Wikipedia:WikiProject Video games/Peer review/Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver[edit]
I've worked on the article a lot in the past, and have done massive and IMO, well-done and much needed clean-ups, and it is currently rated a B-Class. The article is well-sourced and written in an out-of-universe perspective. Gameplay and Story sections are of reasonable length, the article has sourced Reception and Development sections, and overall I believe is well-written.
I'd very much like to improve its rating further, and thus would very much appreciate any suggestions on improving it further, and would gladly welcome other editors to help me in the task. The Clawed One (talk) 05:54, 3 September 2008 (UTC)
- Quick comment: The "References to Abrahamic religious mythology" and fansite references are still in there from the previous peer review. I only did a quick scan, but I think if you address those, it should do well at WP:GAN. (Guyinblack25 talk 14:51, 10 September 2008 (UTC))
- The Abrahamic references section, while interesting, could easily go. The problem for siting "TheLostWorlds" is that it's the only site I can find that provides the cited material. If I could find another, more reliable source, I'd certainly use it. The main problem is that ever since March, I've been the only user working on the page on a consistent basis, so finding another user to help me with things like sourcing, which is my major weak point, has been difficult. The Clawed One (talk)
- Of the content on TheLostWorlds, the Visit to Crystal Dynamics, Q&A with Jen, Richard, and Kyle, and Q&A with Amy Hennig are probably suitable for a GAN because the information comes from the developers. FAC may be more stringent and not accept them though. (Guyinblack25 talk 03:35, 12 September 2008 (UTC))
- The Abrahamic references section, while interesting, could easily go. The problem for siting "TheLostWorlds" is that it's the only site I can find that provides the cited material. If I could find another, more reliable source, I'd certainly use it. The main problem is that ever since March, I've been the only user working on the page on a consistent basis, so finding another user to help me with things like sourcing, which is my major weak point, has been difficult. The Clawed One (talk)
- Currently, thelostworlds.net is used for only two source - one in which the website merely reports on information given by the game makers themselves, and another where it is only sourced as a fansite, and is noted as such within the article. The Clawed One (talk)
- Also, I found an interview with the people who did the audio and music, so I'll add a section on that to development in time, likely later today or tomorrow. I've been looking at other GA and FA video game articles for ideas on improvements, and Audio sections seem fairly standard when applicable to the game. The Clawed One (talk)