Talk:Johnny Checketts/GA1
GA Review[edit]
GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Ed! (talk · contribs) 16:26, 13 January 2019 (UTC)
Taking a look at this one. —Ed!(talk) 16:26, 13 January 2019 (UTC)
- It is reasonably well written:
- Dup links, dab links and external links show no problems.
- Copyvio tool returns a yellow result, likely just based on similar phraseology. Could the wording be rearranged a bit on some similar terms? ie., "when the German battleships Scharnhorst and Gneisenau made a high–speed dash from Brest to reach safety in German ports."; "hecketts led a section of four Spitfires against eight Bf 109s and destroyed three of them. The other three New Zealand pilots in the section each destroyed one and Checketts damaged one of the two remaining 109s"
- It is factually accurate and verifiable:
- Not Yet
- There's a strong reliance on the Orange ref, which which a third-party source, risks favoring the article toward one historian's viewpoint. I'd recommend it needs some additional sources. Don't need to remove any Orange refs, just that a few should be backed up with other books/views.
- Could a few details be cross referenced in other sources, in order to prevent over-reliance on one? Seeing [1] [2] and [3], which adds some detail about his perspective on the war which would be helpful addition.
- Not Yet
- It is broad in its coverage:
- Not Yet A few suggestions to place the detail here in context.
- "although he had damaged others in the previous year he had never put in claims for them." -- Was this something he individually claimed or that historians later cite to him?
- Any chance the DFC or DSO citations can be quoted?
- For both No. 485 and No. 1, any chance for the size of the command, or what's typical for these kinds of units at the time?
- Any number of missions or flight hours tracked anywhere?
- " "university of flying",[65] and when he graduated in August 1945 it was with a "Distinguished Pass."[66]" -- note punctuation inside and outside of quotes. Can be one or the other, just needs to be consistent through the entire article.
- Would be good to link List of World War II aces from New Zealand somewhere. What was his rank among the 80 aces from the country? What number of ace was he?
- Not Yet A few suggestions to place the detail here in context.
- It follows the neutral point of view policy:
- See above.
- It is stable:
- Pass No problems there.
- It is illustrated by images, where possible and appropriate:
- One imaged tagged PD as appropriate. Is there a chance for more supporting images? Thinking aircraft he flew or a map of where he was shot down might be appropriate. Also thinking the engine preserved in the museum, if a photo is readily available.
- Have you considered a table for victories, for reference? I did a few in my ace articles John F. Bolt and George Andrew Davis Jr. thought certainly not a requirement.
- Other:
Perfect! It all looks great now. Based on this, going to Pass the GAN now. Thanks for your work! —Ed!(talk) 01:24, 24 January 2019 (UTC)