Talk:Fist of the North Star/GA1

GA Reassessment
The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the reassessment.''

I am listing this article for GA as it no longer meets the bulk of the GA criteria. The prose is not well-written and the article is in need of copyediting and clean up. There are several lists and tables that should be in prose, or that are unnecessary (cast list - should b in character list), and the article completely violates WP:MOS-AM. Together, these fails criteria 1. Large amounts of this article are unsourced, including most of the Sequels and spinoffs section, the characters section, the fighting styles section, the volume lists/tables, the English editions, etc etc. Of the references that are include, many are lacking basic details, such as publisher, access date, publication date, and language for the Japanese references. The article is also inappropriately using self-published sources and sources that fail WP:RS, including IMDB and Anime World. This fails GA criteria 2.

The layout of the article makes it nearly impossible to find actual details about the article, with the production details all over the place and the reception section, which inappropriately focuses purely on one media format, is buried so deep its easy to miss. This fails criteria 3 (3b and 3a, respectively). The article also has a purely ridiculous number of non-free images. A single image in the infobox is all that is necessary. The rest are purely decoration and need to be removed.

I have left some relevant tags on the article related to some of these issues, and I have left notifications with the relevant projects and primary contributers that the article is under a GAR. If there is no sign of the article being corrected so that it can meet these criteria again, it will be delisted as a GA on November 25, 2008. An additional week will be allowed if there is an active effort seen to correct the article. -- AnmaFinotera  (talk · contribs) 01:48, 19 November 2008 (UTC)


 * Yeah, I just came here and went, "huh?" This can't possibly be a GA-class. It doesn't have almost any sources.  J U M P G U R U   ■ ask ㋐㋜㋗ ■ 17:12, 2 December 2008 (UTC)


 * Wow, forgot about this one for over a month. While some of the work has been done (splitting out the chapters), the bulk of the issues remain and in some areas have gone down instead of up. As such, the article has been delisted. -- AnmaFinotera  (talk · contribs) 05:41, 13 January 2009 (UTC)