Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2

The second season of the American television series Star Trek: Strange New Worlds follows Captain Christopher Pike and the crew of the starship Enterprise in the 23rd century as they explore new worlds and carry out missions throughout the galaxy during the decade before Star Trek: The Original Series. The season was produced by CBS Studios in association with Secret Hideout, Weed Road Pictures, H M R X Productions, and Roddenberry Entertainment, with Akiva Goldsman and Henry Alonso Myers serving as showrunners.

Anson Mount, Ethan Peck, and Rebecca Romijn respectively star as Pike, Spock, and Number One, along with Jess Bush, Christina Chong, Celia Rose Gooding, Melissa Navia, and Babs Olusanmokun. A second season of Strange New Worlds was confirmed in January 2022 and filming took place at CBS Stages Canada in Mississauga, Ontario, from February to July 2022, prior to the release of the first season. The showrunners continued the first season's episodic storytelling approach, inspired by The Original Series, giving each episode a different genre and tone. This includes a crossover episode with the animated comedy series Star Trek: Lower Decks, and the Star Trek franchise's first musical episode featuring original songs by Kay Hanley and Tom Polce. Many of the regular actors and several guest stars portray younger versions of characters from The Original Series in the season.

The season premiered on the streaming service Paramount+ on June 15, 2023, and ran for 10 episodes until August 10. It was estimated to have high viewership and audience demand and was praised by critics. The season was nominated for a Primetime Creative Arts Emmy Award and several other awards, and was named on multiple best of 2023 lists. A third season was ordered in March 2023.

Main

 * Anson Mount as Christopher Pike
 * Ethan Peck as Spock
 * Jess Bush as Christine Chapel
 * Christina Chong as La'an Noonien-Singh
 * Celia Rose Gooding as Nyota Uhura
 * Melissa Navia as Erica Ortegas
 * Babs Olusanmokun as Joseph M'Benga
 * Rebecca Romijn as Una Chin-Riley / Number One

Recurring

 * Adrian Holmes as Robert April
 * Carol Kane as Pelia
 * Melanie Scrofano as Marie Batel
 * Paul Wesley as James T. Kirk
 * Dan Jeannotte as George Samuel "Sam" Kirk
 * Bruce Horak as Hemmer and Garkog

Notable guests

 * Mia Kirshner as Amanda Grayson
 * Gia Sandhu as T'Pring
 * Tawny Newsome as Beckett Mariner
 * Jack Quaid as Brad Boimler
 * Noël Wells as the voice of D'Vana Tendi
 * Eugene Cordero as the voice of Sam Rutherford
 * Jerry O'Connell as the voice of Jack Ransom
 * Clint Howard as Buck Martinez
 * Martin Quinn as Montgomery Scott

Development
After beginning development on Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, a spin-off from Star Trek: Discovery, executive producer Alex Kurtzman said he wanted it to be an ongoing series rather than a miniseries, and said it could explore the seven years between Discovery second season and the accident that seriously injures Christopher Pike in Star Trek: The Original Series. In November 2021, a second season of Strange New Worlds was reported to be starting production in February 2022. Frequent Star Trek director Jonathan Frakes confirmed the season order a month later, before Paramount+ officially announced it in January 2022. The first episode of the season is dedicated to Nichelle Nichols, who portrayed the character Nyota Uhura in The Original Series and several Star Trek films. It was the first episode of the series released after Nichols's death in July 2022.

Writing
Work on the second season began before the release of the first in May 2022. The first season was structured with standalone episodes and season-long character arcs, which was a departure from the more serialized style of Discovery. Unsure how the new style would be received by fans, showrunners Henry Alonso Myers and Akiva Goldsman chose to commit to it. Myers said the second season would "go for broke" in differentiating its episodes with unique genres, and Goldsman added that it would have some "creative stretches" and "big swings" that had not been seen in the franchise before. Other writers for the season include Dana Horgan, David Reed, Kirsten Beyer, Davy Perez, Kathryn Lyn, Onitra Johnson, and Bill Wolkoff. Different episodes for the season include the romantic time travel tragedy "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow", the comedic "Charades", the dark and morally complex war story "Under the Cloak of War", and the franchise's first full musical episode, "Subspace Rhapsody"; Kurtzman had first discussed a musical Star Trek episode for the series Star Trek: Short Treks in July 2020.

Myers said the second season would follow-up on the "serialized threads" left by the first season, including the arrest of Number One, the death of chief engineer Hemmer, and La'an Noonien-Singh taking a leave of absence from the USS Enterprise. Elaborating on Number One's arrest after she was revealed to be a genetically modified Illyrian in the first season, Myers said he and Goldsman did not know how they would resolve that story when they added it as a cliffhanger in the first-season finale, but the writers came up with a "straight-down-the-middle classic Trek episode" idea to address the issue in the second season that made Myers glad to have added the cliffhanger. Because Pike star Anson Mount was expected to have a child around the start of filming, the first episode of the season, "The Broken Circle", was written to focus on the rest of the cast. The explanation for Pike's absence is that he goes to recruit a defense counsel for Number One. This storyline continues in the second episode, "Ad Astra per Aspera", which features Number One's trial, and continues a Star Trek tradition of courtroom-focused episodes.

Discussing the series' approach to fitting within Star Trek canon, Myers said they focused on creating interesting characters for the actors to perform and the audience to watch rather than just referencing previous franchise media. Goldsman added that knowing the end point of the character's stories in previous projects allowed the writers to come up with new and interesting ways to get there, including ideas that they would not have had if they were not constrained by the existing canon. The episode "Lost in Translation" depicts the first canonical meetings between James T. Kirk, the Enterprise captain from The Original Series, and key characters such as Pike, Spock, and Uhura. In The Original Series, Kirk says he met Pike when the latter was promoted to Fleet Captain; the episode depicts Pike being temporarily promoted to that rank for the mission they are on, which allowed the season to align with The Original Series while moving the first meeting between Pike and Kirk to be earlier in the timeline than had previously been presumed. After the first season referenced the Eugenics Wars as taking place in the mid-21st century rather than the 1990s, which had been established in The Original Series, the second-season episode "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow" explains that those events have shifted in the timeline due to interference from time travelers during the Temporal Cold War in Star Trek: Enterprise. Goldsman said the real-world reasoning for this was so the audience could still believe that the franchise was taking place in an "aspirational" future.

In December 2021, Kurtzman said there was potential for the different Star Trek series he was producing to crossover, as long as there was a story reason to justify this. In July 2022, Mount announced that the second season of Strange New Worlds would have a crossover episode with the animated comedy series Star Trek: Lower Decks. Myers explained that one of the writers on the series, David Reed, also worked on the series The Boys which stars Lower Decks voice actor Jack Quaid. Reed and Quaid had discussed the potential of their Star Trek series crossing over, and Reed suggested the idea to the Strange New Worlds writers. They moved forward with the idea after Kurtzman also suggested it independently. The episode was originally just going to focus on Quaid's Brad Boimler time traveling from the 24th century to the 23rd and arriving on the Enterprise, but Lower Decks showrunner Mike McMahan suggested that the character Beckett Mariner also be featured in the crossover. McMahan said he was "heavily involved" in the crossover and worked on the dialogue to make it "feel more Lower Decks". The title of the episode, "Those Old Scientists", references a joke in Lower Decks that explains what future Starfleet officers are referring to when they call the time period of The Original Series the "TOS" era.

The writers wanted to revisit the recurring threat of the Gorn, a lizard-like alien species introduced in The Original Series that were reimagined for modern audiences in the first season. They wanted to depict adult Gorn, which they had avoided doing in the first season, and the time needed to complete the design work for this led to the species being saved for one of the later episodes. They ultimately appear in the second-season finale, which ends on a surprise cliffhanger ending inspired by the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Best of Both Worlds, Part I". Myers acknowledged that this was a risky decision considering a third season was not yet confirmed.

Casting
Anson Mount, Ethan Peck, and Rebecca Romijn star in the series as Captain Christopher Pike, science officer Spock, and first officer Una Chin-Riley / Number One, respectively. Also starring are Jess Bush as nurse Christine Chapel, Christina Chong as chief security officer La'an Noonien-Singh, Celia Rose Gooding as cadet Nyota Uhura, Melissa Navia as helmsman Erica Ortegas, and Babs Olusanmokun as Dr. Joseph M'Benga.

In March 2022, Paul Wesley was revealed to have been cast for the season as James Kirk, who was portrayed in The Original Series by William Shatner. Wesley's casting was announced before the premiere of the first season, after he was spotted filming for the second season on location in Toronto. Myers cautioned fans about making assumptions regarding Kirk's involvement in the series since the science fiction genre allowed them to introduce the character in various ways. He added that they did not want to "leave a story on the table" and decided to explore a young Kirk in this time period after already exploring other The Original Series characters such as Spock, Uhura, and Chapel. Following multiple unsuccessful auditions with other actors, Myers and Goldsman approached Wesley and hired him after just having a conversation. The actor made a surprise first appearance as Kirk during the first-season finale where he played an alternate version from a potential future that Pike visits. He played a different alternate version of the character in the second-season episode "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow", one from a dark timeline who has never been to Earth. Wesley did not want to imitate Shatner for his performances, but said his portrayal of a younger Kirk in the second season would be closer to Shatner's than his portrayal of the alternate versions. Coincidentally, Wesley was once neighbors with Shatner, and the pair happened to share a plane ride around the time Wesley's casting was announced; Shatner gave Wesley his blessing. The second season explores the relationship between James Kirk and his brother George Samuel "Sam" Kirk, played by returning guest star Dan Jeannotte.

Bruce Horak said the first-season death of his character, chief engineer Hemmer, would not be the end of his involvement in the series; Horak returned as Hemmer for a recording that Uhura watches in "Lost in Translation", and also guest starred as the Klingon General Garkog in "Subspace Rhapsody". Myers said the second season would introduce a new engineer who would not be Montgomery Scott (the future chief engineer of the Enterprise as portrayed by James Doohan in The Original Series). Though Scott had a brief role in the first-season finale as part of a potential future that Pike visits, Myers explained that they were not ready to bring the character into the series' main events or cast a new actor in the role which is why that finale cameo was offscreen with a voice actor providing the lines. In September 2022, Carol Kane was revealed to have a recurring role in the second season as the new engineer, Pelia. The character is a Lanthanite, a new species created for the season that appears human but is very long-lived. Kane chose to create a new accent for the character that is different from all the other characters in the series, so the audience would not be able to work out where she comes from. She used this in a table read of the season premiere, held over Zoom, and the producers responded positively. Scott is introduced in the season finale as a junior officer and former student of Pelia, played by Scottish theater actor Martin Quinn. Following the controversial Scottish accents used by Canadian actor Doohan and English actor Simon Pegg (who portrayed Scott in several Star Trek films), Myers wanted to cast an actual Scottish actor in the role and looked at 30 to 50 different actors before Quinn was hired.

With the announcement of the Lower Decks crossover in July 2022, Tawny Newsome and Jack Quaid were revealed to be reprising their roles as Beckett Mariner and Brad Boimler from that series. The characters appear in both live-action and animation, while Noël Wells, Eugene Cordero, and Romijn's husband Jerry O'Connell just reprise their voice roles as D'Vana Tendi, Sam Rutherford, and Jack Ransom for animation. Also returning from previous Star Trek series in the season are Mia Kirshner as Spock's mother Amanda Grayson, an Original Series character who Kirshner first portrayed in Discovery, and frequent Star Trek actor Clint Howard in a new guest role for the eighth episode. Other guest stars returning from Strange New Worlds first season include Adrian Holmes as Admiral Robert April, Melanie Scrofano as Pike's girlfriend Captain Marie Batel, and Gia Sandhu as Spock's fiancée T'Pring. Additionally, Rong Fu returns as operations officer Jenna Mitchell; Noah Lamanna portrays transporter chief Jay, replacing André Dae Kim's transporter chief Kyle from the first season after Kim left to star in the series Vampire Academy; Alex Kapp again provides the voice of the Enterprise computer; and Desmond Sivan portrays a young version of Ricardo Montalban's Star Trek villain Khan Noonien Singh.

Design
Additional design work was required during pre-production for the series' virtual production technology, creating digital backgrounds to display on an LED video wall during filming. Visual effects company Pixomondo worked with the art department to design these environments, and a dedicated "virtual art department" was created for the season. In addition to the sets that production designer Jonathan Lee and his team built for the first season, the second season also features sets for the Enterprise port galley, science lab, nacelle room, and shuttle bay. Lee described the port galley, which is the ship's lounge and bar, as "our new baby" which was built for the type of scenes that were filmed in the mess hall during season one. This was because the mess hall set used virtual production technology and required digital space environments to be created for each scene. In contrast, the port galley set has no windows. The large, round shape of the courtroom set in "Ad Astra per Aspera" was inspired by the Federation command set from Discovery. Lee added hand-carved alien sculptures to the walls that were inspired by the frieze panels inside the United States Supreme Court Building. The set also includes an updated version of the "verifier" (lie-detector) chair from the Original Series episode "Court Martial".

For the Klingons that appear in the season, the design team chose to return to a look that is more similar to past Star Trek series and films than the significant redesign that was done for Discovery. The showrunners explained that they wanted the series to be closer to the original shows in all aspects, not just with Klingon designs, and the new prosthetics were also easier to apply than those that were created for Discovery. Myers added, "I like to imagine that Klingons are a diverse species, and that means there are many different looks the Klingons have."

Filming
Filming began on February 1, 2022, at CBS Stages Canada in Mississauga, Ontario, under the working title Lily and Isaac. Glen Keenan returned as cinematographer from the first season and was joined by Benji Bakshi; the pair alternated episodes. The season again used Arri Alexa LF cameras with Cooke Optics's Anamorphic/i Special Flare lenses. Producing director Chris Fisher directed the first episode. Along with the series' producers, he encouraged the other directors and cinematographers to approach each episode like a film and use the Enterprise as a mood board that reflected the emotions of each episode's genre.

Bakshi suggested Valerie Weiss, who he had worked with before, as a potential director, and she was chosen to direct the second episode. Weiss had worked on several courtroom-based series before, and watched the previous Star Trek trial episodes, including "Court Martial", as research for the episode. Pike's visit to the Illyrian colony was filmed on location in Toronto. Weiss and Bakshi ensured there was always something between Number One and the camera until she takes the stand, showing that she does not open up until that point. Eduardo Sánchez directed the fourth episode during February. He was brought in "last minute" after another planned director had to pull out, and had a month-and-a-half to prepare for his episode. A long-time Star Trek fan, Sánchez was excited about the episode's "old-school" Original Series tone and avoided modern-style camera movements. The exterior scenes were filmed using the video wall, though the producers did consider filming the quarry sequence on location. Sánchez decided against this after scouting potential locations, as he felt they would not match the video wall and the weather would cause scheduling issues. Sánchez used a hand-held camera for the scene where Ortegas loses her memories, to show her mental state. This was inspired by his prior work in the horror genre.

By March 14, Amanda Row had begun directing the third episode, with filming taking place over several weeks on location in Toronto; Wesley's casting was revealed when he was spotted during filming. The writers originally intended to film the episode on location in New York City, but realized that this would be too expensive. They then considered filming Toronto as if it was New York City, as had been done for many other films and series, before deciding to just set the episode in Toronto. Row and much of the crew came from Toronto and were excited to have it depicted as itself in the episode. Filming locations included Yonge-Dundas Square, Harbourfront, the Port Lands, David Pecaut Square, the Royal Ontario Museum, and the Royal Conservatory of Music's headquarters which stood-in for the eugenics lab at the end of the episode.

Jordan Canning directed the fifth episode, and was drawn to the comedic elements. She watched the first season as research and said the episode "Spock Amok" was the "sister episode" to this one. Canning and Keenan planned out many shots ahead of time, but an approach that they discovered during filming was framing Spock from behind to see the reactions of other characters; they found multiple places in the episode to use this framing, which Canning compared to the directing style of the Coen Brothers.

After being prevented from working on the first season when the COVID-19 pandemic impacted his directing schedule on Star Trek: Picard, Jonathan Frakes travelled to Toronto during the week of April 4 to start production on the seventh episode, which is the Lower Decks crossover. Frakes felt that he had been chosen to direct the episode because of his role as a guest voice actor on Lower Decks and because his long history with the franchise aligned with the amount of lore in the episode. Filming for the episode had to work around scheduling conflicts for Quaid with The Boys and the film Oppenheimer (2023), and Newsome with the series Space Force. After the difficult schedule of filming the first season and much of the second, Peck said the arrival of Quaid and Newsome on set brought a "boisterous and fun energy". Newsome used the phrase "chaos bomb", and admitted to accidentally breaking several elements of the Enterprise sets when she was unable to stop herself from touching things. Peck and Quaid had met several years earlier and "got along famously", earning them the nickname "Spoimler" on set. Quaid studied episodes of Lower Decks to ensure that he was recreating the movements and mannerisms of the animated Boimler correctly, while Newsome chose just to act like herself since that is how she portrays the animated version of Mariner. Frakes said the producers allowed Quaid and Newsome to improvise on set.

Filming for the sixth episode, which was directed by Dan Liu, began by the week of April 11, and was still underway at the end of the month. The episode includes the first meeting between Spock and James Kirk, a significant moment for the Star Trek franchise considering the important relationship that they go on to have in other projects. Peck and Wesley discussed the moment a lot and chose to play it as meeting "just another Starfleet officer" because the characters do not yet know the significance of the meeting. For the eighth episode, writer Davy Perez was inspired by the Original Series episode "A Private Little War" and the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode "The Siege of AR-558", and director Jeff W. Byrd wanted to bring those influences to the screen. He was also inspired by war films and researched real-life black ops teams. Byrd wanted to immerse the audience through multiple close-ups. He worked closely with Perez, Bush, and Olusanmokun on the details of the episode's war scenes, incorporating suggestions from Bush and Olusanmokun based on their own research into combat medics. Byrd decided to film the climactic fight between M'Benga and Dak'Rah in multiple different ways, and the executive producers chose during editing to use the version where the fight is obscured behind opaque glass.

Dermott Downs was hired to direct the musical episode after directing a similar musical episode for The Flash. He began work two weeks before the normal preparation period began, giving him extra time to plan each musical sequence with choreographer Roberto Campanella. One of Downs's ideas was a zero gravity sequence between Number One and La'an, inspired by the film Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2000), which had to be pared back due to set restrictions. For La'an's big emotional song, Downs conceived a sequence of the character imagining herself in a field with Kirk, which he compared to The Sound of Music (1965). Fisher suggested they film a different imagination sequence in the hotel room from the third episode since Row was filming pick-up shots of that scene around the same time that Downs was working on his episode. Downs was reluctant to make the change, but ultimately felt that the hotel version was "intimate and magical and romantic". The season finale was directed by Maja Vrvilo. Production for the season wrapped on July 1.

Animation
McMahan was involved in the animated portions of the Lower Decks crossover episode, which used the same animation team and style as Lower Decks; independent animation studio Titmouse provides the animation for that series, using a style that reflects the look of "prime time animated comedy" series such as The Simpsons. McMahan also directed the voice actors for the episode. In addition to animated segments featuring the Lower Decks characters, the episode also features a new version of the series' title sequence animated in the style of Lower Decks as well as a final scene where the crew of the Enterprise are animated in the Lower Decks style.

Music
Composer Nami Melumad began work on the season's score by late July 2022, and was recording it with a 55-piece orchestra (up from the 37-piece orchestra used for the first season). Melumad also introduced a choir for the season. The writers were inspired for "Subspace Rhapsody" by the musical episode "Once More, with Feeling" from Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Myers said that was one of the best musical episodes made because it was "really smart and thoughtful. It has big heart." The one thing the writers did not try to copy from that episode was creating the songs themselves; instead, Kay Hanley and Tom Polce wrote 10 original songs for the episode. It also includes a special version of Jeff Russo's main theme for the series. A soundtrack album for the episode was released digitally by Lakeshore Records on August 4, 2023.

Marketing
The series was discussed during the Star Trek Universe panel at San Diego Comic-Con in July 2022, when the crossover with Star Trek: Lower Decks was announced. Kane's casting was announced at another panel for the series at a "Star Trek Day" event on September 8, where a clip from the season was released. The first teaser for the season was released in April 2023, ahead of the series finale of Star Trek: Picard. Commentary on the teaser focused on the return of Wesley's James Kirk, the appearance of Klingons with their updated designs, and on the lack of footage from the Lower Decks crossover episode. The next month, a full trailer was released alongside the key art poster and a clip from Number One's trial. Discussion of the trailer primarily highlighted the first look at the Lower Decks crossover. Rotem Rusak at Nerdist described the trailer as "short and to the point", and said it promised that "we're going to go deep into the crew's adventures" in the second season. Christian Blauvelt at IndieWire agreed that the series was "definitely delivering another character-based season of storytelling", based on the trailer, and he said the Lower Decks crossover looked to be more ambitious than Katee Sackhoff reprising her animated Star Wars role of Bo-Katan Kryze in the live-action series The Mandalorian.

In June 2023, Bush participated in a panel discussion, titled "How Science Fiction Has Impacted Space Exploration and Policy", at the Kennedy Space Center Visitor Complex. The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine writer Morgan Gendel was also on the panel. A video was shown of Mount reading a message from NASA to the series' cast and crew during filming. Soon after that event, Gooding, Navia, Romijn, and Peck promoted the season at MCM Comic Con London. Technology from Canadian company ARHT was used to have the four appear as live "holograms" on the stage in London, despite Gooding and Navia being in New York and Romijn and Peck being in Los Angeles. Another San Diego Comic-Con panel was held for the season in July, but members of the cast were unable to attend because of the 2023 SAG-AFTRA strike. The crossover episode "Those Old Scientists" was shown in full at the panel, and the musical episode "Subspace Rhapsody" was officially announced with a trailer and poster. The latter was inspired by posters for classic Hollywood musical films.

Streaming and broadcast
The season premiered on the streaming service Paramount+ in the United States, United Kingdom, Australia, Latin America, Brazil, France, Italy, Germany, Switzerland, and Austria on June 15, 2023. The rest of the season's 10 episodes were expected to be released weekly until August 17. After the seventh episode, "Those Old Scientists", debuted early at Comic-Con on July 22, Paramount+ announced that it was also being released on the streaming service that same day. The season's remaining episodes were subsequently each moved up a week, bringing the release of the season finale forward to August 10. The season was released in Canada by Bell Media (broadcast on CTV Sci-Fi Channel before streaming on Crave), in New Zealand on TVNZ, in India on Voot, and in other European countries on SkyShowtime (a combination of Paramount+ and the streaming service Peacock). In August 2023, Star Trek content was removed from Crave and the season began streaming on Paramount+ in Canada. It would continue to be broadcast on CTV Sci-Fi and be available on CTV.ca and the CTV app.

Home media
The season was released on DVD, Blu-Ray, and Limited Edition Steelbook formats in the U.S. on December 5, 2023. The release includes over two hours of bonus features, including deleted and alternate scenes, and featurettes on the season's props, costumes, locations, and the Gorn. The Steelbook format includes a mini-poster for "Subspace Rhapsody" as well as character magnets.

Viewership
Whip Media, who track viewership data for the 19 million worldwide users of their TV Time app, ranked Strange New Worlds in the top 10 original streaming series for U.S. viewership each week an episode of the season was released. It was the top ranked series for the week ending August 6. JustWatch, a guide to streaming content with access to data from more than 20 million users around the world, included Strange New Worlds on its list of top 10 streaming series in the U.S. for the weeks ending June 25, July 2, and August 13. Parrot Analytics determines audience "demand expressions" based on various data sources, and the company calculated that Strange New Worlds was the 6th-most in demand U.S. streaming series for the week ending on June 16 (the season premiered on June 15). Parrot said the series was 33.4 times more in demand than the average U.S. streaming series, which was a 53 percent rise from the previous week when the series was the 18th-most in demand. It remained in the top 5 of Parrot's weekly list until the week ending July 14, peaking at third-most in demand.

Nielsen Media Research records streaming viewership on U.S. television screens, and estimated that Strange New Worlds was watched for nearly 1 billion minutes during June 2023. This helped Paramount+ get to one percent of the total streaming television viewership for that month. Viewership for the season was high enough to enter Nielsen's list of the top 10 original streaming programs in the U.S. for each week an episode of the season was released, except for the weeks ending July 2 and 16. Nielsen reported that Paramount+ had the largest increase in viewership for a streaming service during August 2023 and partially attributed this to the season.

Critical response
The review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes reported a 97% approval score with an average rating of 8.45/10 based on 98 reviews. The website's critical consensus reads, "Boldly going where this hallowed franchise has gone before with effervescent execution, Strange New Worlds' superb sophomore season continues to recapture classic Trek with modern verve." Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned a score of 88 out of 100 based on 11 reviews, indicating "universal acclaim".

Accolades
Yetide Badaki and Rebecca Romijn were named honorable mentions for TVLine "Performers of the Week" for the week of June 18, 2023, for their performances in the episode "Ad Astra per Aspera". The site praised Romijn's "subtle yet powerful" performance and Badaki's "otherworldly charm" as big wins for the series despite the episode's small victory. The site also named Babs Olusanmokun as an honorable mention for his performance in "Under the Cloak of War", which they called a "stunning, tour-de-force performance" that added complex new layers to M'Benga, as well as Celia Rose Gooding for her performance in "Subspace Rhapsody", specifically for her "powerhouse vocals". The site added that Gooding "belted out conflicted feelings of determination and insecurity in a showstopping number that we'll probably have on repeat for the foreseeable future".

In July 2023, critics at Vanity Fair, Esquire, and Vulture all included the season on their lists of best series of 2023 so far. At the end of the year, the series was named on best television series lists for 2023 by Den of Geek (2nd), USA Today (5th), Esquire (6th), Paste (13th), TVLine (13th), and Polygon (33rd), as well as by Gizmodo, Nerdist, Slant, and Vanity Fair on unranked lists. Additionally, Scott D. Pierce of The Salt Lake Tribune included the season as "No. 1–A" on his list as part of his first-place entry for Star Trek: Picard. Some episodes were also named on lists of best television episodes for 2023: "Ad Astra per Aspera" by Polygon; "Charades" by /Film (10th), IndieWire (22nd), and Rolling Stone; "Those Old Scientists" by Mashable (16th); and "Subspace Rhapsody" by Salon (7th) and TV Insider.