sockpuppeteer.  Deletion Review, rather than a straight re-list, is probably best. Uncle G (talk) 22:30, 20 April 2009 (UTC)
 * 77) Articles_for_deletion/One_Man,_One_Woman - edited by 2 of 9 users Non-socks agreed on delete outcome, but since re-created as a redirect to the parent album per NSONGS
 * 78) Articles_for_deletion/Obscured_By_Clouds_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users Non-sock votes suggested delete or Merge, article was merged
 * 79) Articles_for_deletion/O_Holy_Night_(Mariah_Carey_song)/archive1 - edited by 2 of 9 users - old VfD, closed as keep anyway
 * 80) Articles_for_deletion/News_of_the_World_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and failed to rebut arguments that in-depth sources exist.
 * 81) Articles_for_deletion/Muliebrity - edited by 2 of 9 users – AfD from 2005 in which the socks recommended "keep"; article was deleted by Prod in 2009
 * 82) Articles_for_deletion/Michalis_Limnios - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Only one other person apart from the sockpuppeteer expressed any opinion, here, and that was on the lack of sources cited in the article. However, the article was a wholly unsourced biography of a living person, and this deletion does not preclude a properly sourced article from being grown.
 * 83) Articles_for_deletion/Michael_Paul_Oman-Reagan - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; The second edit was a later link fix following a page move.
 * 84) Articles_for_deletion/Michael_Hannon_(2nd_nomination) - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Discussion still active, with sockpuppet contributions struck out.
 * 85) Articles_for_deletion/Me_and_Sarah_Jane - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of the non-sockpuppet accounts was the actual outcome.
 * 86) Articles_for_deletion/Marz_(rapper) - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Discussion still active, with sockpuppet contributions struck out.
 * 87) Articles_for_deletion/Mann's_Men - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Discussion still active, with sockpuppet contributions struck out.
 * 88) Articles_for_deletion/Lourdes_Ciccone - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; The second edit was a later link fix following a page move.
 * 89) Articles_for_deletion/Los_Super_Reyes - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 90) Articles_for_deletion/Lorna_Nogueira/vote3 - edited by 2 of 9 users Closed as no consensus anyway
 * 91) Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Loose_Cannon:_The_Cut_Off - edited by 2 of 9 users restored; AfD changed to "procedural keep"
 * 92) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_musical_acts_that_have_played_at_CBGB - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Even discounting the sockpuppets entirely, issues of verifiability, maintability, and duplication were put forward by several other editors (which the sockpuppets just parroted, in fact).
 * 93) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_melodic_death_metal_bands_(2nd_nomination) - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 94) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_jam_band_music_festivals - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Re-opened and re-listed at Articles for deletion/Log/2009 April 20 by the closing administrator.
 * 95) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_heavy_metal_bands - edited by 2 of 9 users – result was "keep", despite the efforts of the sock puppets
 * 96) Articles_for_deletion/List_of_ancient_Egypt_mysteries - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; This has already been through AFD a second and a third time since then, at Articles for deletion/List of unsolved problems in Egyptology and Articles for deletion/List of unsolved problems in Egyptology (Second nomination).
 * 97) Articles_for_deletion/Like_It_or_Not - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; The extra sockpuppet contributions could well have swayed this one.  I suggest Deletion Review. Uncle G (talk) 22:30, 20 April 2009 (UTC) – was relisted and, after further discussion, closed as "redirect"
 * 98) Articles_for_deletion/Liberacy - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; The argument that this was original research was made by non-sockpuppets.
 * 99) Articles_for_deletion/Letter_to_B.I.G. - edited by 2 of 9 users – probably only a slight possibility, in a discussion with many other participants, that the socks swayed the outcome to delete – article was later recreated and then redirected to the album article anyway
 * 100) Articles_for_deletion/Lac_Motion - edited by 2 of 9 users restored, relisted, then re-deleted
 * 101) Articles_for_deletion/Just_Like_That_(song) - edited by 2 of 9 users – restored and relisted at AfD, with sock contributions noted – after further discussion, closed as "no consensus"
 * 102) Articles_for_deletion/Ju_Ju_Babies - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Even discounting the sockpuppets entirely, there was no consensus here, and ordinary editorial actions have since rendered the discussion moot.
 * 103) Articles_for_deletion/Jiwang - edited by 2 of 9 users – socks may well have swayed the "delete" result in this AfD from 2005, but by today's standards it seems extremely unlikely that this definition of a slang term would be kept as an article anyway
 * 104) Articles_for_deletion/Jazz_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and failed to rebut arguments that plenty of sources exist; the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 105) Articles_for_deletion/It_(MSI_Singles) - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 106) Articles_for_deletion/I_Wanna_Rock_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 107) Articles_for_deletion/Hot_Space_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 108) Articles_for_deletion/Henry_seeley - edited by 2 of 9 users – most others also argued "delete", with only one other arguing for a "redirect", but article had minimal content anyway as noted in the AfD
 * 109) Articles_for_deletion/Happy_Hawaii - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 110) Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Grind_Worldwide:_Ca$his_Part_II:_Capo_Of_Shady - edited by 2 of 9 users restored; AfD changed to "procedural keep"
 * 111) Articles_for_deletion/Genocides_in_history - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion.
 * 112) Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/GHV2_Remixed:_The_Best_of_1991–2001 - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 113) Articles_for_deletion/Fever_(Little_Nell_song) - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 114) Articles_for_deletion/Falling_Up_(band) - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion.
 * 115) Articles_for_deletion/Elaine_(song) - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, as desired.
 * 116) Articles_for_deletion/Don_Pancho - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 117) Articles_for_deletion/Dig_In_(Black_Guns) - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 118) Articles_for_deletion/Die_Young,_Stay_Pretty - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; The sockpuppets argued against deletion, as too did everyone else apart from the nominator.
 * 119) Articles_for_deletion/Destruction_in_15_(band) - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 120) Articles_for_deletion/December_EP - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 121) Articles_for_deletion/Daniel_Buxton - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Discussion still active, with sockpuppet contributions struck out.
 * 122) Articles_for_deletion/Dance_(While_The_Music_Still_Goes_On) - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 123) Articles_for_deletion/Dan_O'Connor - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 124) Articles_for_deletion/Cyberraga - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 125) Articles_for_deletion/Crazy_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 126) Articles_for_deletion/Confession_(band) - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 127) Articles_for_deletion/Christofascism - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway opinion from deletion to keeping, as desired.  Instead, I helped to do that, the right way, without attempting to stuff a nonexistent ballot, at Articles for deletion/Christofascism (2nd nomination). &#9786; Uncle G (talk) 14:18, 20 April 2009 (UTC)
 * 128) Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Choosing_Death:_The_Improbable_History_of_Death_Metal_&_Grindcore - edited by 2 of 9 users – Closed as no consensus anyway
 * 129) Articles_for_deletion/Black_Market_Hero - edited by 2 of 9 users – Sockpuppets were responsible for tipping a multiple relist to delete, looks like a no consensus close would be appropriate. Independently, Black Market Hero has been undeleted, merged, and redirected. Flatscan (talk) 04:25, 21 April 2009 (UTC) Sockpuppet !votes struck; AfD reclosed as no consensus by original closing admin. Flatscan (talk) 04:28, 23 April 2009 (UTC)
 * 130) Articles_for_deletion/Black_Guns - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 131) Articles_for_deletion/Best_selling_Female_artist - edited by 2 of 9 users – Sock puppets might have initially swayed the decision to keep the article, but it was later deleted anyway, through Articles for deletion/Best-selling female singer
 * 132) Articles_for_deletion/Beaucoups_of_Blues_(song) - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 133) Articles_for_deletion/Andante,_Andante - edited by 2 of 9 users – sockpuppets may have tipped a "merge" outcome to "delete"
 * 134) Articles_for_deletion/All_Eyez_On_Me_(Cashis_Mixtape) - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 135) Articles_for_deletion/A_Year_In_The_Life_(EP) - edited by 2 of 9 users restored and relisted, with sock puppet !votes noted
 * 136) Articles_for_deletion/A_Night_At_The_Opera_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 137) Articles_for_deletion/A_Day_At_The_Races_Tour - edited by 2 of 9 users &mdash; Sockpuppets didn't sway the outcome to deletion, and the opinion of other people was the actual outcome.
 * 138) Articles_for_deletion/A_Complicated_Song - edited by 2 of 9 users
 * 139) Articles_for_deletion/A_Beginning - edited by 2 of 9 users – restored and relisted, with sock !vote noted – after relist and further discussion, closed as "keep"