Talk:Dragon Ball Z Collectible Card Game

NOTABLE PLAYERS SECTION
Do not put opinion here unless it was widely known (ex. the community contributions of Matthew Low). Do not add yourself to this list, especially if you are not deserving. Do not consider achievements unrelated to consistent play in major events to be worthy of inclusion on the list.


 * Not only that, but I believe the list either needs a major rehaul or just should be completely removed. After looking at entries for more than ten TCG/CCG on Wikipedia, I found only two that had a notable players section (Yu-Gi-Oh! and Vs. System), and the lists had only a handful of players listed, and the descriptions of said players never exceeded a single line. The S 14:06, 14 June 2007 (UTC)

Vandalizing and Useless Edits
Since my revision of this topic, there have been several edits which were so useless that they could only be called vandalism. Among these:

~Solution: Nothing done, as it didn't harm the article. However, it would be unwise for someone to do a similar edit in the future
 * The apparent rearranging of Saga Personality lists, to where Zarbon and/or Dodoria was listed first in every list they appeared.

~Solution: The Wikiuser who made the edit graciously fixed it. Thus, I believe this was not technically vandalism, just an unnecessary edit. I thank thee.
 * Changing the name "Baby" to "Bebi" throughout the article, despite the fact that the name Baby is used on the actual cards, as well as Bebi just being Japanese phonetics for Baby.

~Solution: Reverted this section back to how it was.
 * Un-Wikifying every link in the "Fusion Saga" Personality list, as well as changing some of the names.

Keep in mind that I am not trying to be an elitist or act like I own the article; in retrospect, I welcome any changes which help the article. However, when someone messes with another's hard work just because they don't like it, that hurts Wikipedia in general. Please think before you edit.

Thank you, The S

Card Game Video Game
The DBZ video game template directs to this article. Should the DBZ CCG video game not get its own article? The S 20:00, 19 May 2006 (UTC)

recent anonymous edit dubious
An anonymous user added the last line to the following paragraph (which I have italicized) under Notable Players:


 * Matthew Low, known for running the "LowAlly.dec" for several years of the game, which consisted of either using allies or the card "Earth Spirt Bomb" to finish the opponent. Also wrote Card of the Day reviews for Pojo.com for several years, as well as several publications such as "Scrye" and "IQ Gamer". More notable as a fan favorite than a consistently successful player.

I question whether the line added should be allowed to stand, as it seems rather subjective unless the anonymous editor cares to back it up with a citation to tournament player stats from the period, for example. Bill W. Smith, Jr. 20:47, 8 October 2006 (UTC)

Removed link to Top Tier Gaming
I have removed a link to the Top Tier Gaming website. It is a trading card game website, but is not otherwise directly connected to the Dragon Ball Z CCG and therefore does not belong in the article as an external link. This link has also been added to and subsequently deleted from World of Warcraft Trading Card Game. See External links for guidelines on external links. Dugwiki 18:37, 7 December 2006 (UTC)