Talk:Halfway Gone/GA1

GA Review[edit]

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Candy o32 17:10, 27 July 2010 (UTC)[reply]

Hi, Rp. First of all I would like to let you know how it is impressive how you could create an article like this, considering where you started at. Initially I was going to but the review on hold, but they are are way too many outstanding issues, so I am going to have to fail the article at this time. In addition to recommending you take a look back at GA guidelines and criteria, I have laid out some issues.

The biggest issues are you references. I don't believe you know how to correctly cite and are mixing up the work and publisher fields. The work field is the publication or site, publisher is the company that publishes it. For example Allmusic is the work published by Rovi Corporation, Billboard is the work published by Nielsen Business Media, Inc., iTunes Store is the work published by Apple Inc.
The next biggest issues is YouTube, Last.fm, Kovideo, TenGossip, and Clips4U are not reliable sources.
To make the chart re-formatting easier check out Template:Singlechart and use the singlechart template. An example of the article making usage of it in the charts section is Somebody to Love (Justin Bieber song).
The chart performance section is way too short. Find certifications, and if you cannot, then add when it debuted and develop it into more than one sentences for the chartings.
Most of the music video section is unsourced.
Remixes must be sourced
As of now, the music video image fails WP:NFCC #8, and may be deleted if it does not meet the criteria after you change the article.

There may be issues past these, but these are what standout, good luck next time! Candy o32 17:10, 27 July 2010 (UTC)[reply]