User talk:Dafyd/Archive 3

I'd Do Anything idea

Hi, do you think this might be a better idea for the weekly songs and eliminations?

For the Saturday show -

Finalist	Song
Nancys and Olivers	I'd Do Anything
Jessie	River Deep - Mountain High
Jodie	Chasing Pavements
Tara	Suddenly I See
Ashley	Black Velvet
Olivers	Food Glorious Food
Amy	Respect
Keisha	Mad About the Boy
Francesca	Hero
Rachel	About You Now
Samantha	I Love Rock 'n' Roll
Sarah	Get Here
Cleo	Who Knew
Niamh	The First Cut Is the Deepest

I tried to create two more for the Results show, one for the weekly missions and one for the two girls in the "sing Off". However, my attempts at making one work for the elimination just doesn't seem to work!

Missions

Mission	Task
Nancys	Working in an East End market
Olivers	Learning magic tricks

Sing Off

Finalist	Song	Lowest viewers votes	Eliminated/saved
Amy	Tell Me on a Sunday	yes	Eliminated
Francesca	Tell Me on a Sunday	no	Saved

What do you think? Details of who was eliminated each week can be worked into the content too of course. And maybe eventually once the seriess has finished the weekly "Songs" box can be changed back to just one box listing all the songs each week which could then encompass the eliminations? ♦Tangerines♦·Talk 18:34, 31 March 2008 (UTC)

How odd, I had been working on the above earlier in one of my user sandboxes and just saw that Acejr tried to do something similar! I know you have amended the two weekly shows into one now, but the box format could still be used with amendments.♦Tangerines♦·Talk 18:44, 31 March 2008 (UTC)

Thanks, I will add them shortly incorporating them into the new layout you amended it to earlier. I will also put a note on the discussion page that it is being "tried" to see how it works and that it can always be amended if it becomes a bit too "table-heavy"!♦Tangerines♦·Talk 19:16, 31 March 2008 (UTC)

Hi, not sure really whether having the table as it is for todays show with all the TBC is correct or not. I thought that maybe someone might come along and do something like that. I took out all the girls names though as the IP user had left them in the order as it was on last weeks show which will not be the same tonight. If it were up to me I would leave it all until each show finishes and then add it in one go. We shall see what happens later though!♦Tangerines♦·Talk 16:02, 5 April 2008 (UTC)

I saw you had removed it, (good idea and one I support you on). However, for some reason Week Two still showed with the tables so I have restored it to the last version before the addition of todays show. I presume that you would agree that we should wait until tonights show is actually over before adding song details etc? If so I can keep an eye on the article while the show is on.♦Tangerines♦·Talk