Talk:Güira

Merge rationale
The güira and güiro are very similar instruments, derived from the same base, therefore it does not make sense to have two separate articles. Kakofonous (talk) 17:19, 19 February 2008 (UTC)
 * I must respectfully disagree. Yes, they are both Latin-American percussion instruments, played in a similar manner, but they are constructed quite differently, have distinctive sounds, and tend to be used with differing musical traditions. Can most people tell a viola from a violin? They are, in my opinion, considerably more similar than are the güira and güiro, but have individual articles. The same can be said for many other groups of similar musical instruments. Wikipedia has over 30 articles on individual types of drums, many of which differ less than do the güira and güiro. Tim Ross ·talk  11:45, 20 February 2008 (UTC)

Let me tell you something, in Panama, we use the güira according to the illustration given, but we call it GÜIRO. I have never called it in other way. For me, it's the same instrument, made of different materials. It's like having a wooden snare drum as those in the marching bands and having a metal snare drum as in a drum kit. Both are snare drums right? Viola and violin are actually two different instruments, not only in range but also in quality of the sound. Have you ever played a viola or a cello? They are chromatic instruments and must never be compared to an undefined sound percussion instrument! One more thing, I have a music degree and I have been playing professional percussion for a while. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 201.226.49.201 (talk) 03:04, 22 June 2008 (UTC)