Wikipedia:Peer review/Ashlee Simpson/archive1

Ashlee Simpson[edit]

This article was the subject of many edit wars in the past. Things seem to have settled down now. Me, Everyking, and ExtraordinaryMachine have restored a NPOV to the article and I think it's on its way to becoming a FA. Any suggestion would be helpful :). Ryan Norton ^{T | @ | C} 07:01, 1 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]

If the article is going to make "featured" status, you'll need to get the image copyrights in order. The "fair use" rationales for the images are pretty generic: they cover why the image can be used under fair use, but not why it can be used in Ashlee Simpson. Try for something more specific than "is meant to put a face on a stage in the person's life": the claim is particularly weak for Image:ASHL078.jpg and Image:1267457-Full.jpg. Also, the copyright holders need to be indicated for Image:1267457-Full.jpg, Image:ASHL078.jpg, and Image:A-simpson-shadow-sitting.jpg. Image:Album ashlee simpson autobiography.jpg needs a fair-use rationale for its appearance on Ashlee Simpson, since the rationale in the tag really only covers its use in Autobiography (Ashlee Simpson album).

Also, has anyone contacted Ashlee Simpson's agent to ask for a photo under GFDL or another free license? --Carnildo 07:54, 1 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]

OK, thanks as always Carnildo :). I've reworked all the image fair use claims to be specific and better. Let me know what you think. Also, I browsed the site for Ashlee for a couple of hours and couldn't find any contact info for anyone at the site (even got an account and logged in). Ryan Norton ^{T | @ | C} 09:49, 2 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]
Looks good. You've done a better job of indicating copyright holders than most pop-culture articles I've seen. --Carnildo 20:08, 2 September 2005 (UTC)[reply]