Talk:1863 Atlantic hurricane season

Was Amanda first uncovered in 1995 rather than 2013?
The article currently states that Amanda was discovered by Chenoweth and Mock in 2013. However, in the meeting notes for the first round of the Atlantic HURDAT reanalysis in January 2000, one of the notes mentions four possible tropical systems that had been uncovered in a 1995 publication by "Rappaport [presumably NHC researcher Edward Rappaport] and Fernandez-Partagas" but had been omitted (due to a presumed oversight) from the slightly-later list that the NHC reanalysis team had been working from, and one of these four is listed as "#214. Northeast Gulf of Mexico - 26 May 1863 - (page 24)", matching Amanda in location and timing. (Those four storms were planned to be reviewed sometime during 2001, due to time constraints for the 2000 reanalysis season, but I haven't found any information to confirm that this was actually done.) Given the physical unlikelihood of two unrelated tropical cyclones being present in the same part of the Gulf of Mexico at the same time (especially with at least one being a category 2 hurricane), does this information indicate that Amanda was actually discovered in 1995 (or earlier), rather than the 2013 discovery currently stated in the article, or would drawing this conclusion violate WP:SYNTH? Whoop whoop pull up Bitching Betty ⚧️ Averted crashes 17:56, 18 November 2021 (UTC)