Murder of Margaret Anderson

On 26 December 1983, in Green Bay, Wisconsin, Margaret Anderson (born October 6, 1948) was beaten, tortured, raped and finally killed by four members of a bike gang inside the Back Forty local bar. The case was finally solved after four years of hard work by the Green Bay Police Department, other jurisdictions, and the help of America's Most Wanted television show.

Murder
On Monday December 26, a day after Christmas, a friend of Margaret, Terry “Weasel” Apfel, a member of the local Drifters motorcycle club, stopped by her house at afternoon, and together they went out to see a movie and have a few drinks. At around 11:00 p.m., Apfel and her went to a bar called the Back Forty. The bar was owned by Mark “Shotgun” Lukensmeyer, himself also a Drifter. Inside, some members of the Drifters and of the DC Eagles, another bike gang, had already spent the evening heavy drinking and taking drugs. Members of the two clubs generally valued their motorcycles more than women, who were often seen as property that could be traded or beaten easily.

At a certain point and after many drinks, one of the Drifters’ girlfriends and Margaret started fighting and had to be separated. After that Apfel sensed that he and Margaret were no longer welcome, so they decided to leave the bar. It was almost closing time, so the other patrons began to leave.

But outside an angry Margaret, fueled by alcohol, confronted Apfel, pulled his hair and slapped him in the face. Furious, Apfel threw her to the ground, kicking her repeatedly with his steel pointed boots in the head and body. Then he pushed her towards three members of the D.C. Eagles, and said: “Here, you guys can have her.” He got in his car and drove away.

The three D.C. Eagles — Randolph “Gargoyle” Whiting, Denice “Bobber” Stumpner and Mark “A.D.” Hinton — began beating and kicking her. Mark Lukensmeyer, the owner of the Back Forty, watched the scene from the doorway. Chris Shavlik, the bartender, tried to make the men stop, but there was nothing she could do. She got into her car and left. Now Lukensmeyer joined the other three men spanking Margaret.

Then the four took Margaret again inside the bar. During the next two hours, they subjected her to severe beatings and sexual abuse, snapping in half a cue stick, and pulled a cue ball into her vagina. Margaret attempted to fight back. At one point she cut Stumpner with a knife, but it only resulted in more beatings.

Eventually, they left the bar and took Margaret with them. They pushed her into the back seat of the Lukensmeyer’s Grand Torino, and drove to the Packerland Meat Packing Plant, and parked in the rear of the company’s manure clean-out area. Whiting exited the vehicle, pulling Margaret out by her hair. He dragged her through the snow. Then Whiting pulled out his buck knife and slit Margaret’s throat. She was left to die in the cold night. Blood was coming out "like a fountain of water" from the neck cut. Around 3 o'clock in the morning she was dead.

Aftermath
Randolph Whiting was on the run for eight months until being found on March 21, 1985. He was charged with first-degree murder and sentenced to life. Mark Lukensmeyer was sentenced to fifty years for aiding and abetting aggravated assault, kidnapping, and first-degree sexual assault. Mark Hinton also had a 50-year sentence. It took four and a half years to locate Denice Stumpner. After his face was broadcast on "America's Most Wanted", it only took three days to find him. He was also sentenced to fifty years.

According to the law, Hinton, Lukensmeyer, and Stumpner's fifty-year sentences resulted in mandatory release after only 22 years. Hinton was freed under supervision in the summer of 2007, followed by Lukensmeyer in the spring of 2008. Denice Stumpner's required release date with supervision was January 20, 2011. Randolph Whiting, the only one of the four to be convicted of the murder, was paroled in 2020. All of them are now free men.