Talk:BBC Scotland's Hogmanay

Hogmanay Live 2010
The 2010 section desperately needs expanding. Who performed? Who were the presenters? Was it from Glasgow again? Skinsmoke (talk) 06:01, 17 December 2011 (UTC)

Not Live
The 2019 edition causes a problem for this article. It wasn't live. It was called Hogmanay 2019, not Hogmanay Live. It was basically a pre-recorded interview show with Susan Calman that cut to Des for the bells (and missed them). It was awful. But, subjective opinions aside, it does raise objective questions:

1. Clearly the fact that it wasn't Live needs to be noted in some form, given the article is Hogmanay Live 2. Should it even be in this article? Perhaps it should end with "The last Hogmanay Live show was broadcast in 2018, after that it was replaced by a non-live programme. 3. Or should the article be renamed to remove Live from it? 2A02:C7F:125A:FA00:642D:424:4C51:4A37 (talk) 16:32, 1 January 2020 (UTC)

Hogmanay Live 1997-98
I am not conversant enough with the code for tables to do this but this James Taylor site (despite misspelling it as "Hogmany") states that Taylor was musical guest that year: https://www.james-taylor.com/1998/12/1998-news-archive/ GBrady (talk) 19:20, 31 December 2020 (UTC)