List of Australian sports controversies

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is a list of major sports controversies in Australia or concerning Australian sportspeople. These controversies cover areas such as rules, match fixing, cheating, sportsmanship, doping and sport administration. They have generated large scale media coverage over a period of time and may have resulted in a large scale inquiry. These controversies affect the integrity of sport.

Sport, Event or Topic
Dates
 Summary of Controversy
Cricket 1879 Sydney riot of 1879 – In a match between New South Wales and England, a riot was sparked by a controversial umpiring decision, when star Australian batsman Billy Murdoch was given out by George Coulthard, a Victorian employed by the Englishmen.[1]
Cricket 1884 Billy Murdoch, the Australian captain, led a players' strike, where the Australian players refused to play unless they received a greater share of the gate takings.
Cycling 1904 Seven riders were disqualified for up to three years after the Sydney Thousand, once the world's richest cycling race, when they deliberately blocked the race favourite. Due to the scandal, the public lost confidence in professional cycling.[2][3]
Boxing 1908 African American boxer Jack Johnson defeated Tommy Burns at the Sydney Stadium to become world heavy weight champion. The victory shattered the notion of white man's superiority and led to race riots and lynching in the United States.[4]
Boxing 1908 At the 1908 London Olympics, 'Snowy' Baker won the silver medal in the middleweight boxing division, losing narrowly on points to Britain's Johnny Douglas. The referee was Douglas' father and his casting vote awarded the fight to his son.[5]
Rugby league 1909 1909 NSWRFL Grand Final – The South Sydney Rabbitohs and Balmain Tigers had unofficially agreed to boycott the grand final in protest at New South Wales Rugby League's plans for a match between the Australian rugby union and rugby league teams that would have upstaged the final. South Sydney turned up ready to play and were awarded the premiership as Balmain was not present.[3][6]
Australian football 1910 Several Carlton Football Club VFL players were suspected of having taken bribes to fix matches, with two players, Alex Lang and Doug Fraser both found guilty and suspended for 99 matches.[3][7]
Boxing 1917 Boxer Les Darcy died in the United States. His failure to enlist in World War I resulted in him being banned from boxing and being called a coward and deserter by many politicians and the media.[8]
Australian football 1922 After the 1922 VFA Grand Final, Vern Banbury was accused by a number of Port Melbourne Football Club players of paying money to throw the match in Footscray Football Club's favour. Banbury subsequently received a life ban from the VFA.[9]
Horse racing 1932 Death of Phar Lap on 5 April in the United States after a sudden and mysterious illness. It was believed that Phar Lap (New Zealand born and bred) was poisoned by American gangsters who feared big losses after he had easily won the Agua Caliente Handicap in Mexico despite attempts to stop him.[10]
Cricket 1932–1933 Bodyline controversy between Australian and English cricket teams over fast bowling tactics. The controversy threatened the political relationship between Australia and England.
Water polo 1956 Blood in the Water match – a match between Hungary and USSR at the 1956 Melbourne Olympics was abandoned after violence in the pool. The match was held during the 1956 Hungarian Revolution.
Soccer 1960 The Australian Soccer Association was suspended from FIFA for the poaching of players from overseas.[11]
Swimming 1960 The United States protested against John Devitt's win in the 100m freestyle at the 1960 Rome Olympics. Time keepers awarded the race to Lance Larson but two judges awarded the race to Devitt. The appeal jury rejected the United States appeal.[12]
Horse racing 1961 Jockey Mel Schumacher, riding Blue Era, was disqualified for life for grabbing the leg of Tommy Hill, the rider of Summer Fair, in the dying seconds of the AJC Derby.
Cricket 1963 Australian fast bowler Ian Meckiff was no-balled for throwing in the First Test against South Africa by Australian umpire Col Egar.[13]
Swimming 1965 Dawn Fraser was suspended for 10 years by the Australian Swimming Union (ASU) but for stealing flags from Japan's Imperial Palace during the Tokyo Olympics.[14] The ban was later reduced to four years. The ASU also banned three other swimmers – Linda McGill, Nan Duncan and Marlene Dayman for three years.
Australian football 1967 1967 VFA Grand Final – Port Melbourne Football Club nearly forfeited in protest at the performance of umpire David Jackson. Historian John Devaney states that it was "indisputably one of the most infamous matches in Australian football history".
Athletics 1968 Black Power salute – Australian sprinter Peter Norman supported African Americans Tommie Smith and Juan Carlos' black power salute during the medal ceremony for the 200m at the 1968 Olympics in Mexico. Norman wore a pro-human rights badge to show his support.
Horse racing 1969 Melbourne Cup favourite Big Philou was scratched by stewards 39 minutes prior to the race. Testing revealed the horse had been administered the drug Danthron.[15]
Rugby union 1971 The 1971 South Africa rugby union tour of Australia resulted in many anti-apartheid protests around Australia, particularly during games.[16]
Cricket 1971 English captain Ray Illingworth took his team off the field after fast bowler John Snow was grabbed by a spectator, and had beer-cans thrown at him. This occurred after Snow had hit low order batsman Terry Jenner in the head with a bouncer.[17]
Athletics 1976 Sprinter Raelene Boyle was disqualified after two false starts in the final of women's 200m at the 1976 Montreal Olympics.[18] A video replay later showed that she had not false started on her first start.
Olympic Games 1976 The Australian team failed to win a gold medal at the 1976 Montreal Olympics, leading to a public outcry and calls for improved support for Australian athletes.[18] In 1981, the Australian Institute of Sport was established to improve Australian performances in international sport.
Cricket 1977 Kerry Packer's World Series Cricket (WSC) breakaway competition dramatically changed the nature of cricket. The two main factors behind WSC were restrictive broadcast rights and player payments.
Olympic Games 1980 Several Australian athletes and teams boycotted the 1980 Moscow Olympics at the request of the Australian Government.[19]
Cricket 1981 Underarm bowling incident during one day international between Australia and New Zealand – Greg Chappell ordered his brother Trevor to roll the final delivery along the ground to make it impossible for New Zealand to hit the six it needed to tie the match.
Horse racing 1984 Fine Cotton horse racing substitution (or ring in) at Eagle Farm Racecourse.[20]
Doping in sport 1988 Senate Drugs in Sport Inquiry into doping allegations concerning the AIS and sport in Australia – The Government established the Australian Sports Drug Agency (now Australian Sports Anti Doping Authority) as a response to the Inquiry.[21][22]
Modern pentathlon 1988 Australian modern pentathlete Alex Watson was found guilty of excessive levels of caffeine at the Seoul Olympics. Watson later cleared his name and was allowed to compete at 1992 Barcelona Olympics.[23]
Australian football 1993 Nicky Winmar, a St Kilda Football Club player, responded to racial taunts by Collingwood Football Club supporters by pointing to his skin.[24]
Sports facilities 1993–1994 Sports rorts affair – Ros Kelly, Minister for Sport, was unable to appropriately explain the distribution of federal sporting grants to marginal electorates held by the governing Australian Labor Party
Athletics 1994 Cathy Freeman caused a huge outcry by waving both the Aboriginal and Australian Flags during her victory lap after winning the 200m at the 1994 Commonwealth Games. Protocol dictated that only the national flag could be carried.[25]
Cricket 1994 Denise Annetts claimed her omission from the Australian team was because she was not a lesbian. The Australian Anti-Discrimination Board could not investigate the complaint as discrimination law at the time only protected homosexuals.[26]
Cricket 1994–1995 John the bookmaker controversy – Shane Warne, Mark Waugh and Tim May alleged that Pakistani cricketer Salim Malik had tried to bribe them in 1994 to under-perform.
Cricket 1995 Sri Lankan spin bowler Muttiah Muralitharan was called for throwing by Australian umpire Darryl Hair on Boxing Day, the biggest day in Australian Cricket.[6]
Rugby league 1997 Super League war was a dispute between the Rupert Murdoch and News Corporation-backed Super League (Australia) and the Kerry Packer and Optus Vision-backed Australian Rugby League over broadcasting rights for, and ultimately control of, the top-level professional rugby league football competition of Australasia. In 1997, there were two competing national rugby league competitions in Australia.
Yachting 1998 The 1998 Sydney to Hobart Yacht Race was the most disastrous in the race's history, with the loss of six lives and five yachts. A coroner's inquest into the deaths was critical of both the race management at the time and the Bureau of Meteorology.
Paralympic Games 2000 Basketball controversy – the Spanish intellectual disability basketball team was stripped of its gold medal after the Games, after it was found that 10 of the 12 competitors in the team were not disabled.
Rugby league 2002 Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs salary cap breach – Bulldogs found guilty of systemic breaches of the salary cap, fined $500,000, and stripped of all 37 competition points.
Australian football 2002 Carlton Football Club salary cap breach – Carlton found guilty of elaborate and sophisticated breaches of the salary cap during 2000 and 2001. The club was fined $930,000 and stripped of draft picks.
Rowing 2004 Sally Robbins dropped her oar during the final of the women's eights at the 2004 Athens Olympics. Robbins was accused of mental weakness and publicly ridiculed in the Australian media as "Lay-down Sally".[27]
Swimming 2004 Ian Thorpe false start controversy at the 2004 Australian Swimming Olympic Trials. Craig Stevens forfeited his place in the 400m at the 2004 Athens Olympics so that Thorpe could defend his title, which he successfully did.
Cycling 2004 Australian Sports Commission and Cycling Australia investigated doping allegations concerning the Australian Institute of Sport track cycling team based in Adelaide, South Australia. Mark French was banned for two years, but in July 2005 the ban was overturned by the Court of Arbitration for Sport due to lack of evidence.[28]
Australian rules football 2006 An AFL match between St Kilda and Fremantle ended in controversy when the umpires failed to hear the final siren, after which St Kilda's Steven Baker scored a behind, tying the scores at 94–all.[29][30] Fremantle successfully protested the result, and were awarded the win 94–93.[31]
Rugby league 2010 Melbourne Storm salary cap breach – the Storm were found guilty of salary cap breaches over five years. The club was stripped of its 2007 and 2009 premierships, among other team achievements, and forced to play for no points for the remainder of the 2010 season from Round 7 onwards.
Rugby league 2010 Ryan Tandy was involved manipulating the first point scoring in a National Rugby League game between Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs and North Queensland Cowboys.[32]
Swimming 2012 The Australian men's freestyle sprint relay team misbehaviour at the 2012 London Olympics resulted in several inquiries. Members of the team used Stillnox, which was banned by the Australian Olympic Committee, and the team's bonding activities adversely affected other swimmers.[33]
Australian football 2013 Melbourne Football Club tanking scandal – the AFL found Dean Bailey and Chris Connolly guilty of "acting in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the competition" during the 2009 season.
Doping in sport 2013 Australian Crime Commission report into organised crime and sport. The report's allegations focused on athletes and teams in the Australian Football League and National Rugby League.[34]
Australian rules football 2013-2016 Essendon Football Club supplements saga – the AFL found that Essendon had brought the AFL into disrepute and handed down severe penalties – $2 million fine, suspension from the 2013 finals series, removal of first round drafts picks and penalties to Essendon football department officials including the one-year suspension of Coach James Hird.[35] The AFL Anti Doping Tribunal found the players not guilty. WADA appealed this decision and in January 2016 the not-guilty verdict was overturned by the Court of Arbitration for Sport.[36] The thirty-four Essendon players were suspended for two years backdated to 31 March 2015; including time served in provisional suspensions during the 2014/15 offseason, this brought the suspensions for almost all of the players to an end in November 2016.[37]
Rugby league 2013 Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks supplements saga – The National Rugby League (NRL) investigated the Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks over irregularities in its supplements program and handed down severe penalties including a $1 million fine, the 12-month suspension of Shane Flanagan as head coach and the deregistration of Trent Elkin as the club's trainer.[38]
Soccer 2013 Southern Stars FC players were accused of match fixing in the Victorian Premier League.[39]
Australian football 2015 Adam Goodes during matches played outside Sydney was constantly booed by spectators. It was suggested that Goodes was booed as a result of an incident in 2013 with a 13-year-old girl who called him an ape, comments made during his 2014 Australian of the Year award and the way he plays and stages for free kicks.[40][41] After the match between the Sydney Swans and the West Coast Eagles at Domain Stadium, Goodes stepped down from playing as he believed the sustained booing had racist overtones. Whilst there were several commentators arguing that the booing was not due to racism, the AFL community including clubs and players and political and community leaders stated that the booing had to cease as it was racist.
Tennis 2015 During a match at the Montreal Masters in August, Nick Kyrgios caused controversy when he was heard making sexual remarks about Stan Wawrinka's girlfriend, Croatian tennis player Donna Vekić, suggesting that Thanasi Kokkinakis had an affair with her. Kyrgios later received a suspended $25,000 fine and a 28-day suspension from the ATP World Tour for the offence.[42][43]
Rugby league 2016 Parramatta Eels salary cap breach resulted in the National Rugby League stripping the Eels of the twelve competition points the club in the 2016 NRL season, fining the club $1 million, cancelling the registrations of five senior officials and revoking its 2016 NRL Auckland Nines title.[44]
Cricket 2018 2018 Australian ball-tampering scandal – Ball tampering by the Australia national cricket team. Cameron Bancroft was charged with alleged ball tampering on 24 March 2018 when videos showing him rubbing and then concealing a suspicious yellow object emerged during day three of the third test against South Africa, at Newlands Stadium. Captain Steve Smith and Cameron Bancroft accepted the ball tampering allegation in front of Andy Pycroft, the match referee, and press.[45]
Australian rules football 2018 Greater Western Sydney player Jeremy Cameron became the first player in AFL history to be sent straight to the tribunal more than once in his career when he was reported for, and subsequently convicted of, rough conduct against Brisbane Lions fullback Harris Andrews; he was suspended for five matches for the incident.[46][47] He had previously been sent straight to the tribunal after breaking Rhys Mathieson's jaw during a pre-season match in 2016, for which he was suspended for four matches.[48]
Rugby union 2019 On 17 May 2019, Rugby Australia terminated Israel Folau's 4-year employment contract with the NSW Waratahs and the Wallabies due to him breaching its code of conduct in relation to social media. After legal proceedings involving the Fair Work Commission and the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, on 4 December 2019 Folau and Rugby Australia issued a joint statement and apology that stated no harm had been intended by either party and announced that a confidential settlement had been reached.
Sports facilities 2019–2020 Sports rorts affair (2020) – Bridget McKenzie, Minister for Sport, reminiscent of a very similar scandal 26 years earlier, this time by the governing Coalition (Australia)
Gliding 2020 During the 10th FAI Women's World Gliding Championships at Lake Keepit NSW, the Australian team were found to have accessed the official tracking system to obtain real-time information on their competitors positions bypassing the 15 minute delay referred to in the local rules.[49]
Australian rules football 2020 Sydney Swans player Elijah Taylor was suspended for the remainder of the 2020 AFL season after his partner breached the club's strict quarantine hub by sneaking into his hotel room.[50] This ultimately resulted in no cricket matches featuring the India national cricket team being scheduled for the city of Perth during the 2020–21 Australian cricket summer.[51]
Cricket 2021 Tim Paine resigned as Australian captain after it was revealed he sent a inappropriate image of himself along with several lewd messages exchange between him and a female Cricket Tasmania employee from 2017. Paine took a leave of absence shortly after the story was announced.
Australian rules football 2022 The Hawthorn Football Club were at the centre of an external review into the historical treatment of Aboriginal Australian players within the club over the previous decade. In this review, former Indigenous players at the club alleged mistreatment of them and their families. Figures at the club such as Alastair Clarkson and Chris Fagan were alleged to have orchestrated efforts to isolate the players from family and partners, and in one case even encouraged a pregnancy termination, to achieve on-field results.[52] Both Clarkson and Fagan were cleared of wrongdoing.[53]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 70. ISBN 009183371X.
  2. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 121. ISBN 009183371X.
  3. ^ a b c Fagan, Sean (February 2011). "How gambling ruined sport". Inside Sport: 84–91.
  4. ^ "Fight to pardon black boxer Johnson renewed". Sydney Morning Herald. 6 March 2013.
  5. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 129. ISBN 009183371X.
  6. ^ a b Larkin, Steve (9 August 2013). "Australia's greatest sporting scandals". The Age. Retrieved 29 September 2013.
  7. ^ Mackie, Craig. "Doug Fraser and the Bribery Scandal of 1910". BluesMuseum. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  8. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 146. ISBN 009183371X.
  9. ^ Pascoe, Robert (14 August 2013). "Essendon charged with bringing the game into disrepute: a history of footy scandals". The Conversation. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  10. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 202. ISBN 009183371X.
  11. ^ "Timeline of Australian Football 1950–1975". Australian Online Football Museum. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  12. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 315. ISBN 009183371X.
  13. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 329. ISBN 009183371X.
  14. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 335. ISBN 009183371X.
  15. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 352. ISBN 009183371X.
  16. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 360. ISBN 009183371X.
  17. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 358. ISBN 009183371X.
  18. ^ a b Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 380. ISBN 009183371X.
  19. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 396. ISBN 009183371X.
  20. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 412. ISBN 009183371X.
  21. ^ Drugs in sport : an interim report of the Senate Standing Committee on Environment, Recreation and the Arts. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service. 1989. ISBN 0644095717.
  22. ^ Drugs in sport : second report to the Senate Standing Committee on Environment, Recreation and the Arts. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service. 1990. ISBN 0644117575.
  23. ^ "Watson's life ban lifted : now for Barcelona". Sydney Morning Herald. 12 May 1989. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  24. ^ Gordon, Michael (16 April 2013). "The day Nicky Winmar drew the line". The Age. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  25. ^ "Freeman, Catherine (Cathy) (1973–?)". Indigenous Australia website. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  26. ^ Cashman, Richard (1997). Australian sport through time : the history of sport in Australia. Sydney: Random House Australia. p. 450. ISBN 009183371X.
  27. ^ Arlington, kim (30 April 2007). "Seven-time lay down Sally". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  28. ^ "French ban overturned on appeal". BBC News, 12 July 2005. 12 July 2005. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  29. ^ Dockers filthy over draw with Saints, ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation), 30 April 2006
  30. ^ Saints, Dockers stage climactic draw, ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation), 30 April 2006
  31. ^ Dockers awarded win over Saints, ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation), 3 May 2006
  32. ^ "Ryan Tandy found guilty of trying to fix 2010 match between Canterbury Bulldogs and North Queensland Cowboys". Daily Telegraph. 6 October 2011. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  33. ^ "AOC Swimming Investigation Findings". Australian Olympic Committee News. 23 August 2013. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  34. ^ Organised crime and drugs in sport (PDF). Canberra: Australian Crime Commission. 2013. Archived from the original (PDF) on 18 August 2013. Retrieved 29 September 2013. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  35. ^ "Bombers kicked out of finals, fined $2m and stripped of draft picks". AFL News. 27 August 2013. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  36. ^ Travis King (12 January 2016). "Guilty: court bans the Essendon 34 for 2016". Australian Football League. Retrieved 12 January 2016.
  37. ^ "Essendon drug scandal: CAS verdict on Bombers live coverage". Herald Sun. Melbourne, VIC. 12 January 2016. Retrieved 12 January 2016.
  38. ^ Rothfield, Phil (17 December 2013). "NRL hits Cronulla Sharks with $1m fine, year ban for coach Shane Flanagan, indefinite ban for trainer Trent Elkin". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 12 March 2014.
  39. ^ "Victorian detectives bust alleged soccer match-fixing syndicate". Sydney Morning Herald. 15 September 2013. Retrieved 28 September 2013.
  40. ^ Flannagan, Martin (4 October 2014). "Why do footy crowds boo Adam Goodes?". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 3 August 2015.
  41. ^ Adair, Darryl (1 August 2015). "Man up? I see a man down: booing and being Adam Goodes". The Conversation. Retrieved 3 August 2015.
  42. ^ "Nick Kyrgios handed suspended ban, $US25,000 fine over Stan Wawrinka 'girlfriend' rant, ATP says". ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation). 25 August 2015. Retrieved 9 October 2015.
  43. ^ "Nick Kyrgios delivers brutal sledge to Stan Wawrinka claiming Thanasi Kokkinakis slept with his girlfriend". Fox Sports Australia. 15 August 2015. Retrieved 9 October 2015.
  44. ^ "Parramatta final determination". NRL website. 9 July 2016. Retrieved 12 October 2016.
  45. ^ "Cameron Bancroft: Australia player admits to ball-tampering, Steve Smith knew in advance". BBC Sport. Retrieved 24 March 2018.
  46. ^ "No Jezza, no worries for the Giants". The Roar. 29 July 2018. Retrieved 31 July 2018.
  47. ^ Ramsey, Michael (6 August 2018). "Gaff could face biggest AFL ban in years". The Courier. Retrieved 17 October 2018.
  48. ^ "Brisbane won't hold any grudges towards Jeremy Cameron after errant elbow on Harris Andrews". news.com.au. 26 June 2018. Retrieved 9 August 2018.
  49. ^ https://wwgc2019.com/wp-content/uploads/files/downloads/Annex%20SC3a%20Rules.pdf [bare URL PDF]
  50. ^ "Young Swan suspended for rest of season for COVID breach". AFL.com.au. 15 August 2020. Retrieved 28 October 2020.
  51. ^ Craddock, Robert (6 September 2020). "Cricket: Elijah Taylor COVID breach set to cost Perth international cricket this summer". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 6 September 2020.
  52. ^ "Family separations and pregnancy termination: Hawthorn racism review reveals shock allegations against former coaches". ABC News. 20 September 2022.
  53. ^ "No findings against coaches in AFL's Hawks probe but Human Rights Commission looms". Fox Sports. 30 May 2023. Retrieved 12 January 2024.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_Australian_sports_controversies&oldid=1220576381"